SMARTBIOCONTROL - Portefeuille de projets - Plateforme transfrontalière de recherche et de formation pour la promotion du biocontrôle des agents phytopathogènes
Database – Effects of biocontrol agents
This database lists the effects of biocontrol agents (BCAs) from the scientific literature for diverse host-pathogen combinations.
Here is the content of the columns:
- Reference
- Scientific journal
- Volume and pages
- Microorganism used as a biocontrol agent
- Biocontrol agent strain/isolate
- Biomolecule used as a biocontrol agent
- Biomolecule composition
- Commercial product name
- Pathogen
- Pathogen strain/isolate
- Host plant
- Common name of the disease
- Plant variety
- Susceptibility of the host for the pathogen
- Culture conditions
- Parameters studied
- First take-home message
- Second take-home message
- Additional Remark
- Effect of the biocontrol agent on the pathogen/disease
The database can be viewed in the form of a table for which several functions are available:
- Sort the columns by ascending/descending alphabetical order using the arrow placed under the column title;
- Select a portion of the results based on keywords with the “Search:” tab. For example: the name of a host (Strawberry) or the name of a disease (mildew), etc;
- Print and download the results in different formats (with the list of print, Excel, CSV, Copy and PDF buttons).
A bar is available at the bottom of the page to horizontally scroll the window and view all the columns.
| reference | Journal | vol / pages | BCA: microorganism | strain/isolat of the BCA | biomolecule | biomolecule composition | commercial product | pathogen (strain/collection number) | strain / isolats | host plant | disease common name | plant variety | susceptibility (Y/N) | culture condition | parameters studied | Take-home message 1 | Take-home message 2 | remark | control effect on the pathogen/disease (yes/no) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sernaité et al. (2020) | Foods | 9(10) : 1430 | NA | NA | Cinnamon bark (Cinnamomum cassia) extract | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Connell Red | Y | In vitro | Radial colony growth | Cinnamon extract was found effective against apple gray mold | NA | NA | NA |
| Sernaité et al. (2020) | Foods | 9(10) : 1431 | NA | NA | Cinnamon bark (Cinnamomum cassia) extract | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Connell Red | Y | In vivo | Lesion parameter measurement | No efficiency | NA | NA | NA |
| Sernaité et al. (2020) | Foods | 9(10) : 1431 | NA | NA | Pimento fruits (Pimenta dioica) extract | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Connell Red | Y | In vitro | Radial colony growth | Antifungal effect at high concentration | NA | NA | NA |
| Sernaité et al. (2020) | Foods | 9(10) : 1431 | NA | NA | Pimento fruits (Pimenta dioica) extract | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Connell Red | Y | In vivo | Lesion parameter measurement | No efficency | NA | NA | NA |
| Sernaité et al. (2020) | Foods | 9(10) : 1431 | NA | NA | Laurel leaves (Laurus nobilis) extract | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Connell Red | Y | In vitro | Radial colony growth | No antifungal effect until 300 µg/L | NA | NA | NA |
| Sernaité et al. (2020) | Foods | 9(10) : 1431 | NA | NA | Laurel leaves (Laurus nobilis) extract | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Connell Red | Y | In vivo | Lesion parameter measurement | No efficiency | NA | NA | NA |
| Lemos Junior et al. (2020) | Food Microbiology | 89 :103446 | Starmerella bacillaris | CHIAR4 and PECO4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 and TOB62 | Apple | Grey mould | Golden delicious | Y | In vitro and In vivo | Antagonistic activity | Strong antagonistic activity | Possible involvement of benzyl alcohol; known for its antimicrobial action; in biocontrol efficacy | NA | NA |
| Mewa-Ngongang et al. (2019) | Foods | 8(10); 454 | Candida pyralidae | Y1117 isolated from grape must | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Golden delicious | Y | In vitro and in vivo | Spore germination and hyphal growth | 100% inhibition against the germination of B. cinerea | Inhibition of hyphal growth : antagonistic activity | Involvement of yeast Volatil Compounds | NA |
| Mewa-Ngongang et al. (2019) | Foods | 8(10); 454 | Pichia kluyveri | Y1125 isolated from Sclerocarya birrea juice) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Golden delicious | Y | In vitro and in vivo | Spore germination and hyphal growth | 100% inhibition against the germination of B. cinerea | Inhibition of hyphal growth : antagonistic activity | Involvement of yeast Volatil Compounds | NA |
| Carbo et al. (2019) | J Sci Food Agric | 99(11):4969-4976 | Candida sake | Candida sake CPA-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | NA | Y | On fruits | ? | Both film-forming formulations based on potato starch and maltodextrins are efficient against B. cinerea on apple | NA | NA | NA |
| Sansone et al. (2018) | Letters in Applied Microbiology | 66(5):455-461 | Rhodosporidium fluviale (Yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | 527 | Apple | Grey mould | Red delicious | Y | In vivo | Conidial germination on fruits | Preventive effect : 84% of reduction (Rf was added 2h before infection by Bc) | Curative effect : 54% of reduction (Rf was added 2h later infection by Bc) | NA | Y |
| Sansone et al. (2018) | Letters in Applied Microbiology | 66(5):455-461 | Rhodosporidium fluviale (Yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | 528 | Apple | Grey mould | Red delicious | Y | In vivo | Conidial germination on fruits | Preventive effect : 80% of reduction (Rf was added 2h before infection by Bc) | Curative effect : 45% of reduction (Rf was added 2h later infection by Bc) | NA | Y |
| Sansone et al. (2018) | Letters in Applied Microbiology | 66(5):455-461 | Rhodosporidium fluviale (Yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red delicious | Y | In vivo | Plant defense stimulation | Induction of β-1;3-glucanase activity in apple tissue; Probable production of glucanase in the apple wounds | NA | NA | NA |
| Sansone et al. (2018) | Letters in Applied Microbiology | 66(5):455-461 | Rhodosporidium fluviale (Yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red delicious | Y | In vivo | Fungal mode of action | Antifungal effect :Competition for space; and direct interaction between antagonist and pathogen | Antifungal action of cellular components; probably chitin; present in the wall of viable and nonviable yeast cells | NA | Y |
| Zhao and Yin (2018) | Journal of Food Protection | 81 : 186-194 | Pichia guilliermondii ; antagonistic yeast | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red Fuji Apple; Malus pumila var. domestica; | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | Combination of hot air and antagonistic yeast totally inhibited the disease | NA | NA | Y |
| Zhao and Yin (2018) | Journal of Food Protection | 81 : 186-194 | Pichia guilliermondii ; antagonistic yeast | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red Fuji Apple; Malus pumila var. domestica; | Y | In vivo | Fruits quality and ; antioxidative activity and phenolics accumulation | The combined hot air and P. guilliermondii treatments maintained or enhanced the antioxidative enzyme activities and total phenolic content of apple fruit | NA | NA | NA |
| Ballet et al. (2016) | Acta Hortic. | 1144; 105-112 | Candida oleophila; | Strain O | NA | NA | NEXY® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | NA | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | In most of trials; high protective levels were observed with the application of NEXY® (62 to 98% of efficacy in term of disease incidence reduction) | NA | NA | Y |
| Ritpitakphong (2016) | New Phytologist | 1033-1043 | Pseudomonas sp friburgensis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | ? | Y | Laboratory | Disease incidence on fruits (lesions size) | Protective effect on apple against Bc by 44% | NA | NA | Y |
| Ritpitakphong (2016) | New Phytologist | 1033-1043 | Pseudomonas sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | NA | Y | In vitro | Antifungal activity | No direct activity was observed against B. cinerea | NA | NA | N |
| Ruiz-Moyano et al. (2016) | Food Microbiology | 57 : 45-53 | Hanseniaspora opuntiae : Yeast isolated from ficus carica | L479 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT20518 from the Spanish Type Culture Collection | Apple | Grey mould | NA | Y | In vitro and in vivo | Antagonistic activity | Significant reductions in percent infection and lesion size | Reduction of the radial growth of B. cinerea | NA | NA |
| Ruiz-Moyano et al. (2016) | Food Microbiology | 58 : 45-53 | Metschnikowia pulcherrima : Yeast isolated from ficus carica | L672 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT20518 from the Spanish Type Culture Collection | Apple | Grey mould | NA | Y | In vitro and in vivo | Antagonistic activity | Significant reductions in percent infection and lesion size | Reduction of the radial growth of B. cinerea | NA | NA |
| Li et al. (2011) | Int J Food Microbiol | 146(2):151-6 | Rhodotorula mucilaginosa | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Malus domestica Borkh; cv. Fuji | Y | NA | Decay incidence and lesion diameter of gray mold | Its modes of action were based on competition for space and nutrients with pathogens | NA | NA | NA |
| Li et al. (2011) | Int J Food Microbiol | 146(2):151-6 | Rhodotorula mucilaginosa | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Malus domestica Borkh; cv. Fuji | Y | In vitro | Germination and survival of spores | Inhibition | NA | NA | NA |
| Li et al. (2011) | Int J Food Microbiol | 146(2):151-6 | Rhodotorula mucilaginosa | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Malus domestica Borkh; cv. Fuji | Y | Post harvested | Defense-related enzyme activities assays in apple | Inducement of activities of defense-related enzymes such as POD; PPO and inhibition of lipid peroxidation (MDA content) of apples | Enhance the resistance and delay the ripening and senescence of apples | NA | NA |
| Spadaro et al. (2010) | Can J Microbiol | 56(2):128-37 | Metschnikowia pulcherrima (Pitt) M.W. Miller | BIO126 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Golden delicious and Gala | Y | Post harvested | Incidence and severity of the disease | M. pulcherrima grown in YEMS reduced incidence and severity of Botrytis cinerea in Golden delicious apples (51.1% and 70.8%; respectively); and also in 'Gala' apples (58.1% and 50.5%). | Biofungicide | NA | NA |
| S Peighami-Ashnaei et al. (2009) | Commun Agric Appl Biol Sci . | 74(3):843-7 | NA | NA | Essential oil from Syzygium aromaticum | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | NA | Y | In vitro and in vivo | Antifungal activity in vitro and % of disease on apple | High antifungal activity | 50% Reduction of the disease | NA | NA |
| S Peighami-Ashnaei et al. (2009) | Commun Agric Appl Biol Sci . | 74(3):843-7 | NA | NA | Essential oil from Foeniculum vulgare | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | NA | Y | In vitro and in vivo | Antifungal activity in vitro and % of disease on apple | High antifungal activity | 50% Reduction of the disease | NA | NA |
| Fiori et al. (2008) | FEMS Yeast research | Vol.8 (6); p.961-963 | Pichia angusta | Eight isolates | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | NA | Y | Post harvested | ? | Protection against Botrytis cinerea | NA | NA | NA |
| Peighamy-Ashnaei et al. (2008) | Commun Agric Appl Biol Sci. | 73(2):249-55 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | Strains P-5 and P-35 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Golden Delicious | Y | Post harvested | Antagonistic efficacy | After ten days; all of the strains significantly inhibited pathogenicity of B. cinerea on apples | The cultivation medium has a profound effect on biocontrol agents | NA | NA |
| Peighamy-Ashnaei et al. (2008) | Commun Agric Appl Biol Sci. | 73(2):249-55 | Bacillus subtilis | Strains B-3 and B-16 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Golden Delicious | Y | Post harvested | Antagonistic efficacy | After ten days; all of the strains significantly inhibited pathogenicity of B. cinerea on apples | The cultivation medium has a profound effect on biocontrol agents | NA | NA |
| Friel et al. (2007) | MPMI | 20 (4) : pp. 371–379 | Pichia anomala | Strain K | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | NA | Y | Post harvested | Antagonistic efficacy | Decrease in the protection level as a result of glucanase inactivation | Yeast inoculum concentration and physiological stage of the fruit influence dramatically the protection level | NA | Y |
| Calvo et al. (2007) | Int J Food Microbiol | 113(3):251-7 | Bacterium: Rahnella aquatilis | (bSL1strain) isolated from fruit and leaves of apples | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red Delicious | Y | Post harvested; controlled conditions | NA | At 15 degrees C and 90% RH : the reduction of decay severity was nearly 64% At 4 degrees C and 90% RH : the treatment with the bacterium significantly inhibited the development of B. cinerea | At 15 degrees C and 90% RH : no reduction in the incidence of disease. At 4 degrees C and 90% RH : the incidence of disease was reduced by nearly 100% | The bacterium did not produce extracellular antibiotic substances and when the acute toxicity test was performed no mortality; toxicity symptoms or organ alterations on the test animals | NA |
| Tian et al. (2002) | Plant Disease | 86(8):848-853 | Yeast : Trichosporon sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Golden Delicious | Y | Post harvested; controlled atmosphere | Antagonistic efficacy | Composition of controlled atmosphers modifies efficacy | NA | NA | NA |
| Tian et al. (2002) | Plant Disease | 86(8):848-853 | Yeast : Cryptococcus albidus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Golden Delicious | Y | Post harvested; controlled atmosphere | Antagonistic efficacy | NA | NA | NA | NA |
| Nunes et al . (2002) | J Appl Microbiol | 92(2):247-55 | Pantoea agglomerans | CPA-2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Golden Delicious | Y | Post harvested; controlled atmosphere | Antagonistic efficacy | Incidence reduction and reduction of lesion diameter | Efficacy under a wide range of temperature and atmosphere conditions | NA | NA |
| El-Ghaouth et al. (1998) | Phytopathology | 88(4):282-91 | Candida saitoana | Strain 240 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red Delicious | Y | Post harvested | Antagonistic efficacy | Prevention of necrotrophic growth of the pathogen | C. saitoana restricted the proliferation of B. cinerea | Severe cytological injury of B. cinerea hyphae; such as cell wall swelling and protoplasm degeneration | NA |
| El-Ghaouth et al. (1998) | Phytopathology | 88(4):282-91 | Candida saitoana | Strain 240 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red Delicious | Y | Post harvested | Apple defense induction | Stimulate structural defense responses | Formation of papillae and hemispherical protuberances along host cell walls | NA | NA |
| Chen et al. (2020) | Biological Control | 148; 104306 | Lactobacillus plantarum | CM-3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vitro | Fungal growth | L. plantarum CM-3 reduced the mycelial growth of B. cinerea between 55.27% and 79.80% | NA | NA | Y |
| Chen et al. (2020) | Biological Control | 148; 104306 | Lactobacillus plantarum | CM-3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | The incidence of gray mold was reduced by 48.23% ( 1 × 108 CFU /mL) and 75.00% (1 × 109 CFU) | . The concentrations of the antagonist had significant effects on biocontrol effectiveness both in vitro and in vivo. However; cell-free filtrates of the strain failed to provide any protection against B. cinerea. | NA | Y |
| Shen et al. (2019) | Postharvest Biol. And Technol. | 150; 1-8 | Sporidiobolus pararoseus | ZMY-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fragaria ananassa Hongyan (China) | Y | In vitro | Fungal growth | ZYM-1 reduced the mycelial growth of B. cinerea by 70% at 108 and 109 Cfu/ml | NA | NA | Y |
| Shen et al. (2019) | Postharvest Biol. And Technol. | 150; 1-8 | Sporidiobolus pararoseus | ZMY-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fragaria ananassa Hongyan (China) | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | The incidence of gray mold was reduced by 47% ( 1 × 108 CFU /mL) and 50% (1 × 109 CFU) | However; cell-free filtrates of the strain failed to provide any protection against B. | NA | Y |
| Toral et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 1315 | Bacilllus sp. | XT1 CECT 8661 | Lipopeptides | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vitro | Estimation of the antagonisitic test | Inhibition of fungi by lipopeptides | Cinerea. | NA | Y |
| Toral et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 1315 | Bacilllus sp. | XT1 CECT 8661 | Lipopeptides | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vitro | Identification lipoppetides | NA | NA | NA | NA |
| Toral et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 1315 | Bacilllus sp. | XT1 CECT 8661 | Lipopeptides | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vitro | Bioassays on fruits | Activation antioxdidant activity | NA | NA | Y |
| Wei et al. (2018) | Postharvest Biol. And Technol. | 136; 139-144 | NA | NA | tea tree oil and hot air treatment | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Estimation of the antagonisitic test | Inhibition of fungi by single treatment | NA | NA | Y |
| Wei et al. (2018) | Postharvest Biol. And Technol. | 136; 139-144 | NA | NA | tea tree oil and hot air treatment | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Estimation of plant defense stimulaiton | Induction of defense for all tretaments | Better commercial quality of strawberry by the combinason treatment | NA | NA |
| Wei et al. (2018) | Postharvest Biol. And Technol. | 136; 139-144 | NA | NA | tea tree oil and hot air treatment | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Disease severity | Reduction of decay by all treatents | Lowest decay incidence by the combinaison | NA | Y |
| Oro et al. (2018) | Int J Food Microbiology | 265; 18-22 | Wickerhamomyces anomalus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Alba | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Antifungal test of volatils compounds | Volatile organic compounds from this yeasts decreased growth by amount 70% | Strawberry fruit exposed to 6-day-old liquid culture : 89% reduction of disease incidence | Identification of volatil compound : ethyl acetate activity | Y |
| Oro et al. (2018) | Int J Food Microbiology | 265; 18-22 | Metschnikowia pulcherrima | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Alba | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Antifungal test of volatils compounds | Volatile organic compounds from this yeasts decreased growth by amount 70% | Strawberry fruit exposed to 6-day-old liquid culture : 40% reduction of disease incidence | Identification of volatil compound : ethyl acetate activity | Y |
| Oro et al. (2018) | Int J Food Microbiology | 265; 18-22 | Saccharomyces cerevisiae | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Alba | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Antifungal test of volatils compounds | Volatile organic compounds from this yeasts decreased growth by amount 70% | Strawberry fruit exposed to 6-day-old liquid culture : 32% reduction of disease incidence | Identification of volatil compound : ethyl acetate activity | Y |
| Ambrico et Trupo et al. (2017) | Postharvest Biol. And Technol. | 134; 5-10 | NA | NA | Cell free supernatant of Bacillus subtilis ET-1 (a producer strain of Iturin A) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Sabrosa | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Antifungal test | Inhibit B. cinerea at 3.30 and 6.60 mg/L | Bacterial Iturin A production started at the end of the exponential growth phase and a maximum concentration of 422 mg/L was observed after 57h | NA | Y |
| Ambrico et Trupo et al. (2017) | Postharvest Biol. And Technol. | 134; 5-10 | NA | NA | Cell free supernatant of Bacillus subtilis ET-1 (a producer strain of Iturin A) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Sabrosa | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Fungal parameters | CFS treatment has drastically prevented the expansion of the fungal mycelium on the diseased fruits | NA | NA | Y |
| Ambrico et Trupo et al. (2017) | Postharvest Biol. And Technol. | 134; 5-10 | NA | NA | Cell free supernatant of Bacillus subtilis ET-1 (a producer strain of Iturin A) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Sabrosa | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Disease incidence | Significant decrease of disease incidence up to 74.1% on strawberry | NA | NA | Y |
| Lyu et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 8; art 550 | NA | NA | Streptomyces (close to Streptomyces yanglinensis) filtrates - Identified compounds : reveromycins A and B | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Jing Yu (China) | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Antifungal test | Crude extract at 1 and 5 µg/ml inhibited Bc growth | Two compounds were were identified as reveromycins A and B : high antifungal activity against Botrytis cinerea | Reveromycin A from strain 3–10 at 10; 50; and 100 µg/ml showed high efficacy in suppression of strawberry fruit | Y |
| Lyu et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 8; art 550 | NA | NA | Streptomyces (close to Streptomyces yanglinensis) filtrates - Identified compounds : reveromycins A and B | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Jing Yu (China) | Y | In vitro | Spore germination | Inibition spore germination | NA | NA | NA |
| Nechet et al. (2017) | Australasian Plant Pathol | 46; 107-113 | Clonostacys rosea | NA | With used of UV-B radiation | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | NA | Y | Fields | Disease incidence | Reduction of disease incidence with C. rosea treatment | No effet of UV treatments on dissease | No adding effect of UV on C. rosea treatment | Y |
| Nechet et al. (2017) | Australasian Plant Pathol | 46; 107-113 | Clonostacys rosea | NA | With used of UV-B radiation | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | NA | Y | Fields | Plant enzymatic activities | No effect on enzymes | NA | NA | NA |
| Simionato et al. (2017) | Frontiers Microbiology | 8; art 1102 | Pseudomonas aeruginosa extract | LV | Phenazine-1-carboxylic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | NA | Y | In vitro | Antifungal activity | PCA inhibited mycelial growth; where MIC was 25 mg.L | The compounds were extracted with dichloromethane and passed through a chromatographic process. The purity level of PCA was determined by reversed-phase high-performance and confirmed by RMN | Microscopic analysis revealed a reduction in exopolysaccharide (EPS) formation; showing distorted and damaged hyphae of B. cinerea. The results suggested that PCA has a high potential in the control of B. cinerea and inhibition of EPS (important virulence factor) | Y |
| Aqueveque et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 95-100 | NA | NA | Extracts of Stereum species (36 strains from Chile : S. hirsitum and S. rameale) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Camarosa (Chile) | Y | In vitro | Antigunagal test (fungal growth; spore productio) | Inhibition of mycelial growth of B. cinerea showed t by EtOAc-extracts produced by S. hirsutum (Sh134-11; Sh152-11) from 1000 mg/ml ; reaching 67 and 49%; respectively. | Differences in antifungal activities observed in the different strains suggested that the ability to produce bioactive compounds is not homogenously distributed among S. hirsutum and S. rameale | NA | Y |
| Aqueveque et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 95-100 | NA | NA | Extracts of Stereum species (36 strains from Chile : S. hirsitum and S. rameale) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Camarosa (Chile) | Y | On fruits | Disease incidence on fruits | Strawberries treated with 1000 mg/mL of Sh134-11 and Sr25-11 reached 82 and 72% of decay inhibition | Treatments with 2000 mg/mL showed a decay inhibition of 90% approximately | NA | Y |
| Ayduki et al. (2016) | Acta Horticulturae | 1117-29 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungal growth | The Bs aliquot reduced the Bc growth at a rate of 90 | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2016) | J Agricultural Food Chemistry | 64; 5855-5865 | NA | NA | Beta-aminobutyric acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fengxiang (Chine) | NA | In vitro | Spore germination and fungal growth | Inhibition of fungal growth; spore germination at 10 mmol /L and not at 1 mmol/L | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2016) | J Agricultural Food Chemistry | 64; 5855-5865 | NA | NA | Beta-aminobutyric acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fengxiang (Chine) | NA | On fruits | Disease incidence | Treatment with 10−500 mmol /L BABA inhibited the Botrytis cinerea infection | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2016) | J Agricultural Food Chemistry | 64; 5855-5865 | NA | NA | Beta-aminobutyric acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fengxiang (Chine) | NA | On fruits | Plants defense | Activation of the priming defense appeared almost as effective against B. cinerea as inducing direct defense | NA | NA | NA |
| Wang et al. (2016) | J Agricultural Food Chemistry | 64; 5855-5865 | NA | NA | Beta-aminobutyric acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fengxiang (Chine) | NA | On fruits | Sucrose | The primed strawberries maintained higher activities of SS synthesis and SPS and SPP enzymes = higher sucrose; fructose.... | NA | NA | NA |
| Feliziani et al. (2015) | Carbohydrate Polymers | 132 ; 111-117 | Saccharomyces spp. (mixed with laminarin) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Alba and Romina | NA | Treatement in Fields; fruits assays in lab | Disease incidence | In 2013 : reduction on cv. Alba by 73 and on cv. Romina by 63% | NA | NA | Y |
| Feliziani et al. (2015) | Carbohydrate Polymers | 132 ; 111-117 | Polygonum. (mixed with laminarin) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Alba and Romina | NA | Treatement in Fields; fruits assays in lab | Disease incidence | In 2013 : reduction on cv. Alba by 71 and on cv. Romina by 72% | NA | NA | Y |
| Feliziani et al. (2015) | Carbohydrate Polymers | 132 ; 111-117 | NA | NA | Chitosan | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Alba and Romina | NA | Treatement in Fields; fruits assays in lab | Disease incidence | In 2013 : reduction on cv. Alba by 69 and on cv. Romina by 62% | NA | NA | Y |
| Feliziani et al. (2015) | Carbohydrate Polymers | 132 ; 111-117 | NA | NA | BTH | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Alba and Romina | NA | Treatement in Fields; fruits assays in lab | Disease incidence | In 2013 : reduction on cv. Alba by 67 and on cv. Romina by 69% | NA | NA | Y |
| Kim et al. (2015) | Mycobiology | 43; 339-342 | NA | NA | Streptomyces sp. BS062 (culture broth) extracts | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | In vitro | Fungal growth | The culture filtrate of strain BS062 potently inhibited the mycelial growth of B. cinerea. Specifically; after incubation for 3 or 5 days; the growth of B. cinereawas completely inhibited by the 5-fold dilution of the culture filtrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Kim et al. (2015) | Mycobiology | 43; 339-342 | NA | NA | Streptomyces sp. BS062 (culture broth) extracts | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | On fruits | Disease incidence | The efficacy of strain BS062 against strawberry gray mold disease was 58% | NA | NA | Y |
| Mohammadi et al. (2015) | J Food Sci Technol | 52; 7441-7448 | NA | NA | Chitosan (CS) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | In vitro / on fruits | Fungal growth and disease incidence | 73 % inhibition of Bc growth at 0;15% | After 9 days storage approximately 44%reduction of disease incidence on fruits | NA | Y |
| Mohammadi et al. (2015) | J Food Sci Technol | 52; 7441-7448 | NA | NA | Oil of Zataria multiflora (ZEO) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | In vitro / on fruits | Fungal growth and disease incidence | 73 % inhibition of Bc growth at 0;15% | After 9 days storage approximately 24%reduction of disease incidence on fruits | NA | Y |
| Mohammadi et al. (2015) | J Food Sci Technol | 52; 7441-7448 | NA | NA | Oil of Cinnamomum zeylanicum (CEO) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | In vitro / on fruits | Fungal growth and disease incidence | 76 % inhibition of Bc growth at 0;15% | After 9 days storage approximately 30%reduction of disease incidence on fruits | NA | Y |
| Mohammadi et al. (2015) | J Food Sci Technol | 52; 7441-7448 | NA | NA | CS+CEO | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | In vitro / on fruits | Fungal growth and disease incidence | 100 % inhibition of Bc growth at 0;15% | After 9 days storage approximately 50%reduction of disease incidence on fruits | NA | Y |
| Mohammadi et al. (2015) | J Food Sci Technol | 52; 7441-7448 | NA | NA | CS+ZEO | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | In vitro / on fruits | Fungal growth and disease incidence | 100 % inhibition of Bc growth at 0;15% | After 9 days storage approximately 64%reduction of disease incidence on fruits | NA | Y |
| Nguyen et al. (2015) | J Basic Microbiology | 55; 625-634 | NA | NA | Protocatechuic acid (PCA) extracted from Paenibacillus elgii HOA73 | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | In vitro | Fungal growth | PCA displayed potent antifungal activity against B. Cinerea | The minimum inhibitory concentration of PCA to inhibit any visiblemycelial growth of both B. cinerea was 64mg/ml | NA | Y |
| Nguyen et al. (2015) | J Basic Microbiology | 55; 625-634 | NA | NA | Protocatechuic acid (PCA) extracted from Paenibacillus elgii HOA73 | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | On fruits | Disease incidence | Gray mold formation on strawberry fruit was almost (50µg/ml) or completely inhibited (100µg/ml) by these PCA concentrations 7 days following infection | NA | NA | Y |
| Okon Levy et al. (2015) | Plant Pathology | 64; 365-374 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Dorit line 216 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence on strawberry leaves | 88% of disease reduction | Induced resistance assay : the site of BC infection was different to the site of T. harzianum treatment. | NA | Y |
| Okon Levy et al. (2015) | Plant Pathology | 64; 365-374 | Solarization | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Dorit line 216 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence on strawberry leaves | 82% of disease reduction | Induced resistance assay : the site of BC infection was different to the site of T. harzianum treatment. | NA | Y |
| Okon Levy et al. (2015) | Plant Pathology | 64; 365-374 | Trichoderma harzianum + solarization | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Dorit line 216 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence on strawberry leaves | 98% of disease reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Sylla et al. (2015) | Eur J Plant Pathol | 143; 461-471 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens FZB42 (RhizoVital®42) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | NA | Fields | BC incidence in the field / Bc developement during stockage | No effect in fields/ no effect on storage | Effects of treatment are different according to the years... | NA | N |
| Sylla et al. (2015) | Eur J Plant Pathol | 143; 461-471 | Aureobasidium pullulans 14940 and 14491 (BoniProtect®forte) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | NA | Fields | BC incidence in the field / Bc developement during stockage | No effect in fields/ reduction Bc during storage 1 on 2 years | NA | NA | Y |
| Sylla et al. (2015) | Eur J Plant Pathol | 143; 461-471 | Beauveria bassiana ATCC 7404 (Naturalis® ) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | NA | Fields | BC incidence in the field / Bc developement during stockage | No effect in fields/ no effect on storage | NA | NA | N |
| Sylla et al. (2015) | Eur J Plant Pathol | 143; 461-471 | Ba + Ap | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | NA | Fields | BC incidence in the field / Bc developement during stockage | 2012 38% of reduction in the fields/ no effect on storage | NA | NA | Y |
| Sylla et al. (2015) | Eur J Plant Pathol | 143; 461-471 | Ba+Bb | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | NA | Fields | BC incidence in the field / Bc developement during stockage | 2012 45% of reduction in the fields/ no effect on storage | NA | NA | Y |
| Sylla et al. (2015) | Eur J Plant Pathol | 143; 461-471 | Bb+Ap | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | NA | Fields | BC incidence in the field / Bc developement during stockage | 2011 35% reduction in fields; reduction of BC during storage 1 years on 2 | NA | NA | Y |
| Sylla et al. (2015) | Eur J Plant Pathol | 143; 461-471 | Ba+Bb+Ap | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | NA | Fields | BC incidence in the field / Bc developement during stockage | 2011 34% reduction in fields; reduction of BC during storage 1 years on 2 | NA | NA | Y |
| Van Delm et al. (2015) | Journal of Berry Research | 5; 23-28 | Gliocladium catenulatum | J1446 | NA | NA | Verdera B | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | Greenhouse | On fruits with "natural" contamination | Disease reduction of 42% | NA | NA | Y |
| Van Delm et al. (2015) | Journal of Berry Research | 5; 23-28 | Gliocladium catenulatum | J1446 | NA | NA | Verdera B | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | NA | Greenhouse | On fruits with "artificial" contamination | No significant effect | NA | NA | N |
| Zhang et al. (2015) | PlosONE | 140380 | Pseudomonas aerugiosa extracts) | SU8 | Phenazine-1-carboxamide | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fenxiang | Y | In vitro and field control | Antagonistic test | Inhibition of B.cinerea by PCN with a 50% effective concentration (EC50) of 108.12μg/mL | NA | NA | Y |
| Zhang et al. (2015) | PlosONE | 140380 | Pseudomonas aerugiosa extracts) | SU8 | Phenazine-1-carboxamide | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fenxiang | Y | In vitro and field control | On fruits in lab | In vitro control effect of PCN against greymould in strawberry (fruit) reached 75.32 | NA | NA | Y |
| Zhang et al. (2015) | PlosONE | 140380 | Pseudomonas aerugiosa extracts) | SU8 | Phenazine-1-carboxamide | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fenxiang | Y | In vitro and field control | Disease incidence on fruits | Field control effect of PCN against grey mould reached amaximumof 72.31% at a PCN concentration of 700μg/ mL | NA | NA | Y |
| Lopes et al. (2014) | Crop Protection | 63; 103-106 | NA | NA | Chitosan + potassium silicate | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Camaroa ; Oso Grande | Y | Greenhouse pulverized treament before harvest with or not additional dipped | Disease incidence on fruits | Fruits from plants that received the chitosan application showed 64% less area under the rot progress curve (AURPC) than fruits not treated from plants that were not treated with chitosan. | Harvested fruits that were chitosan dipped showed 48% less AURPC than fruits that were not treated at postharvest | NA | Y |
| Silva et al. (2014) | Phytopathology | 104; 1298-1305 | NA | NA | Produced by Streptomyces araujoniae ASBV-1T | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Grande | Y | In vitro / on fruits | Disease incidence on fruits | Ethyl acetate crude extract (0.1 mg ml–1) of ASBV-1T fermentation broth completely inhibited fungus growth in strawberry pseudofruit under storage condition | This complex contained members of the macro-tetralides class (including monactin; dinactin; trinactin; and tetranactin) and the cyclodepsipeptide valinomycin; all of which were active against B. cinerea | NA | Y |
| Wei et al. (2014) | Biological Control | 73; 68-74 | Cryptococcus laurentii (yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Toyonoka (Chine) | Y | Greenhouse experiments | Disease incidence on fruits (on fruits artificial inoclated or with natural decay) | Application of a suspension (log 8.0/ml) of Cryptococcus laurentii prior to harvest led to a reduction in B. cinerea decay of strawberries stored at 4 or 20 C; for 12 or 4 days; respectively | The best inhibition of disease was achieved when fruit sprayedC. laurentiiwith three applications that began 6 days prior to harvest; and the incidence of gray mold and natural decay treated with this method was 21% and 11%; compared with 88% and 62% in the control after storage at 20 C for 4 days | NA | Y |
| Weiss et al. (2014) | Acta Horticulturae | 1017; 238-242 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | NA | NA | Boni Protect forte | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Clery | Y | Field experiments | Disease incidence on fruits and flowers | Its efficacy in the control of B. cinerea could be shown in two years trials in strawberries at two different locations in Germany | NA | NA | Y |
| Costa et al. (2013) | Biological Control | 65; 95-100 | Clonostachys rosea (and influence of UV-B) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Clery | Y | In vitro / lab | Disease incidence on leaves | The highest concentration ofC. rosea(106 conidia/mL ) reduced the incidence and severity by 91% and 98% ofB. cinereaon strawberry leaf discs. | The incidence and severity ofB. cinereaon leaf discs were inversely correlated to presence and sporulation of C. Rosea | NA | Y |
| Ilhan and Karabulut (2013) | Biocontrol | 58; 457-470 | Bacillus megaterium | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Aroma | Y | Laboratory tests and field experiments | In vitro | Inhibition effect on Bc fungal growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Ilhan and Karabulut (2013) | Biocontrol | 58; 457-470 | Bacillus megaterium | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Aroma | Y | Laboratory tests and field experiments | Disease incidence on fruits after harvest | 25 and 32% of protection at the 1st and 2nd years | NA | NA | Y |
| Ilhan and Karabulut (2013) | Biocontrol | 58; 457-470 | Bacillus megaterium | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Aroma | Y | Laboratory tests and field experiments | In vivo during storage | 11 and 42% of protection at the 1st and 2nd years | NA | NA | Y |
| Ilhan and Karabulut (2013) | Biocontrol | 58; 457-470 | Pseudomonas vesicularis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Aroma | Y | Laboratory tests and field experiments | In vitro | Inhibition effect on Bc fungal growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Ilhan and Karabulut (2013) | Biocontrol | 58; 457-470 | Pseudomonas vesicularis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Aroma | Y | Laboratory tests and field experiments | Disease incidence on fruits after harvest | 22 and 18% of protection at the 1st and 2nd years | NA | NA | Y |
| Ilhan and Karabulut (2013) | Biocontrol | 58; 457-470 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Aroma | Y | Laboratory tests and field experiments | In vivo during storage | ONLY 38% of protection at the2nd years | NA | NA | Y |
| Ilhan and Karabulut (2013) | Biocontrol | 58; 457-470 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Aroma | Y | Laboratory tests and field experiments | In vitro | Inhibition effect on Bc fungal growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Ilhan and Karabulut (2013) | Biocontrol | 58; 457-470 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Aroma | Y | Laboratory tests and field experiments | Disease incidence on fruits after harvest | 25 and 14% of protection at the 1st and 2nd years | NA | NA | Y |
| Ilhan and Karabulut (2013) | Biocontrol | 58; 457-470 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Aroma | Y | Laboratory tests and field experiments | In vivo during storage | 17 and 23% of protection at the 1st and 2nd years | NA | NA | Y |
| Romanazzi et al. (2013) | Postharvest Biol Technol | 75; 24-27 | NA | NA | Chitosan; BTH; oligosaccharides... | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Camarosa | Y | On fruits | Disease incidence on fruits | The commercial chitosan formulation was as effective as the practical grade chitosan solutions in the control of gray mold . | The highest disease reduction was obtained with the commercial chitosan formulation; followed by benzothiadiazole; calcium and organic acids | NA | Y |
| Bocek et al. (2012) | Acta Univ. Agric Sulvi Mendel Brunensis | 8; 19-28 | Pythium oligogandrum (mycoparasite) | NA | NA | NA | POLY VERSUM® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Induka | Y | On fruits | Disease incidence on fruits (artificial infection by Bc) | POLY VERSUM® showed a protection rate : no protection in 201) and 48;6 % (2011) of protection | NA | NA | Y |
| Bocek et al. (2012) | Acta Univ. Agric Sulvi Mendel Brunensis | 8; 19-28 | algal extracts | NA | NA | NA | Alginure ® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Induka | Y | On fruits | Disease incidence on fruits (artificial infection by Bc) | Alginure® showed the best and stable results by e 39.6 % (2012) and 57.4 % (2011) of protection | NA | NA | Y |
| Bocek et al. (2012) | Acta Univ. Agric Sulvi Mendel Brunensis | 8; 19-28 | Sulfuric clay | NA | NA | NA | MYCO-SIN®VIN | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Induka | Y | On fruits | Disease incidence on fruits (artificial infection by Bc) | MYCOSIN® showed protection rate at 47;2 % (2012) and 9.9 % (2011) of protection | NA | NA | Y |
| Huang et al. (2012) | Biological Control | 62; 53-63 | Sporidiobolus pararoseus (Yeast cells) | Strain YCXT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Feng Xian N°5 | Y | In vitro | Fungal growth and spore germination | No inhibition of Bc growth | NA | NA | N |
| Huang et al. (2012) | Biological Control | 62; 53-63 | Sporidiobolus pararoseus (Yeast cells) | Strain YCXT3 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | On fruits | Disease incidence on fruits (artificial infection by Bc) | Sp yeast cells on strawberry fruits resulted in reducing the disease incidence and disease severity index. | NA | NA | Y |
| Huang et al. (2012) | Biological Control | 62; 53-63 | Sporidiobolus pararoseus (Yeast cells) | Strain YCXT3 | Test of VOCS produced by the yeast | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Feng Xian N°5 | Y | In vitro | Fungal growth and spore germination | Highly effective in inhibiting both the conidial germination and the mycelial growth of Bc | NA | NA | Y |
| Donmez et al. (2011) | J Animals and Plant Sci | 21; 758-763 | Antagonistic bacteria (Bacillus; Enterobacter; Paenibacillus; Pantoea....) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fern | Y | In vitro | BC growth | In vitro assay : active bacteria : Bacillus megaterium; Paenibacillus polymyxa; B. lentimorbis; B. subtilis; Kurtia sibirica; Enteroacter intermedius; Pantoea agglomerans; B. pumilis; Pseudomonas fluorescens biotype G | NA | NA | Y |
| Donmez et al. (2011) | J Animals and Plant Sci | 21; 758-763 | Antagonistic bacteria (Bacillus; Enterobacter; Paenibacillus; Pantoea....) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Fern | Y | On fruits | Disease incidence | Assays on fruits ; fungal growth on fruitsPaenibacillus polymyxa; B. lentimorbus; B. subtilis; Kurthia sibirica; Pantoea agglomerans; Enterobacter intermedius; Pseudomonas fluorescen biotype G; B. pumilis | NA | NA | Y |
| Huang et al. (2011) | Phytopathology | 101; 859-869 | NA | NA | VOCS produced by Candida intermedia | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Feng Xian N°5 | Y | In vitro | Bc growth ; conidial germination | Inhibition of conidial germination and mycelial growth of B. cinerea by volatiles of C. intermediawas observed | Two compounds; 1;3;5;7-cyclooctatetraene and 3-methyl-1-butanol from C. intermedia were the most abundant | NA | Y |
| Huang et al. (2011) | Phytopathology | 101; 859-869 | NA | NA | VOCS produced by Candida intermedia | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Feng Xian N°5 | Y | In fruits | Disease incidence | Incidence and severity of Botrytis fruit rot of strawberry was significantly (P< 0.01) reduced by exposure of the strawberry fruit to the volatiles from C. intermedia cultures or C. intermedia-infested strawberry fruit | NA | NA | Y |
| Kim and Yun (2011) | Plant Pathol J | 27; 257-265 | NA | NA | Extracts of myxobacteria (Sorangium cellulosum) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In fruits | Disease incidence | Fruits protection : 88 % fludioxoni (ref) and 84% S. cellulosum KYC 3270; 60 % Myxococcus sp. KYC1126 and 50% S. cellulosum KYC3248 | NA | NA | Y |
| Meszka et Bielenin (2011) | Phytopathollogia | 62; 15-23 | NA | NA | Laminarin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Kent; Senga Sengana | Y | Fields | Disease incidence | In 2006 : the effectiveness of laminarin in control of the disease was very good and varied from 68% to 89% depending on the dose . The best results were obtained at higher rates; 1.0 and 2.0 l/ha with the efficacy more than 80% | In 2008 : Under low disease pressure (21%) conditions the efficacy of laminarin was high; about 90%; the same as that of the standard fungicides Signum 33 WG; Switch 62;5 WG and Folpan 80 WG | In 2008 : On the other plantation; where the intensity of grey mould on the non-protected strawberry plants was higher (total per-centage of infected fruits was 44%); efficacy of laminarin was 60.5% after three and 83% after five applications | Y |
| Eccleston et al. (2010) | Sustainability | 2; 3835-3841 | NA | NA | Molecules of Streptomyces isolated from the strawberry soil | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Serva; Parkerand; Kabala (Australia) | Y | In vitro | Fungal growth | 25/39 streptomycetes isolated from strawberry field soils inhibited B. Cinerea growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Eccleston et al. (2010) | Sustainability | 2; 3835-3841 | NA | NA | Molecules of Streptomyces isolated from the strawberry soil | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Serva; Parkerand; Kabala (Australia) | Y | In fruits | Disease incidence | No significant disease reduction was recorded in the greenhouse experiments (soil inoculated with streptoyces strains) or spraying of streptomyces extracts. | NA | NA | N |
| Ge et al. (2010) | Food Chemistry | 120; 490-495 | Rhodotorula glutinis (antagonist yeast) | NA | Combined with chitin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Feng Xian N°5 | Y | In fruits | Disease incidence | The control efficacy of the cell-free filtrate of the chitin-supplement culture media (0.5%) and NYCB were higher than that of cell-free culture filtrates of NYDB in 2 days incubation; with the associated high level of chitinase activity | The application ofR. glutiniscultivated in the culture media of the chitin-supplement (0.5%) induced higherb-1;3-glucanase activity and reduced more MDA content of strawberries compared with that R. glutinis cultivated in the NYDB | NA | Y |
| Xu et al. (2010) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 20; 359-370 | Trichoderma atroviride | NA | NA | NA | Sentinel ® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | Y | On leaves | Leaf necrosis | Protected effect | Combinations of BCAs; whether applied simultaneously or sequentially (48 h apart); did not improve disease control over the most effective BCA within the combination applied alone | NA | Y |
| Xu et al. (2010) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 20; 359-370 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | Serenade ® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | Y | On leaves | Leaf necrosis | No protected effect | Combinations of BCAs; whether applied simultaneously or sequentially (48 h apart); did not improve disease control over the most effective BCA within the combination applied alone | NA | N |
| Xu et al. (2010) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 20; 359-370 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Trianum ® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | Y | On leaves | Leaf necrosis | Protected effect | Combinations of BCAs; whether applied simultaneously or sequentially (48 h apart); did not improve disease control over the most effective BCA within the combination applied alone | NA | Y |
| Zhang et al. (2010) | Int J of Food Microbiol | 141; 122-125 | Rhodotorula glutinis (antagonist yeast) | NA | NA | combined with salicylic acid (100µg/ml) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Feng Xian N°5 | Y | On fruits | Disease indicence | R. glutinisas -alone treatment; and the combined treatment of SA at 100μg/mL with R. glutinis significantly reduced the disease incidence and lesion diameter of gray mold | The combination of R. glutinisand SA was the most effective treatment in controlling the natural spoilage of strawberrie | NA | Y |
| Balode (2009) | AGRIcULtURAL scIences(cRoP scIences; AnIMAL scIences) | 87-90 | (Trihoderma harzianum 8-21 and Trihoderma viride 1-5) (10 kg/ha) | NA | NA | NA | Trihodermin | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Latvia; Senga Sengana | Y | Fields | Disease indicence | No protected effect | NA | NA | N |
| Balode (2009) | AGRIcULtURAL scIences(cRoP scIences; AnIMAL scIences) | 87-90 | Azotobacter chroococcum 23; Polyangium cellulosum 5-t; Polyangium 56; Pseudomonas putida 48-t; Rhizobium meliloti 15; Streptomyces griseoviridis P-t andStreptomyces cellulosae D; Trihoderma harzianum 7-t and Trihoderma viride A-L) (10 kg/ha) | NA | NA | NA | Biomiks | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Latvia; Senga Sengana | Y | Fields | Disease indicence | Strawberry plants treated with BioMikss showed resistance to the grey mould; | NA | NA | Y |
| Card et al. (2009) | Australasian Plant Pathol | 38; 183-192 | Nine BCAs (bacteria and Fungi) were tested | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Camaro (greenhouse) Aptos and Yolo (fields) | Y | Greenhouse; fields (for treatments) | Leaf necrosis and fruits | T. atrovirideLU132; fenhexamid and the mixture of fenhexamid and T. atrovirideLU132 all gave similar reductions in sporulation | The mechanisms of action of T. atrovirideLU132 were postulated to be a combination of competition for sugars; production of non-volatile compounds and possible mycoparasitism | NA | Y |
| Card et al. (2009) | Australasian Plant Pathol | 38; 183-192 | Gliocladium catenumatum | NA | NA | NA | PresTop WP® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Camaro (greenhouse) Aptos and Yolo (fields) | Y | Greenhouse; fields (for treatments) | Leaf necrosis and fruits | No significant protected effect | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2009) | Australasian Plant Pathol | 38; 183-192 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Trichodex ® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Camaro (greenhouse) Aptos and Yolo (fields) | Y | Greenhouse; fields (for treatments) | Leaf necrosis and fruits | No significant protected effect | NA | NA | N |
| Choi et al. (2009) | Plant Pathol J | 25: 165-171 | Acremonium strictum BCP (mycoparasite) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Janghea (Korea) | Y | Greenhouse (treatments) / on fruits | Disease incidence | A. strictum treatment showed statistically similar control efficacy to the fungicide procymidone (500 mg/ml) | 67% of protection by A. strictum a;d 75% by the fungicide | NA | Y |
| Cota et al. (2009) | Biological Control | 50: 222-230 | Clonostachys rosea (yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Camarosa (Brazil) | Y | Fields treatments / flowers and fruits | Disease incidence / yield | With just C. rosea sprays; ANC; Iflower and Ifruit were reduced by 92.01%; 68.48% and 65.33%; respectively; whereas yield was increased by 75.15%. | Max reductions with the combination of C. rosea sprays + fungicide sprays + debris removal (96.62%; 86.54% and 65.33% reductions of ANC; Iflower and Ifruit; respectively) and maximal yield (103.14% increase as compared to the check) | NA | Y |
| Essghaier et al. (2009) | J Applied Microbiol | 106; 833-846 | Halophilic bacteria | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? (Tunisia) | Y | Laboratory / on fruits | Disease incidence | Thirty strains were active against the pathogen and reduced the percentage of fruits infected after 3 days of storage at 20 C; from 50% to 91% | The bacterial cell-free extracts of the speciesB. lichenifor-mis(J24) and B. pumilus(M3-16) were bioactive against B. cinerea | NA | Y |
| Essghaier et al. (2009) | J Applied Microbiol | 106; 833-846 | Halophilic bacteria | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? (Tunisia) | Y | Laboratory / on fruits | In vitro | 6 halophilic isolates out of seven showed inhibitory effect on Botrytis growth; The highest volatile antifungal activities on Bc were obtained by the strains; M3-16 of B. pumilus; M3-23 of B. marismortui and L80 of H. elongata | NA | NA | Y |
| Robinson-Boyer et al . (2009) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 10; 1051-1065 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | SerenadeTM | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | Y | Laboratory and growth chamber | Disease incidence on leaves | Low protection | Combinations of BCAs as mixtures resulted in less control than when the most effective BCA within the combination was applied alone; indicating possible antagonism between the BCAs. | NA | N |
| Robinson-Boyer et al . (2009) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 10; 1051-1065 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | NA | Trianum TM | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | Y | Laboratory and growth chamber | Disease incidence on leaves | High protection | NA | NA | Y |
| Robinson-Boyer et al . (2009) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 10; 1051-1065 | T. atroviride | LC52 | NA | NA | Sentinel ® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | Y | Laboratory and growth chamber | Disease incidence on leaves | High protection | NA | NA | Y |
| Robinson-Boyer et al . (2009) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 10; 1051-1065 | Candida oleophila | NZY1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | Y | Laboratory and growth chamber | Disease incidence on leaves | Low protection | NA | NA | N |
| Robinson-Boyer et al . (2009) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 10; 1051-1065 | T. harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Tricodex TMC | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta | Y | Laboratory and growth chamber | Disease incidence on leaves | Low protection | NA | NA | N |
| Cota et al. (2008) | Biological Control | 46; 515-522 | Four Clonostachys rosea (yeast) isolates | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Camaro (Brazil) | Y | Fields | Disease incidence on flowers and fruits | The applications of C. rosea twice a week provided higher LAC (16.97%); smaller ANC (10.28; 78.22 in the control (water); smaller IFlower (10.02%; 50.55% control); and smaller IFruit (5.95%; 25.10% in control). | Based on this 2-year study; at least two weekly applications of C. rosea are required for a successful gray mold management program. | NA | Y |
| Mamarabadi et al. (2008) | FEMS Microbiol Lett | 285; 101-110 | Clonostachys rosea | IK726 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Senga Senagna (Denmark) | Y | Growth chamber | Fungal growth | Growth of B. cinerea was inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Mamarabadi et al. (2008) | FEMS Microbiol Lett | 285; 101-110 | Clonostachys rosea | IK726 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Senga Senagna (Denmark) | Y | Growth chamber | Plant defense stimulation | In strawberry leaves; the chitinase genes were upregulated 2–12-fold; except one of the endochitinases; whereas no change in expression of the two endoglucanases was measured | NA | NA | NA |
| Wan et al. (2008) | Biological Control | 46; 552-559 | NA | NA | Volatile substances of Streptomyces platensisF-1 | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Feng Xian N°5 | Y | Growth chamber | In vitro /fungal growth | A significant (P< 0.05) suppression of the mycelial growth of B. cinereaby the VS of S. platensis was observed | NA | NA | Y |
| Wan et al. (2008) | Biological Control | 46; 552-559 | NA | NA | Volatile substances of Streptomyces platensisF-1 | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Feng Xian N°5 | Y | Growth chamber | On fruits / disease incidence | S. platensis effectively reduced the incidence of fruit rot of strawberry | NA | NA | Y |
| Batta (2007) | Postharvest Biol and Technol | 43; 143-150 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Variety 43 (Israel) | Y | Growth chamber | On fruits / disease incidence | T. harzianum conidia significantly (P≤0.05) reduced the mean lesion diameters of B. cinerea on strawberry | NA | NA | Y |
| Kim et al. (2007) | J Microbiol Biotechnol | 17; 438-444 | Bacillus lichenformis | N1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Seiko (Korea) | Y | Greenhouse | On fruits / disease incidence | The severity of gray mold on strawberry leaves and flowers was significantly reduced by N1E treatment. | The N1E formulation contained 400 g of corn starch; 50 ml of olive oil; and 50 g of sucrose par a liter of bacterial fermentation | NA | Y |
| Liu et al. (2007) | Int J of Food Microbiol | 119; 223-229 | NA | NA | Aureobasidin A produced by Aureobasidium pullulans R106 | Cyclic depsipeptide antibiotic | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelium growth; spore germination; germ tube elongation; morpology of the fungi | AbA inhibited pathogenic fungi by reducing conidial germination rates; delaying conidial germination initiation; restricting elongation of germ tuber and mycelium; as well as inducing abnormal alternations of morphology of germ tubes and hyphae of the fungi | NA | NA | Y |
| Liu et al. (2007) | Int J of Food Microbiol | 119; 223-229 | NA | NA | Aureobasidin A produced by Aureobasidium pullulans R106 | Cyclic depsipeptide antibiotic | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | On fruits | Disease incidence | AbA at 50 μg/ml was effective in reducing the strawberry gray mold incidence and severity; caused by B. cinere | AbA targets the inositol phosphorylceramide (IPC) synthase; an enzyme essential for fungi but absent from mammals. | NA | Y |
| Zhang et al. (2007) | Biological Control | 40; 287-292 | Rhodotorula glutinis (antagonist yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (PDA medium) | Growth and germination of Bc | R. glutinis signicantly inhibit the growth of B. cinerea. Spore germination of pathogens in PDB was greatly controlled in the presence of living cell suspensions | NA | NA | Y |
| Zhang et al. (2007) | Biological Control | 40; 287-292 | Rhodotorula glutinis (antagonist yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Chunx-ing (China) | Y | On fruits | Disease incidence | The concentrations of antagonist had significant effects on biocontrol effectiveness: | The higher the concentrations of the antagonist; the lower the disease incidence regardless of whether the fruit was stored at 20 °C for 2 days or 4 °C for 7 days | NA | Y |
| Abanda-Nkpwatt et al. (2006) | BioControl | 51; 279-291 | Epiphytic bacteria Pseudomonas lurida Pseudomonas rhizosphaerae Pseudomonas parafulva Bacillus megaterium | NA | Aldehydes extracted | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | NA | NA | IN VITRO | Fungal growth | Increasing volatile concentrations led to the inhibition ofBotrytis cinerea growth with concomitant increase of colony diameters of epiphytic bacteria | The unsaturated aldehydes were found to be the most potent with the minimum effective concentration being 1 ppm | NA | Y |
| Abanda-Nkpwatt et al. (2006) | BioControl | 51; 279-291 | Epiphytic bacteria Pseudomonas lurida Pseudomonas rhizosphaerae Pseudomonas parafulva Bacillus megaterium | NA | Aldehydes extracted | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | ON FRUITS | Disease incidence | Co-application of antagonistic bacteria with natural plant volatiles can enhance the effectiveness of the biocontrol agents agains t B. cinerea. | Especially (E)-2-nonenal showed a stronger inhibitory effect on different strains of the plant pathogenic fungus Botrytis cinerea | NA | Y |
| Francés et al. (2006) | Postharvest Biol and Technol | 39; 299-307 | Pantoea agglomerans (2 strains) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Idea (Spain) | Y | ON FRUITS | Disease incidence | High efficienty to control diseas | A significant inverse relationship was observed between the efficiency of biocontrol and the ED50 of the pathogen on the corresponding host; indicating that the higher the aggressiveness of the pathogen the lower the efficiency of the BCA | NA | Y |
| Hang et al. (2005) | Plant Pathol J | 21; 59-63 | Bacilus subtilis | S1-0210 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vitro | Fungal growth | Inhibition of fungal growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Hang et al. (2005) | Plant Pathol J | 21; 59-63 | Bacillus subtilis | S1-0210 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | On fruits (lab and fields) | Disease incidence | The formulation showed 85 to 89% control efficacies of gray mold incidence on fruits of strawberry in pots ; and 70% of control in field conditions | Pre-application of the isolate before pathogen inoculation is more effective in controlling gray mold than post-application | NA | Y |
| Freeman et al. (2004) | Eur. J Plant Pathol | 110; 361-370 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | TRICHODEX | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Mal'ack (Israel) | Y | Growth chamber and greenhouse | Disease incidence on flowers | High efficacy to control Bc | Grey mould reduction highest whenT-39 was applied at a 2-day interval at 0.4% concentration (2.107 spores/ml) | NA | Y |
| Freeman et al. (2004) | Eur. J Plant Pathol | 110; 361-370 | T. harzianum | T161 | NA | NA | TRICHODEX | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Mal'ack (Israel) | Y | Growth chamber and greenhouse | Disease incidence on flowers | No significant protection | Certain isolates appeared to survive better in a mix than others on leaf sur-faces indicating diversity in survival and viability. | NA | N |
| Freeman et al. (2004) | Eur. J Plant Pathol | 110; 361-370 | T. harzianum | T166 | NA | NA | TRICHODEX | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Mal'ack (Israel) | Y | Growth chamber and greenhouse | Disease incidence on flowers | Efficacy to control Bc | NA | NA | Y |
| Prokkola et al. (2003) | Acta Horticulturae | 626; 169-175 | Trichoderma spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Jonsok (Finlande) | Y | Commercial greenhouse | Disease incidence on fruits | No significant protection | NA | NA | N |
| Prokkola et al. (2003) | Acta Horticulturae | 626; 169-175 | Gliocladium catenulatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Jonsok (Finlande) | Y | Commercial greenhouse | Disease incidence on fruits | No significant protection | NA | NA | N |
| Prokkola et al. (2003) | Acta Horticulturae | 626; 169-175 | NA | NA | Garlic extracts | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Jonsok (Finlande) | Y | Commercial greenhouse | Disease incidence on fruits | No significant protection | NA | NA | N |
| Wszelaki and Mitcham (2003) | Postharvest Biol Technol | 27; 255-264 | Pichia guilliermondii (yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Aromas (USA) | Y | Chamber storage | Disease incidence on fruits | Efficient protection | Fruit treated with the combination of heat; biocontrol; and CA had significantly less decay than those in all of the other treatments | NA | Y |
| Boff et al. (2002) | BioControl | 47; 193-206 | Ulocladium atrum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta (Netherlands) | Y | Field experiments | Disease incidence on fruits | The efficacy of the U. atrum sprays in controlling grey mould was low to moderate; and resulted on average in a reduction of 21% in disease incidence on ripe fruits. | Significant reductions of grey mould in comparison to the control (p≤0.10; on average 41% reduction) were found most frequently when the antagonist was introduced at late flowering or early fruit stages. | NA | Y |
| Boff et al. (2002) | BioControl | 47; 193-206 | Ulocladium atrum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta (Netherlands) | Y | Field experiments | Disease incidence on flowers | U. atrum suppressed Bc sporulation on petals by 15 to 54% (natural infection) | NA | NA | Y |
| Guestsky et al. (2002) | Phytopathology | 92; 976-985 | Pichia guillermondii | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Granada (Israel) | Y | Greenhouse | Bc development on leaves and disease | Scanning electron microscopy revealed significant inhibition of Bc conidial germination in the presence of P guilermondii. Efficient reduction of Bc symptoms on leaves (71%) | P guillermondii competed with Bc for glucose; sucrose; ade-nine; histidine; and folic acid | NA | Y |
| Guestsky et al. (2002) | Phytopathology | 92; 976-985 | Bacillus mycoides | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Granada (Israel) | Y | Greenhouse | Bc development on leaves and disease | B mycoides caused breakage and destruction of conidia; Efficient reduction of Bc symptoms on leaves (86%) | Mixture of Pichia guilermondiiand Bacillus mycoides resulted in additive activity compared with their separate application | NA | Y |
| Guetsky et al. (2002) | Biocontrol Sci Biotechnol | 12; 625-630 | Pichia guilermondii | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Granada (Israel) | Y | Greenhouse | Bc development on leaves and disease | Nutrient availability is one of the factors that govern the efficacy of biocontrol | NA | NA | Y |
| Guetsky et al. (2002) | Biocontrol Sci Biotechnol | 12; 625-630 | Bacillus mycoides | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Granada (Israel) | Y | Greenhouse | Bc development on leaves and disease | Nutrient availability is one of the factors that govern the efficacy of biocontrol | NA | NA | Y |
| Guetsky et al. (2002) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 12; 705-714 | Pichia guilermondii (yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Granada (Israel) | Y | NA | Disease incidence on fruits | Populations and their rate of decline over time after treatment | Biocontrol agents reduced the number of diseased fruits by 50% when applied alone whereas their mixture resulted in a 75% disease reductio | NA | Y |
| Guetsky et al. (2002) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 12; 705-714 | Bacillus mycoides B16(B16 and B17) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Granada (Israel) | Y | NA | Disease incidence on fruits | Populations and their rate of decline over time after treatment | Biocontrol agents reduced the number of diseased fruits by 50% when applied alone whereas their mixture resulted in a 75% disease reductio | NA | Y |
| Guetsky et al. (2002) | Biocontrol Sci and Technol | 12; 705-714 | Bacillus mycoides B17 | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Granada (Israel) | Y | NA | Disease incidence on fruits | Populations and their rate of decline over time after treatment | Biocontrol agents reduced the number of diseased fruits by 50% when applied alone whereas their mixture resulted in a 75% disease reductio | NA | Y |
| Helbig (2002) | BioControl | 47; 85-99 | Cryptococcus albidus (yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona; leaf discs and Elsanta ; field trials | Y | Invitro | Growth =; condiial germination | Conidial germination and germ tube growth of conidia of B. cinereawere inhibited by a cell suspension of the antagonist in aqueous strawberry fruit pulp suspension (1%) after 6 and 24 hours of incubation | NA | NA | Y |
| Helbig (2002) | BioControl | 47; 85-99 | Cryptococcus albidus (yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona; leaf discs and Elsanta ; field trials | Y | On leaf discs | Disesase incidence and conidiophore density on leaves | Application of a cell suspension (1×106 cells/ml) on detached strawberry leaf disks incubated at 10°C reduced incidence and conidiophore density of B. cinerea by 86 and 99%; respectively; but | Effectiveness was reduced at higher temperatures | NA | Y |
| Helbig (2002) | BioControl | 47; 85-99 | Cryptococcus albidus (yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona; leaf discs and Elsanta ; field trials | Y | On fruits | Disease incidence | Treatments with C. albidus during bloom of strawberries reduced incidence of grey mould on ripe strawberry fruits after harvest by 33; 28 and 21% in three years of field trials | The effectiveness of the yeast was increased when formulation substances (alginate; xanthan and cellulose) were added to the cell suspension | NA | Y |
| Berto et al. (2001) | Phytopathology | 91; 1030-1036 | Ulocladium atrum | Strain 385 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta (Belgium) | Y | Laboratory (detached leaves) | Colonisation of leaves and sporulation | Ulocladium atrum(strain 385) consistently reduced Bc sporulation on necrotic fragments of strawberry leaves | The strawberry leaflet colonization by U. atrum 385 was better than by the other U. atrum The colonization of Bc in tissues was lower in the presence of U. atrum 385 than with the two other U. | NA | Y |
| Berto et al. (2001) | Phytopathology | 91; 1030-1036 | Ulocladium atrum | Strain 18558 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta (Belgium) | Y | Laboratory (detached leaves) | Colonisation of leaves and sporulation | Ua 18558 showed lower antago-nistic activities than the reference strain 385 | NA | NA | Y |
| Berto et al. (2001) | Phytopathology | 91; 1030-1036 | Ulocladium atrum | Strain 18559 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta (Belgium) | Y | Laboratory (detached leaves) | Colonisation of leaves and sporulation | Ua 18559 showed lower antago-nistic activities than the reference strain 385 | NA | NA | Y |
| Boff et al . (2001) | BioControl Sci Technol | 11; 613-623 | Ulocladium atrum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta (Netherlands) | Y | Fields experiment and growth chamber | Colonisation of leaves by Ua and Bc | The total density of U . Atrum conidia on green strawberry leaves declined exponentially after application | Leaf colonization by naturally occurring Bc was consistently reduced in leaves treated wuth Ua | NA | Y |
| Guetsky et al. (2001) | Phytopathology | 91; 621-627 | Pichia guilermondii | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Granada (Israel) | Y | Laboratory | Spore germination and lesions formation on leaves | Applied separately; the agents significantly inhibited spore germination; lesion formation; with some variability : BC control efficacy approximately 70% of reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Guetsky et al. (2001) | Phytopathology | 91; 621-627 | Bacillus mycoides | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Granada (Israel) | Y | Laboratory | Spore germination and lesions formation on leaves | Applied separately; the agents significantly inhibited spore germination; lesion formation; with some variability : BC control efficacy approximately 70% of reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Guetsky et al. (2001) | Phytopathology | 91; 621-627 | Combination | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Oso Granada (Israel) | Y | Laboratory | Spore germination and lesions formation on leaves | The mixture of B. mycoides + P. guilermondii suppressed Bc effectively (80 to 99.8% control) under all conditions | Thus; appli-cation of both biocontrol agents resulted in better suppression of Botrytis cinerea; and also reduced the variability of disease control | NA | Y |
| Helbig (2001) | J Phytopathology | 149; 265-273 | Paenibacillus polymyxa | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona and Elsanta (Germany) | Y | Growth chamber and fields experiments | Spore germination and growth of conidia germ tube | Germ tube growth of conidia of Bc was strongly inhibited by the culture suspension of the antagonist but germination rate of conidia was not affected | NA | NA | Y |
| Helbig (2001) | J Phytopathology | 149; 265-273 | Paenibacillus polymyxa | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona and Elsanta (Germany) | Y | Growth chamber and fields experiments | Conidiophores density and lesions formation on leafs | The application of the culture suspension and the washed cells on detached strawberry leaf discs reduced conidiophore density of Bc. | In3-year field trials the effectiveness of P. polymyxa was in a range of 24±36% as compared to the water control | NA | Y |
| Hjeljord et al. (2001) | Phytopathology | 91; 1172-1180 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona (Norway) | NA | Laboratory | In vitro | When coinoculated with Bc ; concentrated inocula of preactivated but ungerminated T. harzianum P1 conidia reduced in vitro germination of the pathogen by ≥87% | NA | NA | Y |
| Hjeljord et al. (2001) | Phytopathology | 91; 1172-1180 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona (Norway) | Y | Greenhouse and field experiment | On detached strawberry flowers | Both quiescent and preactivated conidia significantly reduced latent infection in greenhouse-grown strawberries at a mean temperature of 19°C; whereas only preactivated conidia were effective in the field at a mean temperature of 14°C on the day of treatment application | An antagonistic mechanism based on initiation of germination in sufficiently concentrated inocula suggests that at sub-optimal temperatures the efficacy of Trichoderma antagonists might be improved by conidia activation prior to application | NA | Y |
| Terry and Joyce (2001) | Pest Manag Sci | 56; 989-992 | NA | NA | NA | BTH : acibenzola | Bion® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta and Andana (UK) | Y | Laboratory and glasshouse (for plants growth) | Disease incidence with natural infection | When applied to strawberry plants at 0.25-2.0mg /ml BTH; acibenzolar delayed by about 2 days the development of grey mould disease on harvested strawberry fruit held at 5°C. This delay was equivalent to a 15±20% increase in storage life of the fruit. | NA | NA | ... A delay |
| Guinebretière et al. (2000) | J Food Protec | 63; 386-394 | Candida reukaufii (5L3; 10CL4; 10L2) Candida pulcherima (10L8) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Pajaro (France) | Y | In vitro | Fungal growth and spore germination | Inhition of fungal growth with 10CL4; 10l2; 5L3; 10L8 | NA | NA | Y |
| Guinebretière et al. (2000) | J Food Protec | 63; 386-394 | Candida reukaufii (5L3; 10CL4; 10L2) Candida pulcherima (10L8) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Pajaro (France) | Y | On fruits | Lesion diameter and conidiophore density | C. reukaufii (5L3; 10CL4; 10L2) and C. pulcherima reducing lesion or conidiophore development. | The four antagonists (Candida reukaufii L3; Candida pulcherima10L8 and the both bacteria) effectively colonized fruit wounds and strongly inhibited spore germination of Bc in vitro | NA | Y |
| Guinebretière et al. (2000) | J Food Protec | 63; 386-394 | Enterobacteriaceae (10B1; 5B4) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Pajaro (France) | Y | In vitro | Fungal growth and spore germination | Inhition of fungal growth with 10B1 and 5b4 | NA | NA | Y |
| Guinebretière et al. (2000) | J Food Protec | 63; 386-394 | Enterobacteriaceae (10B1; 5B4) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Pajaro (France) | Y | On fruits | Lesion diameter and conidiophore density | Two Enterobacteriaceae (10B1; 5B4) highly reduced pathogen development | Strain 5B4 was still highly inhibitory when inoculated at 102 CFU/wound. | NA | Y |
| Hjeljord et al. (2000) | Biological Control | 19; 149-160 | Trichoderma | NA | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona (Norway) | Y | Greenhouse | Effect of temperature and nutrient stress on the capacity of Commercial Trichoderma to control Bc on greenhouse growner strawberries | Formulated conidia were also inferior to fresh conidia in capacity to colonize senescent strawberry leaves | These findings may be relevant not only to the lack of disease control shown in the present application but also to the inconsistent performance of these products reported in other trials. | NA | Y |
| Hjeljord et al. (2000) | Biological Control | 19; 149-160 | Trichoderma | NA | NA | NA | Binab TF WP | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona (Norway) | Y | Greenhouse | NA | NA | NA | NA | Y |
| Hjeljord et al. (2000) | Biological Control | 19; 149-160 | Trichoderma | NA | NA | NA | Rootshiled | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona (Norway) | Y | Greenhouse | NA | NA | NA | NA | Y |
| Reddy et al. (2000) | Postharvest Biol and Technol | 20; 39-51 | NA | NA | Chitosan | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Korona (Norway) | Y | Greenhouse | Fruits incidence | The incidence of decay decreased with increased chitosan concentration and increased with storage period and temperature | The second spray of chitosan extended the protective effect against decay of fruit from subsequent picks | NA | Y |
| Moline et al. (1999) | Eur J Plant pathol | 105; 95-101 | BCAS antagonists: Chryseobacterium indologenes; Pseudomonas putida; | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | 8 various cv. (USA) | Y | In vitro | Fungal growth | Most of the 52 bacterial isolates that were obtained from the surface of ‘organically grown’ strawberry fruit and could grow on B. Cinerea wall media in culture showed some ability to inhibit the growth of the fungu | Eleven of the 52 isolates initially recovered; subsequently demonstrated strong antagonism on Bc in vitro and were selected for additional screening tests on strawberry fruit | NA | Y |
| Moline et al. (1999) | Eur J Plant pathol | 105; 95-101 | BCAS antagonists: Chryseobacterium indologenes; Pseudomonas putida; | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | 8 various cv. (USA) | Y | Greenhouse and fields | Disease incidence on fruits | All 11 isolates reduced grey mold rot incidence on fruit in storage | Three of best isolates (Pseudomonas putida Biotype B; Pseudomonas putida Biotype A; Chryseobacterium indologenes strains 50) were tested in limited field trials; and also reduced grey mold rot on fruit under field conditions. | NA | Y |
| Lima et al. (1998) | Biocont Sci and Technol | 8; 257-267 | Cryptoloccus laurentii (LS-11) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Pajaro (Italy) | Y | Laboratory (postharvest tests) | Disease incidence on fruits | No significant and high reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Lima et al. (1998) | Biocont Sci and Technol | 8; 257-267 | Rhodotorula glutinis (LS-28) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Pajaro (Italy) | Y | Laboratory (postharvest tests) | Disease incidence on fruits | R. glutinis (SL-28) showed the highest activity on B. cinerea ; giving 90 % reduction of infection | NA | NA | Y |
| Lima et al. (1997) | Postharvest Biol Technol | 10; 169-178 | Aureobasidiu pullulans | L47 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Pajaro and Chandler (Italy) | Y | Plastic tunnels | Disease incidence on fruits | Efficent protection against BC; more active when applied at the flowering stage. L47 more efficient than vinclozolin | Competition for the nutrienst seem to be the mode of action | NA | Y |
| Lima et al. (1997) | Postharvest Biol Technol | 10; 169-178 | C. oleophila | L66 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Pajaro and Chandler (Italy) | Y | Plastic tunnels | Disease incidence on fruits | Efficent protection against BC; more active when applied at the flowering stage. | NA | NA | Y |
| Walker et al. (1996) | J. Applied Microbiology | 81; 531-537 | Pseudomonas antimicrobia | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta (UK) | Y | Plastics tunnels and laboratory | In vitro : antagonist activity test | Reduction of Bc growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Walker et al. (1996) | J. Applied Microbiology | 81; 531-537 | Pseudomonas antimicrobia | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Elsanta (UK) | Y | Plastics tunnels and laboratory | In vivo : conidial germination on leaf | Bacterial cell filtrates reduced conidial germination of the spores | The results suggest that the conidial germination bioassay as more sensitive than the Petri dish bioassay. | NA | Y |
| Pratella and Mari (1997) | Postharvest Biol and Technol | 3; 49-56 | Trichoderma viride; T. harzianum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | Trichoderma harzianum (strains B11) significant control of artificially inoculated B. cinerea in strawberry (from 80 to 60% ) but proved ineffective against latent infections | NA | NA | Y |
| Pratella and Mari (1997) | Postharvest Biol and Technol | 3; 49-56 | Gliocladium roseum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | No significant effect on the disease severity | NA | NA | N |
| Pratella and Mari (1997) | Postharvest Biol and Technol | 3; 49-56 | Paecilomyces variotii | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | ? | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | No significant effect on the disease severity | NA | NA | N |
| Tronsmo and Denos (1977) | Neth J Pl Path | 83; 449-455 | Trichoderma hamatum | 85 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Cambridge Favourite (UK) | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | T. viride 1 reducing the level of Bc infection by 37% | NA | NA | Y |
| Tronsmo and Denos (1977) | Neth J Pl Path | 83; 449-455 | Trichoderma viride | 1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Cambridge Favourite (UK) | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | T. viride 1 reducing the level of Bc infection by 37% | NA | NA | Y |
| Tronsmo and Denos (1977) | Neth J Pl Path | 83; 449-455 | Trichoderma harzianum | 107 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Strawberry | Grey mould | Cambridge Favourite (UK) | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | T. harzianum 107 reducing the level of Bc infection to that achieved by applications of dichlofluanid (by 42 %) | NA | NA | Y |
| Sansone et al. (2018) | Letters in Applied Microbiology | 66(5):455-461 | Rhodosporidium fluviale (Yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | 527 | Apple | Grey mould | Red delicious | Y | In vivo | Conidial germination on fruits | Preventive effect : 84% of reduction (Rf was added 2h before infection by Bc) | Curative effect : 54% of reduction (Rf was added 2h later infection by Bc) | NA | Y |
| Sansone et al. (2018) | Letters in Applied Microbiology | 66(5):455-461 | Rhodosporidium fluviale (Yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | 528 | Apple | Grey mould | Red delicious | Y | In vivo | Conidial germination on fruits | Preventive effect : 80% of reduction (Rf was added 2h before infection by Bc) | Curative effect : 45% of reduction (Rf was added 2h later infection by Bc) | NA | Y |
| Sansone et al. (2018) | Letters in Applied Microbiology | 66(5):455-461 | Rhodosporidium fluviale (Yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red delicious | Y | In vivo | Plant defense stimulation | Induction of β-1;3-glucanase activity in apple tissue; Probable production of glucanase in the apple wounds | NA | NA | NA |
| Sansone et al. (2018) | Letters in Applied Microbiology | 66(5):455-461 | Rhodosporidium fluviale (Yeast) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red delicious | Y | In vivo | Fungal mode of action | Antifungal effect :Competition for space; and direct interaction between antagonist and pathogen | Antifungal action of cellular components; probably chitin; present in the wall of viable and nonviable yeast cells | NA | Y |
| Zhao and Yin (2018) | Journal of Food Protection | 81 : 186-194 | Pichia guilliermondii ; antagonistic yeast | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red Fuji Apple; Malus pumila var. domestica; | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | Combination of hot air and antagonistic yeast totally inhibited the disease | NA | NA | Y |
| Zhao and Yin (2018) | Journal of Food Protection | 81 : 186-194 | Pichia guilliermondii ; antagonistic yeast | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | Red Fuji Apple; Malus pumila var. domestica; | Y | In vivo | Fruits qualitu and ; antooxidative activity and phenolics accumulation | The combined hot air and P. guilliermondii treatments maintained or enhanced the antioxidative enzyme activities and total phenolic content of apple fruit | NA | NA | NA |
| Ballet et al. (2016) | Acta Hortic. | 1144; 105-112 | Candida oleophila; | Strain O | NA | NA | NEXY® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | NA | Y | In vivo | Disease incidence on fruits | In most of trials; high protective levels were observed with the application of NEXY® (62 to 98% of efficacy in term of disease incidence reduction) | NA | NA | Y |
| Ritpitakphong (2016) | New Phytologist | 1033-1043 | Pseudomonas sp friburgensis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | ? | Y | Laboratory | Disease incidence on fruits (lesions size) | Protective effect on apple against Bc by 44% | NA | NA | Y |
| Ritpitakphong (2016) | New Phytologist | 1033-1043 | Pseudomonas sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Apple | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | No direct activity was observed against B. cinerea | NA | NA | N |
| Renard-Merlier et al. (2007) | Phytochemistry | 68 : 1156-1164 | NA | NA | Laminarin | NA | IODUS 40 (Goemar-Arysta) | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | Protection between50-55%. | Second application of elicitors increased the protection obtained | NA | Y |
| Renard-Merlier et al. (2007) | Phytochemistry | 68 : 1156-1164 | NA | NA | Laminarin | NA | IODUS 40 (Goemar-Arysta) | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Plant ROS metabolism | IODUS induced H2O2 accumulation only on fungal penetration site | NA | NA | NA |
| Renard-Merlier et al. (2007) | Phytochemistry | 68 : 1156-1164 | NA | NA | Salicylic acid | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | Protection between50-55%. | Second application of elicitors increased the protection obtained | NA | Y |
| Renard-Merlier et al. (2007) | Phytochemistry | 68 : 1156-1164 | NA | NA | Salicylic acid | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Plant ROS metabolism | SA induced H2O2 accumulation in the whole cel | NA | NA | NA |
| Randoux et al. (2010) | Phytopathology | 100; 1352-1363 | NA | NA | Acetylatyed oligogalacturonides (OGA-Ac) and non acteylated oligogalacturonides (OGA -unAc) | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | Protection by induced resistance. 57 and 58% of protection in response to OGA-unAC and OGA -AC; respectively | NA | NA | Y |
| Randoux et al. (2010) | Phytopathology | 100; 1352-1363 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Plant defense induction | Induction OXO; POX and LOX in response to the both OGA | Similair H2O2 accumulation by the both fractions at the site of the penetration by the fungi. | NA | NA |
| Randoux et al. (2006) | Phytopathology | 96; 1278-1286 | NA | NA | Ethanolics extract of plant extracts Reynoutria sachalinensis - 3%) | NA | Milsana ® | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | Rate of wheat protection by 85% with 1 application; 100 % of protection with 2 applications | NA | NA | Y |
| Randoux et al. (2006) | Phytopathology | 96; 1278-1286 | NA | NA | Ethanolics extract of plant extracts Reynoutria sachalinensis - 3%) | NA | Milsana ® | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In vitro | Spore germination | Fungistatic effect on spores germination of B. graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | NA | Y |
| Randoux et al. (2006) | Phytopathology | 96; 1278-1286 | NA | NA | Ethanolics extract of plant extracts Reynoutria sachalinensis - 3%) | NA | Milsana ® | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Plant defense induction | Induction plant defense : LOX stimulation and MDA accumulation | NA | NA | NA |
| Rémus-Borel et al. (2005) | Physiological and Molecular Plant Pathology | 66; 108-115. | NA | NA | silicon | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv HY644 (Canada) | NA | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | Induction of resistance by silicon : 5 fold less Bgt infection in SI plant compared to control | NA | NA | Y |
| Rémus-Borel et al. (2005) | Physiological and Molecular Plant Pathology | 66; 108-115. | NA | NA | silicon | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv HY644 (Canada) | NA | In planta . laboratory | Accumulation plant phytoalexins | Induction of phenolic compounds accumulation | SI treated plant : histological studies : intense fluorescence zone and collapse of conidial chains at the zones of infection | NA | NA |
| Tayeh et al. (2014) | Phytopathology | 104; 293-305 | NA | NA | Trehalose | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Study of bgt fungal structure on leaf during infection | Fungal infectious process shown to be stopped at the appressorial germ tube stage in the wheat treated with trehalose | NA | NA | Y |
| Tayeh et al. (2014) | Phytopathology | 104; 293-305 | NA | NA | Trehalose | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Plant defense induction | Trehalose elicites defense in wheat under non-infected conditions | Protection of wheat is associated with two specific defense responses : lox and Chi4C induction | NA | NA |
| Tayeh et al. (2013) | Journal of Plant Physiology | 170; 1620-1629 | NA | NA | SA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | Rate of wheat protection by 50% | SA slow down the evolution of Bgt infection | NA | Y |
| Tayeh et al. (2013) | Journal of Plant Physiology | 170; 1620-1629 | NA | NA | SA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Plant defense induction | Wheat lipid metabolism differentially activated by SA and HSA | NA | NA | Y |
| Tayeh et al. (2013) | Journal of Plant Physiology | 170; 1620-1629 | NA | NA | HSA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | Rate of wheat protection by 95% | Bgt infection evolution is completely impaired in plants treated with HSA | NA | Y |
| Tayeh et al. (2013) | Journal of Plant Physiology | 170; 1620-1629 | NA | NA | HSA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Plant defense induction | Wheat lipid metabolism differentially activated by SA and HSA | HSA induced LOX under non-infected plants HSA induced earlier phospholipase C2 ont plant tissues and specifically induced lipid transfer protein (ltp) | NA | NA |
| Mustafa et al. (2017) | Functionnal Plant Biology | 44; 443-454 | Funneliformis mosseae FR 140 : arbuscular mycorhizal fungi (AMF) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | Systemic resistance : protection against Bgt 78% with F. mosseae. | NA | NA | Y |
| Mustafa et al. (2017) | Functionnal Plant Biology | 44; 443-454 | Funneliformis mosseae FR 140 : arbuscular mycorhizal fungi (AMF) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Study of bgt fungal structure on leaf during infection | The resistance was associated with a significant reduction of B. graminis haustorium formation in epidermal leaf cells of mycorrhizal wheat | NA | NA | Y |
| Mustafa et al. (2017) | Functionnal Plant Biology | 44; 443-454 | Funneliformis mosseae FR 140 : arbuscular mycorhizal fungi (AMF) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Plant defense induction | The upregulation of genes encoding for several defence markers; such as peroxidase; phenylalanine ammonia lyase; chitinase 1 and nonexpressor of pathogenesis-related proteins 1 in mycorrhizal wheat only in the absence of the pathogen | Accumulation of phenolic compounds and H2O2 at B. graminis penetration sites | NA | Y |
| Mustafa et al. (2016) | Mycorrhiza | 26; 685-697 | Funneliformis mosseae FR 140; | NA | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | The highest protection level against B. graminis f. sp. tritici was obtained with F. mosseae (74 %) | The mycorrhizal protective effect was associated with a reduction in the number of conidia with haustorium and with an accumulation of polyphenolic compounds at B. graminis f. sp. tritici infection site | NA | Y |
| Mustafa et al. (2016) | Mycorrhiza | 26; 685-697 | Rhizophagus irregularis (DAOM 197198: lab strains) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | Rate of wheat protection in response to R. irregularis inoculation : 34% | NA | NA | Y |
| Mustafa et al. (2016) | Mycorrhiza | 26; 685-697 | Glomus sp. | NA | NA | NA | Solrize® (Agrauxine) | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Orvantis | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression | Rate of wheat protection in response to SZE inoculaiton : 58 % | NA | NA | Y |
| Vechet et al. (2009) | Crop Protection | 28; 151-154 | NA | NA | Synthetic elicitors : Bion (benzothiadiazole BTH 50%); | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Rep Tchèque) | Y | In fields | Symptoms expression | The disease incidence observed on the susceptible wheat treated with the BTH was very close to the incidence reported on the race-specifi resistance and the partial resistance cultivars. | NA | NA | Y |
| Vechet et al. (2009) | Crop Protection | 28; 151-154 | NA | NA | SA (1mM); glycine betaine (0.3M) | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Rep Tchèque) | Y | In fields | Symptoms expression | No protection fo SA or Glycine betaine stable on the 3 years assays | NA | NA | N |
| Vechet et al. (2009) | Crop Protection | 28; 151-154 | NA | NA | Quercus robur (oak bark) | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Rep Tchèque) | Y | In fields | Symptoms expression | No protection | NA | NA | N |
| Vechet et al. (2009) | Crop Protection | 28; 151-154 | NA | NA | Reynoutria sachalinensis (giant knotweed | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Rep Tchèque) | Y | In fields | Symptoms expression | Over the 3 years were observed following treatments with knotweed 28;5% of disease reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Vechet et al. (2009) | Crop Protection | 28; 151-154 | NA | NA | Curcuma longa (curcuma) | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Rep Tchèque) | Y | In fields | Symptoms expression | Over the 3 years were observed following treatments with ginger (on average 24;5% of disease reduction) | NA | NA | Y |
| Vechet et al. (2009) | Crop Protection | 28; 151-154 | NA | NA | Zingiber officinale (ginger) | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Rep Tchèque) | Y | In fields | Symptoms expression | Over the 3 years were observed following treatments : curcuma (27;1% of disease reduction ) | NA | NA | Y |
| Koitabashi and Tsushima (2007) | JARQ (Japan Agricultural Research Quarterly) | 41: 261-265 | NA | Strain Kyu-W63 | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Minamino Komugi (Japan) | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression on detached leaves | Inhibitory effect of Kyu-W63 strain against wheat powdery mildew on wheat leaves | Kyu-W63 strain suposed to be a Irpex lacteus; which produces 5-pentyl-2-furaldehyde abd 5-(4-pentenyl)-2-furaldehyde | NA | Y |
| De Curtis et al. (2012) | Field Crops Research | 134; 36-46 | Rhodosporidium kratochvilovae | Strain UM350 | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Durum wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Simeto (Italy) | Y | In fields | Symptoms expression | Protection rate : 50% first year and 66 % the second year | Among the integrated treatments; the highest level of disease as well as better levels of grain yield components were supplied by BCAs combined with sulphur or silicate | NA | Y |
| De Curtis et al. (2012) | Field Crops Research | 134; 36-46 | Cryptococcus laurentii | Strain UM108) | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Durum wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Simeto (Italy) | Y | In fields | Symptoms expression | Protection rate : 61% first year and 58 % the second year | NA | NA | Y |
| De Curtis et al. (2012) | Field Crops Research | 134; 36-46 | Aureobasidium pullulans | Strain LS30 | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Durum wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Simeto (Italy) | Y | In fields | Symptoms expression | Protection rate : 42% first year and 51 % the second year | NA | NA | Y |
| Pazarlar et al. (2017) | Functional Plant Biology | 44; 1016-1028 | NA | NA | ozone | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Pamukova-97 (Bgt susceptible cv) | Y | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression / plant response | Ozone was effective to diminishing Bgt invasion in the susceptible cultivar un a short term. | Clear discrepancies between the responses of susceptible and resistance cultivars were found; suggesting that different defences mechanisms were activated in responses to pre-inoculated ozone treatements. | NA | Y |
| Pazarlar et al. (2017) | Functional Plant Biology | 44; 1016-1028 | NA | NA | ozone | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Tahirova-2000 (Bgt resistant cv) | N | In planta . laboratory | Symptoms expression / plant response | The resistant cultivar exhibited a different mode of action against the pathogen; plaisibly related to JA pathway. | NA | NA | Y |
| Cai et al. (2017) | Microbiol Res | 196; 89-94 | Bacillus velezensis | CC09 | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv Zhengmai 9023 | Y | Fields | Symptoms expression | Protection rate : 82 %; superior to the triazolone assay (50% of disease reduction) | NA | NA | Y |
| Goa et al. (2015) | BioMed Research International | ID462645 | Bacillus subtilis | Strain E1R-J | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Xiaoyan (China) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | 24h before Bgt infection; application of fermentation liquid without bacterial cells and crude protein suspension displayed similar protection effects | NA | NA | Y |
| Goa et al. (2015) | BioMed Research International | ID462645 | Bacillus subtilis | Strain E1R-J | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Xiaoyan (China) | Y | Greenhouse | Fungal structure during infection process on leaf | Pulverisation with bacterial suspensions 24h before Bgt infection; the conidial germination and appressorial foramtion were retarded by 43 and 42%; respectively in comparison to water | Bacterial suspensions reduced the number of hautoria and the speed of mycelium growth. | NA | Y |
| Paulert et al. (2010) | Plant Pathology | 59; 634-642 | NA | NA | Ulvans; a polysaccharides from green macroalgae : Ulva fasciata | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Germany) | Y | Laboratory and Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Ulvan (pretreatment) significantkly reduced the symptom severity of the disease by 45%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Paulert et al. (2010) | Plant Pathology | 59; 634-642 | NA | NA | Ulvans; a polysaccharides from green macroalgae : Ulva fasciata | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Germany) | Y | Laboratory and Greenhouse | Plant defense induction | Pretreatment of wheat cells by ulval increased the chitin-elicited oxidative burst about five ou six-fold and that elicited by chitosan about twofold | Mode of action of the Ulvan as a priming inducer in monocotyledonous plants | NA | NA |
| Serfling et al . (2007) | Phytopathology | 97; 523-531 | Endophytic fungi Piriformospora indica | Strain DSM 11827 | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Germany) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | A significant reduction of disease severity was observed for the wheat pre-inoculated by P. indica compared to control condition. | NA | NA | Y |
| Serfling et al . (2007) | Phytopathology | 97; 523-531 | Endophytic fungi Piriformospora indica | Strain DSM 11827 | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Germany) | Y | Greenhouse | Plant defense induction | Increased numbers of sheath layers and hydrogen peroxide concentrations after Bgt attacks suggesting that the root colonization causes indyuction of systemic resistance or priming of the host plant. | NA | NA | Y |
| Serfling et al . (2007) | Phytopathology | 97; 523-531 | Endophytic fungi Piriformospora indica | Strain DSM 11827 | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Bread Wheat | Powdery mildew | Cv. Kanzler (Germany) | Y | Fields | Disease incidence | No significant effect on the disease severity was observed of wheat pre-inoculated with P. indica compared to control | NA | NA | N |
| Sylla et al. (2013) | Crop Protection | 51; 40-47 | Antagonistic BCAs combinaison (fungal and bacterial agents) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | ? | Y | In vivo (detached leaves) + pathogenic infection | Disease incidence | Leaf discs assay with single or multiple strain treatments demonstrated either unaffected or signifcantly improved control of P. aphanis | Hightest inhibition of powdery mildew conidiation (80%) was achieved with combined Bacilllus subtilis and Metharizium anisopliae. In this combination; conidiation was 3.7 times lower than in single treatments with B. subtilis indictaing synergistic interactions between these BCAs. | NA | Y |
| Sylla et al. (2013) | Crop Protection | 51; 40-47 | Antagonistic BCAs combinaison (fungal and bacterial agents) | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | Dual culture between BCA organismes for future combination | Inhibitory effects between fungal and bacterial BCAs were demonstrated in dual culture test on two solid media. | The BCAs used alone or in integration stratgeies neither increased phytophageous mites; or neither influenced predatory mite populations. | NA | Y |
| Pertot et al. (2008) | Crop Protection | 27; 622-631 | Bacillus subtilis QTS 713 | NA | NA | NA | Seranade TM | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Elsanta | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence on fruits | Protection rate : 57% | NA | NA | Y |
| Pertot et al. (2008) | Crop Protection | 27; 622-631 | Ampelomyces quisqualis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Elsanta | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence on fruits | Protection rate : 44% | NA | NA | Y |
| Pertot et al. (2008) | Crop Protection | 27; 622-631 | Trichoderma harzianum T39 (Trichodex®) | NA | NA | NA | Trichodex® | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Elsanta | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence on fruits | Protection rate : 26% | In fields : Interessant treatment combined two fungicide treatments and 4 treatments (T. harzianum T39 + pinolene) - on fruits | NA | Y |
| De Cal et al. (2008) | Biological Control | 47; 104-107 | Penicillium oxilacum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Elsanta; Camarosa; Aguedilla; Ventana (Spain) others fagraia lines under open-greenhouse | Y | Growth chamber and greenhouse nursery | Disease incidence on fruits | Under growth chamber condition; P. oxilacum -treated strawberry cultivars showed a significant reduction of powdery mildew for 3 of the 4 cultivars | P. oxalicum appeared to correctly control the disease on all of strawberry cultivars and lines used in open-field conditions | NA | Y |
| Chen et al. (2012) | African Journal of Microbiol Res | 6; 4017-4022 | Bacillus strain | TS02 | NA | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Toyonoka (China) | Y | Laboratory and field trials | Disease incidence on fruits | The bacteria fermented liquid; pure live bacteria and filtrated bacteria fermented liquid had inhibition effects on strawberry powdery mildew | NA | NA | Y |
| Chen et al. (2012) | African Journal of Microbiol Res | 6; 4017-4022 | Bacillus strain | TS02 | NA | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Toyonoka (China) | Y | Laboratory and field trials | Conidia microscopical observations | Antifungal activity against pathogen | TS02 is a new strain; it has 6 bp differences in the 16S rDNA sequence compared to the strain B. thuringiensis type strain AF290545. | NA | Y |
| Meller Harel et al. (2012) | Plant Soil | 357: 245-257 | NA | NA | Biochar (solid co-product of biomass pyrolysis) | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Yael (Israel) | Y | Growth chamber | Index disease | Reduction of disease on plants growing on soil enriched with 3% of Biochar CW | NA | NA | Y |
| Meller Harel et al. (2012) | Plant Soil | 357: 245-257 | NA | NA | Biochar (solid co-product of biomass pyrolysis) | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Yael (Israel) | Y | Growth chamber | Defense genes expression | All genes were upregulated in leaves of strawberry cultivated with 3% biochar CW (non-infected condition) | NA | NA | Y |
| Meller Harel et al. (2011) | IOBC Conference paper | 71; 47-51 | Trichoderma harzianum T39 () | NA | NA | NA | Trichodex® | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Yael (Israel) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | T39 and Y13 had comparable efficacy (between 30 and 60% inhibition) | NA | NA | Y |
| Meller Harel et al. (2011) | IOBC Conference paper | 71; 47-51 | Yeast Rhodotorula sp. | Y13 | NA | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Yael (Israel) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | T39 and Y13 had comparable efficacy (between 30 and 60% inhibition) | NA | NA | Y |
| Meller Harel et al. (2011) | IOBC Conference paper | 71; 47-51 | Pseudommonas sp. | B52 | NA | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Yael (Israel) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | B52 was the least efficient microorganism (30% inhibitio | NA | NA | Y |
| Meller Harel et al. (2011) | IOBC Conference paper | 71; 47-51 | NA | NA | Protein hydrolysate (SNCB2) | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Yael (Israel) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | After 7 to 14 days of infection; SNCB2 protect the plant against P. aphanis : 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| Meller Harel et al. (2011) | IOBC Conference paper | 71; 47-51 | NA | NA | Bion (BTH) | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Yael (Israel) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | After 7 to 14 days of infection; Bion was the most efficient agent to protect the plant against P. aphanis : 80% | NA | NA | Y |
| Kanto et al. (2009) | Acta Hort. | 842; 359-362 | NA | NA | UV-B radiation | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Akhime; Toyonoka; Sachinoka (Japan) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence on leaves and fruits | Authors demonstrated that UV-B radiation could suppress the powdery mildew on both the leaves and fruits of strawberries | UV-B prevents powdery mildew development by inducing plant disease resistance as one of its modes of action. | NA | Y |
| Pertot et al. (2009) | Acta Hort. | 807; 733-738 | Ampelomyces quisqualis | AQ10 | NA | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Elsanta (Italy) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Rate of protection of fruits by 60% | The biocontrol agents were less effective than the chemicals | NA | Y |
| Pertot et al. (2009) | Acta Hort. | 807; 733-738 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Trichodex® | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Elsanta (Italy) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No significant protection | NA | NA | N |
| Pertot et al. (2009) | Acta Hort. | 807; 733-738 | Bacillus subtilis | QTS 713 | NA | NA | Seranade TM | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Elsanta (Italy) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Rate of protection of fruits by 20% | NA | NA | Y |
| Meszka et Bielenin (2011) | Phytopathollogia | 62; 15-23 | NA | NA | Laminarin | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Elsanta; Marmmolada; Honeye | Y | Field experiment | Disease incidence on leaves | Results showed that laminarin effectively reduced powdery mildew | Laminarin tretaments effectiveness at higher rates used 1.0 and 2.0 l/ha was very good on cv. ‘Senga Sengana’ and reach 90% | NA | Y |
| Pertot et al. (2009) | Acta Hort. | 807; 739-744 | NA | NA | NA | NA | Bion ( 50 % BTH) | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Elsanta (Italy) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | The results confirm that BTH (foliair spraying 1.0 g/l provides protection and indicate that BTH could be used as a substitute for fungicides commonly used to control powdery mildew in strawberry crops. | Both rates of soil-applied BTH (0.1 and 1.0 g /L Bion) provided disease control comparable to that provided by the foliar-applied BTH | NA | Y |
| Nam et al . (2005) | Plant Pathology Journal | 21; 270-274 | NA | NA | Sterilised Milk (5; 10; 20 % in water w/v) | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Mehyang; Akihim (Korea) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence on fruits | Foliar spray application of milk was effective for powdery mildew control; whereas drench application was not | 10% milk show a higher efficacy than other concentrations applied onto strawberry in greenhouse experiments | NA | Y |
| Hukkanen et al. (2007) | Journal of Africultural and Food Chemistry | 55; 1862-1870 | NA | NA | BTH (0.4g/l) | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Jonsok (Finlande) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence on leaf (infected leaves/plant; nb patchs per leaves; size of patchs) | BTH improved the resistance to powdery mildew infection under greenhouse conditions | NA | NA | Y |
| Hukkanen et al. (2007) | Journal of Africultural and Food Chemistry | 55; 1862-1870 | NA | NA | BTH (0.4g/l) | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Jonsok (Finlande) | Y | Greenhouse | Accumulation of plant defense compounds | Benzothiadiazole (BTH) enhanced the accumulation of soluble and cell-wall-bound phenolics in strawberry leaves | The most pronounced change was seen in the levels of ellagitannins; which increased up to 2- to 6-fold 4 days after the BTH application; but persisted only in the inoculated plants. The induction of phenolic metabolism by BTH was also reflected in the fruits | NA | Y |
| Janisiewicz et al. (2006) | Can J Plant Pathol | 1263607 | NA | NA | Irradiation UV C following by a dark period (4h) | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Monterey (USA) | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence on leaf discs | Irradiation for 15 s by UV-C followed by a 4-h dark period resulted in a significant decrease in disease | An increase in irradiation to 60 s followed by 4-h dark period resulted in complete control of the disease in most cases. | NA | Y |
| Janisiewicz et al. (2006) | Can J Plant Pathol | 1263607 | NA | NA | Irradiation UV C following by a dark period (4h) | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Monterey (USA) | Y | Laboratory | Estimation of photosynthesis; yield and fruits quality | UV treatments tested did not affect leaf photosynthesis | The UV-C treatment of plants over 15 weeks increased fruit yield and quality. | NA | Y |
| Angeli et al. (2012) | Biological Control | 63; 348-358 | Ampelomyces quisqualis (24 strains tested) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | ? (Italy) | Y | Laboratory | In vivo nb of conidia produce on plant leaves; | The most aggressive strains reduce the production of conidiophores by up to 50%. | The principal component analysis showed that A. quisqualis strains with similar levels of mycoparasitic activity originated from the same host species and shared an identical ITS rDNA sequence. | NA | Y |
| Angeli et al. (2012) | Biological Control | 63; 348-358 | Ampelomyces quisqualis (24 strains tested) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Podosphaera aphanis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | ? (Italy) | Y | Laboratory | Intra-hyphal production of A. quisqualis in Pa mycelium; production of CWDES by the mycoparatits | Individual strains differed significantly in enlargement of the colonization area by intra-hyphal formation of pycnidia within powdery mildew colonies and in inhibition of host conidiation | Authors found a positive correlation between mycoparasitic activity and chitobiases and proteases but not glucanases | NA | NA |
| Miller et al. (2004) | Biocontrol Sci Technology | 14; 215-220 | Lecanicillium lecanii (fungal parasite) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sphaerotheca macularis | NA | Strawberry | Powdery mildew | Gaviota and Pacific (USA) | Y | Fields (3 various locations) | Disease severity and microscopic observations of the leaf (colonisation of plant sand fungi by L. lecani...) | The L. lecanii treatments reduced powdery mildew at all locations for some; but not all the fruits of the season | Treatmets were instable; cause they appeardd t inefficient during different years --> humidity; Moreover re-application would be necessary to replace spores washed and weathered from the strawberry | NA | Y |
| Segarra G. et al. (2009) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 91 (3); 683-689 | NA | NA | Aerated composr tea | NA | NA | Erysiphe polygoni | NA | Tomato (lycopersicon esculentum cv | Powdery mildew | Roma | NA | Greenhouse growth chamber | Disease evaluation( number infected leaves on number of total leaves. Microbial composition of tomato leaves.Enzymatic activities peroxidase; chitinase | Reduction of infected leaves in treated plant when composte used as preventive treatment. No differences in enzyme activities | NA | NA | Y |
| Bardin et al. (2008) | Biological control | 46; 476-483 | NA | NA | NA | NA | Mycotal | Oidium neolycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | Raissa | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Mycotal has no effect; | NA | NA | N |
| Bardin et al. (2008) | Biological control | 46; 476-483 | NA | NA | NA | NA | Milsana | Oidium neolycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | Raissa | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Milsana reduce drastically disease | NA | NA | Y |
| Jacob et al. (2007) | IOBC bulletin | 30; 329-332 | Bacteria | B69 | NA | NA | NA | Oidium lycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Appressoria formation; conidia production ; disease severity | Reduction by 55; 50; 39% respectively | NA | NA | Y |
| Jacob et al. (2007) | IOBC bulletin | 30; 329-332 | Bacteria | B71 | NA | NA | NA | Oidium lycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Appressoria formation; conidia production ; disease severity | Reduction by 35; 57; 52% respectively | NA | NA | Y |
| Jacob et al. (2007) | IOBC bulletin | 30; 329-332 | Yeast | Y2 | NA | NA | NA | Oidium lycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Appressoria formation; conidia production ; disease severity | Reduction by 31; 56; 53% respectively | NA | NA | Y |
| Jacob et al. (2007) | IOBC bulletin | 30; 329-332 | Yeast | Y13 | NA | NA | NA | Oidium lycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Appressoria formation; conidia production ; disease severity | Reduction by40; 28; 82% respectively | NA | NA | Y |
| Jacob et al. (2007) | IOBC bulletin | 30; 329-332 | Yeast | Y16 | NA | NA | NA | Oidium lycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Appressoria formation; conidia production ; disease severity | Reduction by 66; 66; 43% respectively | NA | NA | Y |
| Jacob et al. (2007) | IOBC bulletin | 30; 329-332 | Yeast | Y89 | NA | NA | NA | Oidium lycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Appressoria formation; conidia production ; disease severity | Reduction by 23; 31; 37% respectively | NA | NA | NA |
| Yamamoto et al. (2015) | Pest managment science | 71; 722-727 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | S13-3 | NA | NA | NA | Oidium neolycopersici | NA | Tomato (Solanum lycopersicon | Powdery mildew | Momotaro | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | 50% reduction of disease severity | NA | NA | Y |
| KO et al. (2003) | Journal of phytopathology | 151; 144-148 | NA | NA | Sunflower oil | NA | NA | Oidium neolycopersici | NA | Tomato (Solanum lycopersicon | Powdery mildew | Farmers | NA | Greenhouse | Estimation of infected leaf area | 72% reduction disease severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Dafermos et al . (2012) | Plant disease | 96; 1506-1512 | NA | NA | Milsana | NA | NA | Oidium neolycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | Elpida F1 Bison F1 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity; %leaf area | Reduction disease severity 40% (Milsana; foiar application) | NA | NA | Y |
| Dafermos et al . (2012) | Plant disease | 96; 1506-1512 | NA | NA | Chitin foliar treatment | NA | NA | Oidium neolycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | Elpida F1 Bison F1 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity; %leaf area | Reduction disease severity 15% (chitosan) | NA | NA | Y |
| Dafermos et al . (2012) | Plant disease | 96; 1506-1512 | NA | NA | Chitin soil amendement | NA | NA | Oidium neolycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | Elpida F1 Bison F1 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity; %leaf area | Reduction disease severity 15% (chitin soilamendment) | NA | NA | Y |
| Konstantinidou-doltsinis (2006) | Biocontrol | 51; 375-392 | NA | NA | Milsana | NA | NA | Leveillula taurica | NA | Tomato | NA | Menthos F1 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Disease reduction from 42to 64% | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2004) | IOBC bulletin | 27(8); 329-331 | Ampelomyces quisqualis (Q-fect WP | 94013 | NA | NA | NA | Golovinocemyces cichoracearum | NA | Tomato | NA | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of 90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Nonomura et al. (2009) | Plant Science | 176; 31-37 | NA | NA | Trichome exudates of lycopersicon | NA | NA | Oidium neolycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | NA | Conidia germination | 100% inhibition | NA | NA | Y |
| Abada et al. (2018) | Journal of Biotechnology and Bioingeneering | 2; 25-35 | Trichoderma | NA | NA | NA | NA | Oidium lycopersici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Field | Disease severity | 80% protection | NA | NA | Y |
| Sultan M (2012) | PhD thesis Bonn University | NA | Bacillus subtilis | FZB24 | NA | NA | NA | Oidium lycoprsici | NA | Tomato | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Devlopment of fungi on leaf | 50% inhibition of germinetion; appressoria and haustoria formation | NA | NA | Y |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Cladosporium spp. | ER3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Cladosporium spp. | YNA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Pseudomonas marginalis | GA8-PS4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Trichoderma harzianum | C52 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Trichoderma longipile | 6sr4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Ulocladium spp. | U13 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | Reduction by 94% | NA | Reduction in one of two experiments | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Ulocladium spp. | U16 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Epicoccum sp. | E21 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Bacillus subtilis | PT69 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Paenibacillus polymyxa | 18-25 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified white yeast | PK10 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified pink yeasts | Y44 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified pink yeasts | Y46 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified pink yeasts | Y48 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified fluorescent Pseudomonas spp. | PF13 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | Reduced by 76% and 96%. | NA | Reduction in all experiments | Y |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified fluorescent Pseudomonas spp. | PF14 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | Reduced from 60% to 96%. | NA | Reduction in all experiments | Y |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified fluorescent Pseudomonas spp. | PF15 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | Reduced from 60% to 96%. | NA | Reduction in all experiments | Y |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | LC8 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | Reduced from 60% to 96%. | NA | Reduction in all experiments | Y |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Gliocladium catenulatum | NA | NA | NA | Prestop | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Fiddaman et al. (2000) | Annals of Applied Biology | 137:223—235 | Bacillus spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | 92/B8 | Lettuce | Grey mould | NA | NA | Leaf disc bioassays | Leaf tissue discoloration | Reduced over 90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiddaman et al. (2000) | Annals of Applied Biology | 137:223—235 | Pseudomonas spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | 92/B8 | Lettuce | Grey mould | NA | NA | Leaf disc bioassays | Leaf tissue discoloration | Reduced over 90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Charmy | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severity (McKinney index) | Reduced by 68;4% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | LM 1307 | N | Greenhouse | Disease severity (McKinney index) | Reduced by 35.8% | The combination of LM 1307 plant varity and Contans®WG showed the best results in pathogen suppresion | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Ninja | Y /N | Greenhouse | Disease severity (McKinney index) | Reduced by 46.7% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Charmy | Y | Greenhouse | Healthy plants | Improved for 66.7% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | LM 1307 | N | Greenhouse | Healthy plants | Improved for 58.4% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Ninja | Y /N | Greenhouse | Healthy plants | Improved for 66.6% | NA | NA | Y |
| Lolas et al. (2005) | Acta Horticulture | 697 ISHS 2005 | Trichoderma virens | Sherwood | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Butterhead lettuce | Grey rot | Esmeralda | NA | Greenhouse (hydroponic float system) | Disease incidence | Significant lower incidence (P<0.01) | NA | Should be used as a preventive biocontrol agent | Y |
| McQuilken et al. (1994) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 10: 20-26 | Filamentous fungi and yeasts; Penicillium chrysogenurn; P. brevicompactum; Mucor hiemalis and Trichoderma spp.; Debaryomyces hansenii | NA | NA | Compost extract (containing BCA:microorganism) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BCI3 | Lettuce | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Conidial germination | Significant (P < 0.05) reduction | NA | Not better reduction than in treatments with iprodion | Y |
| McQuilken et al. (1994) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 10: 20-26 | Filamentous fungi and yeasts; Penicillium chrysogenurn; P. brevicompactum; Mucor hiemalis and Trichoderma spp.; Debaryomyces hansenii | NA | NA | Compost extract (containing BCA:microorganism) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BCI3 | Lettuce | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth | Significant (P < 0.05) reduction | NA | Not better reduction than in treatments with iprodion | Y |
| McQuilken et al. (1994) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 10: 20-26 | Filamentous fungi and yeasts; Penicillium chrysogenurn; P. brevicompactum; Mucor hiemalis and Trichoderma spp.; Debaryomyces hansenii | NA | NA | Compost extract (containing BCA:microorganism) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BCI3 | Lettuce | Grey mould | Hudson | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty (severty index) | Significant (P < 0.002) reduction by 22.8 | NA | NA | Y |
| McQuilken et al. (1994) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 10: 20-26 | Filamentous fungi and yeasts; Penicillium chrysogenurn; P. brevicompactum; Mucor hiemalis and Trichoderma spp.; Debaryomyces hansenii | NA | NA | Compost extract (containing BCA:microorganism) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BCI3 | Lettuce | Grey mould | Hudson | NA | Glasshouse | Number of marketable plants | Significant (P < 0.001) increase by 37.2% | NA | NA | Y |
| McQuilken et al. (1994) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 10: 20-26 | Filamentous fungi and yeasts; Penicillium chrysogenurn; P. brevicompactum; Mucor hiemalis and Trichoderma spp.; Debaryomyces hansenii | NA | NA | Compost extract (containing BCA:microorganism) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BCI3 | Lettuce | Grey mould | Hudson | NA | Glasshouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Growth rate unafected with Y4ᴬ treatments of 10 µg ml¯¹ Y4 but was enhanced on with 100µg and 1000µg ml¯¹ . | NA | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Little Gem | NA | Detached leaf bioassays | Infected leaf area | Y3ᴬ reduced disease by 50%; Y4ᴬ to 90% and Y20ᴬ by 85% | NA | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Little Gem | NA | Glasshouse | Overall disease assessment | Y4ᴬ reduced disease by approx. 70% | NA | Inoculation was carried out by placing two barley seeds infected with R solani at the base of the growing plant adjacent to the stem and then spraying each plant with B. cincrea spore suspension. | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Berlo | NA | Detached leaf bioassays | Infected leaf area | Y3ᴬ reduced infection by 58%; Y4ᴬ by 72%; Y20ᴬ by 69%. | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ each reduced disease levels by 5-14 % | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Berlo | NA | Glasshouse | Overall disease assessment | Y4ᴬ reduced disease by approx. 50% | NA | Inoculation was carried out by placing two barley seeds infected with R solani at the base of the growing plant adjacent to the stem and then spraying each plant with B. cincrea spore suspension. | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Norden | NA | Detached leaf bioassays | Infected leaf area | Y3ᴬ reduced infection by 58%; Y4ᴬ by 72%; Y20ᴬ by 69%. | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ each reduced disease levels by 5-14 % | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Novita | NA | Detached leaf bioassays | Infected leaf area | Y3ᴬ reduced infection by 58%; Y4ᴬ by 72%; Y20ᴬ by 69%. | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ each reduced disease levels by 5-14 % | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Patricia | NA | Detached leaf assays | Infected leaf area | Y3ᴬ reduced infection by 58%; Y4ᴬ by 72%; Y20ᴬ by 69%. | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ each reduced disease levels by 5-14 % | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Patricia | NA | Glasshouse | Overall disease assessment | Y4ᴬ reduced disease by approx. 70% | NA | Inoculation was carried out by placing two barley seeds infected with R solani at the base of the growing plant adjacent to the stem and then spraying each plant with B. cincrea spore suspension. | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 96% | NA | Once infection had been established; none of the antagonists tended to cause a large reduction in severity of disease or sporulation on stem segments. | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | Reduction by more than 75% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus luteus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 50% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus luteus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 39% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus albidus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 37% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus albidus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 30% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus laurentii var. flavescens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus laurentii var. flavescens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 40% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium catenulatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 97% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium catenulatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 89% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium catenulatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | Reduction by more than 75% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium roseum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 78% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium roseum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 78% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium roseum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | Reduction by more than 75% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma hamatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 51% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma hamatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 34% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma viride | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 41% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma viride | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 16% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma viride | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Chaetomium globosum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 68% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Chaetomium globosum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 66% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Ulocladium atrum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 75% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Ulocladium atrum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 68% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus pumilus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 15% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus pumilus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 15% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus pumilus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 17% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Pseudomonas sp. | Isolate 1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 78% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Pseudomonas sp. | Isolate 1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 55% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Pseudomonas sp. | Isolate 2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Pseudomonas sp. | Isolate 2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 57% | NA | NA | Y |
| Altomare et al. (2000) | Journal of Natural Products | 63: 1131-1135 | Fusarium semitectum | NA | Fusapyrone and deoxyfusapyrone | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ITEM 966 | Tomato | NA | NA | NA | Disk diffusion assays | Antifungal activity | Fusapyrone was more active causing 29.3 mm inhibition zone while deoxyfusapyrone caused 13.5 mm; in comparation with antifungal antibiotic nystatine of 31.2 mmdeoxyfusapyrone | Fusapyrone was mostly fungicidal at 5 µg/disk against B. cinerea | NA | Y |
| Altomare et al. (2000) | Journal of Natural Products | 63: 1131-1135 | Fusarium semitectum | NA | Fusapyrone and deoxyfusapyrone | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ITEM 966 | Tomato | NA | NA | NA | Leaf puncture assay | Disease symptoms | Only fusapyrone was active | Fusapyrone caused severe symptoms on tomato leaves at 5 × 10-⁴and 10-⁴ M | NA | N |
| Altomare et al. (2000) | Journal of Natural Products | 63: 1131-1135 | Fusarium semitectum | NA | Fusapyrone and deoxyfusapyrone | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ITEM 966 | Tomato | NA | NA | NA | Cutting assay | Disease symptoms | No symptoms were observed on tomato cuttings treated with 10-³ M | Symptom of phytotoxicity (chlorosis of leaf veins) to cuttings treated with fusapyrone was detected at the concentration of 10-⁵ M; and complete wilting (leaves and stems) was observed at 10-⁴ | NA | N |
| Altomare et al. (2000) | Journal of Natural Products | 63: 1131-1135 | Fusarium semitectum | NA | Fusapyrone and deoxyfusapyrone | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ITEM 966 | Tomato | NA | NA | NA | Seedlings assay | Disease symptoms | No phytotoxic activity in the tomato seedling germination assay | The doses of 10-⁴ and 10-⁵ M; deoxyfusapyrone stimulated the elongation of rootlets; the values being more than 120% of the control | NA | N |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Pseudomonas putida | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus cereus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Enterobacter agglomerans | B8 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 5.2 mm of diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus subtilis | AGS-K | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 8.4 mm of diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus subtilis | AGS-4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 8.0 mm of diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus subtilis | BACT-O | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 6.0 mm of diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus subtilis | BACT-10 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 22.8 mm of diameter | Significantly increased the total fruit yield | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus subtilis | BACT-10 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | Trust | NA | In vivo | Lesion length | Significantly decreased lesion length | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Rhodosporium diobovatum | S33 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 5.4 mm of diameter | NA | Antibiosis may be one of the mechanism responsible for control of this disease | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Rhodosporium diobovatum | S33 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | Trust | NA | In vivo | Lesion length | Significantly decreased lesion length | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | RootShield® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | No effect | NA | The survival of T. harzianum on stems is a key factor for achieving effective control. The poor activity often shown by T. harzianum against B. cinerea under severe disease pressure was due to its poor survival on leaf surface | N |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | RootShield® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | Trust | NA | In vivo | Lesion length | Significantly decreased lesion length | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Gliocladium virens | NA | NA | NA | SoilGard® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Gliocladium virens | NA | NA | NA | SoilGard® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | Trust | NA | In vivo | Lesion length | Significantly decreased lesion length | NA | NA | Y |
| Audenaert et al. (2002) | The American Phytopathological Society | 15: 1147–1156 | Pseudomonas aeruginosa | 7NSK2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | R16 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Greenhouse | Lesion spreading | Reduced lesion spreading and induced resistance to B. cinerea | Pyocyanin and pyochelin; rather than salicylic acid; are the determinants for induced resistance | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Fungitoxicity assay | Decreased mycelium growth rate during the exponential phase by 0.33 cm/day. | Maximalmycelium growth reached 7 days after incubation (compared to 6 days in presence of methanole). | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (liquid medium) | Fungitoxicity assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Production of p-nitrophenylbutyrate esterases | Induced | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Production of laccases | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Membrane leakage | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | Roma | NA | In vivo | Leason area | Reduced by 2.2 mm² | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxicity assay | Decreased mycelium growth rate during the exponential phase by 0.76 cm/day. | Maximal mycelium growth reached 9 days after incubation (compared to 6 days in presence of methanole ) | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (liquid medium) | Fungitoxicity assay | Inhibition by 80.8% in minimum medium and 36% in malt-yeast extract medium. | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Production of p-nitrophenylbutyrate esterases and laccases | Induced | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Production of laccases | Induced | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Membrane leakage | Induced 3 times | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | Roma | NA | In vivo | Leason area | Reduced by 4.9 mm² | NA | NA | Y |
| Meziane et al.; . (2005) | Molecular Plant Pathology | 6: 177–185 | Pseudomonas putida | WCS358 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | R16 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassays for induced resistance | Lesions spreading | Significant reduction | Lipopolysaccharides and pseudobactin are responsible for the ISR | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2006) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Sciences; Ghent University | 71: 897-908 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Reduction of the mycelial radial growth by 76% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2006) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Sciences; Ghent University | 71: 897-908 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Nikita | NA | Greenhouse | Symptom severity | 4 kg/ha of trichodex after the fruit setting controlled with very effectiveness the gray mould | Trichodex at 400g/hL gave the best results; decreasing the disease over 50% compared to untreated control and over 70% compared to chemical control. | NA | Y |
| Cho et al. (2006) | Pest Management Science | 62:414–418 | NA | NA | Dehydro-α-lapachone (isolated from Catalpa ovata stems) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Complete mycelial inhibition at doses above 0.41mg/l | NA | NA | Y |
| Cho et al. (2006) | Pest Management Science | 62:414–418 | NA | NA | Dehydro-α-lapachone (isolated from Catalpa ovata stems) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vivo | Antifungal activity | Inhibition by 63% with 500mg/l and 31% with 250mg/l | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Pseudomonas sp. | CHAO-Rif | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | Reduction of approx. 6mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Pseudomonas sp. | CHAO-Rif | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | Reduction of approx. 6mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Pseudomonas sp. | CHAO-Rif | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxic activity | Caused inhibition zone of 6mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Cupriavidus campinensis | OxB | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | Reduction of approx. 6mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Cupriavidus campinensis | OxB | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | Reduction of approx. 6mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Cupriavidus campinensis | OxB | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxic activity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Bacillus cereus | OxC | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | Reduction of approx. 2mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Bacillus cereus | OxC | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Bacillus cereus | OxC | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxic activity | Caused inhibition zone of 1mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxD | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxD | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxD | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxic activity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxE | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxE | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxE | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxic activity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pantoea ananatis | 125P12 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Effect (data not shown) | Showed a-tomatine resistance what suggests the advantage to resist on/in the leaf tissue and ability to produce metabolic compounds such as AHL and IAA. | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pantoea ananatis | 125P12 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 4.2. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pantoea agglomerans | 124NP3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Effect (data not shown) | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pantoea agglomerans | 124NP3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 10.4. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus sp. | 73ND23 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Effect (data not shown) | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus sp. | 73ND23 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 12.5. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus licheniformis | 52ND12 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 6.3. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Erwinia persicinus | 113NP38 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 14.6. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus megaterium | 53NP31 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 12.5. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus subtilis | 72ND21 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Effect (data not shown) | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus subtilis | 72ND21 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 14.6. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus sp. | 84ND13 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Effect (data not shown) | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus sp. | 84ND13 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 16.7. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pseudomonas sp. | 124NP20 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pseudomonas sp. | 124NP20 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 18.8. | NA | NA | N |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pseudomonas sp. | 94NP18 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pseudomonas sp. | 94NP18 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 22.9. | NA | NA | N |
| Lu et al. (2008) | Brazilian Journal of Microbiology | 39:701-707 | Streptomyces lydicus | A01 | Natamycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Zhongshu No.6 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease rate and disease index | Reduced disease rate and disease index by 35.1 and 8.1; respectively; after 5 dpi. | Reduced disease rate and disease index by 33.7 and 14; respectively; after 10 dpi. | NA | Y |
| Lu et al. (2008) | Brazilian Journal of Microbiology | 39:701-707 | Streptomyces lydicus | A01 | Natamycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Zhongshu No.6 | NA | Diffusion bioassay | Antifungal activity | Effect with mycelial inhibition zone of 4.03mm. | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2009) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemestry | 57: 5750–5755 | Chloranthus henryi | NA | Dimeric sesquiterpene; CHE-23C | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significant growth inhibition with MIC value of 8μg/mL | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2009) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemestry | 57: 5750–5755 | Chloranthus henryi | NA | Dimeric sesquiterpene; CHE-23C | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Seokwang | NA | Greenhouse | Desease severty | No significant effect (7.2%) with concentration of 11μg/ml | With concentration of 100μg/mL the controle effect was 36% | This activity was less than the activity of fludioxonil (82% with 5μg/ml and 100% with 50μg/ml) | N |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Epicoccun nigrum | 126 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Epicoccun nigrum | 126 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced by 22% | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Epicoccun nigrum | 126 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 110 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 110 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 118 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 118 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced by 22% | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 118 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 248 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination by 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 248 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 252 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 252 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 22 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 22 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 24 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 24 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium semitecum | 25 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium semitecum | 25 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 105 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 105 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced by 20% | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 105 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Macrocystis pyrifera (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Macrocystis integrifolia (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Lessonia nigrescens (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Lessonia trabeculata (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | Protection rate more than 72% | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Durvillaea antarctica (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Gracilaria chilensis (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Porphyra columbina (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Gigartina skottsbergii (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Ulva costata (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Hyun Ji et al. (2013) | Mycobiology | 41(4): 234-242 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | CNU114001 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Reduction of mycelial growth by 51. 09% with concentration of 200 ppm | NA | NA | Y |
| Hyun Ji et al. (2013) | Mycobiology | 41(4): 234-242 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | CNU114001 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Reduction of infcted leaves by over 52% | NA | NA | Y |
| Zhang et al. (2013) | Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology | 97:9525–9534 | Bacillus atrophaeus | CAB-1 | Fengycin; putative phage-related pre-neck appendage protein and VOCs | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significant effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Medina et al. (2013) | Frontiers in Plant Science | Vol. 14; DOI:10.3389/fpls.2013.00206 | Trichoderma harzianum | T-78 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | Castlemart | NA | Bioassay | Disease severty | Reduction of lesion diameter by approx. 5mm | Induced ISR depends on JA;SA; and ABA hormones | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Medina et al. (2013) | Frontiers in Plant Science | Vol. 14; DOI:10.3389/fpls.2013.00206 | Trichoderma harzianum | T-78 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymake | NA | Bioassay | Disease severty | Reduction of lesion diameter by approx. 4mm | Induced ISR depends on JA;SA; and ABA hormones | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Medina et al. (2013) | Frontiers in Plant Science | Vol. 14; DOI:10.3389/fpls.2013.00206 | Trichoderma harzianum | T-78 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | UC82B | NA | Bioassay | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Martínez-Medina et al. (2013) | Frontiers in Plant Science | Vol. 14; DOI:10.3389/fpls.2013.00206 | Trichoderma harzianum | T-78 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | Betterboy | NA | Bioassay | Disease severty | Reduction of lesion diameter by approx. 5mm | Induced ISR depends on JA;SA; and ABA hormones | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2013) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 161: 151–157 | NA | NA | Lactoferrin (LF) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ToBc09 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly inhibited spore germination and germ tube elongation by LF when the concentration was 25 mg/L or more. | NA | The mechanisms by which LF decreased gray mould decay of tomato plant may be directly related to the severe damage to the conidia plasma membrane and loss of cytoplasmic materials from the hyphae. | Y |
| Wang et al. (2013) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 161: 151–157 | NA | NA | Lactoferrin (LF) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ToBc09 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro assay of spores plasma membrane integrity | Membrane integrity | LF (50 mg/L) decreased to 68% at 2 h. | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2013) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 161: 151–157 | NA | NA | Lactoferrin (LF) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ToBc09 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro measurement of cellular leakage and MDA content | The leakage of cytoplasmic contents | Leakage of methane dicarboxylic aldehyde; carbohydrate and protein increased as the dose of LF increased. | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2013) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 161: 151–157 | NA | NA | Lactoferrin (LF) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ToBc09 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro determination of SOD and CAT activity and ATP content | SOD and CAT activities | The activities of superoxide dismutase and catalase in spores treated with LF were also 1.3; twice as high as those in the control at 6 h; whereas ATP content was 1.5 times lower | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2013) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 161: 151–157 | NA | NA | Lactoferrin (LF) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ToBc09 | Tomato | Grey mould | Qingyan 1 | NA | In planta | Antifungal activity | Significant curative effect (76.3%; 100 mg/L) against gray mould; compared with the preventive effect (52.6%; 100 mg/L). | NA | NA | Y |
| Harel et al. (2014) | Phytopathology | 104: 150-7 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BcI16 | Tomato | Grey mould | 5811- Ram | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | 0.4% T39 suspension; reduced disease severity by 84% at 5 dpi | NA | NA | Y |
| Mouekouba et al. (2014) | PLoS ONE | 9: e102690 | Clonostachys rosea | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Line 704f | NA | In vivo | Induced resistance | Higher levels of PAL; PPO; GST; NO; SA and GA3 activity and upregulation of WRKY and MAPK. | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.71 % homology with Bacillus mojavensis NBRC 15718ᵀ) | BL1 | Fengycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro dual culture assay | Antifungal activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 46% over control | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.71 % homology with Bacillus mojavensis NBRC 15718ᵀ) | BL1 | Fengycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity of cell-free supernatant | Antifungal activity of 40 (AU ml¯¹) inhibited the growth of pathogen | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.71 % homology with Bacillus mojavensis NBRC 15718ᵀ) | BL1 | Fengycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro paper disk-agar assay method | Antifungal activity | At conc. Of 62.50 lg ml¯¹ caused inhibition zone of 7.5mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.71 % homology with Bacillus mojavensis NBRC 15718ᵀ) | BL1 | Fengycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Detached leaflets assay | Disease severty | Reduced disease severity till 50 % | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.93 % homology with Brevibacterium halotolerans DSM 8802ᵀ) | BT5 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro dual culture assay | Antifungal activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 42% over control | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.93 % homology with Brevibacterium halotolerans DSM 8802ᵀ) | BT5 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity of cell-free supernatant | Antifungal activity of 40 (AU ml¯¹) inhibited the growth of pathogen | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.93 % homology with Brevibacterium halotolerans DSM 8802ᵀ) | BT5 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro paper disk-agar assay method | Antifungal activity | 62.50 lg ml¯¹ caused inhibition zone of 6.2mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.93 % homology with Brevibacterium halotolerans DSM 8802ᵀ) | BT5 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Detached leaflets assay | Disease severty | Reduced disease severity till 50 % | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus subtilis) | BR8 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro dual culture assay | Antifungal activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 27% over control | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus subtilis) | BR8 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity of cell-free supernatant | Antifungal activity of 10 (AU ml¯¹) inhibited the growth of pathogen | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus subtilis) | BR8 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro paper disk-agar assay method | Antifungal activity | 62.50 lg ml¯¹ caused inhibition zone of 5.3mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus subtilis) | BR8 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Detached leaflets assay | Disease severty | Reduced disease severity till 50 % | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens BCRC 11601ᵀ) | BF11 | Fengycin and bacillomycin D | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro dual culture assay | Antifungal activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 53% over control | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens BCRC 11601ᵀ) | BF11 | Fengycin and bacillomycin D | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity of cell-free supernatant | Antifungal activity of 40 (AU ml¯¹) inhibited the growth of pathogen | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens BCRC 11601ᵀ) | BF11 | Fengycin and bacillomycin D | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro paper disk-agar assay method | Antifungal activity | At conc. of 7.81 lg ml¯¹ caused inhibition zone of 5.5mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens BCRC 11601ᵀ) | BF11 | Fengycin and bacillomycin D | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Detached leaflets assay | Disease severty | Reduced disease severity till 11 % | NA | NA | Y |
| Salas-Marina et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Plant Science | 23; 77 | Trichoderma virens | Gv29-8 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Antifungal assay | Disease severty | Significan reduction of leaves damage area by approx. 18% | Protein Sm1 mainly responsible for ISR | NA | Y |
| Salas-Marina et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Plant Science | 23; 77 | Trichoderma atroviride | IMI 206040 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Antifungal assay | Disease severty | Significan reduction of leaves damage area by approx. 10% | Protein Epl1 mainly responsible for ISR | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora viridifaciens | AL4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora saelicesensis | AL16 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora chokoriensis | AL20 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora humi | ALF1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora narathiwatensis | ALF2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora coxensis | ALF4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora saelicesensis | ALF7 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora saelicesensis | ALFb5 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora saelicesensis | ALFb5 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Roma | NA | Greenhouse | Symptom severty | Reduced lesion size by approx. 2mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora saelicesensis | ALFb7 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora echinospora | ALFb1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora tulbaghiae | ALFpr18c | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora tulbaghiae | ALFpr18c | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Roma; Moneymaker and Castlemart | NA | Greenhouse | Symptom severty | Reduced lesion size by approx. 3mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora lupini | ALFpr19a | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora cremea | ALFr4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Pérez et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:1181 | Trichoderma parareesei | IMI 113135 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium; cellophane membranes) | Antifungal assay | Colony growth reduced by 22.7% | NA | NA | Y |
| Pérez et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:1181 | Trichoderma parareesei | IMI 113135 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (liquid medium) | Antifungal assay | Significant inhibition of hyphal growth from conidia | NA | NA | Y |
| Pérez et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:1181 | Trichoderma parareesei | IMI 113135 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Marmande | NA | In vivo (greenhouse) | Disease severty | No significant reduction of necrotic leaf area | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium aurantiacum | BT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium aurantiacum | BT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium aurantiacum | MT8 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium aurantiacum | MT8 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium spp. | GT4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium spp. | GT4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Staphylococcus xylosus | BT5 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Staphylococcus xylosus | BT5 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pantoea eucalypti | NT6 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | Reduced mycelial growth by 29.1% | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pantoea eucalypti | NT6 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | Reduced lesion size by over 56% during the time | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | MT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | Reduced mycelial growth by 52.7% | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | MT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | Induced severty for 1-fold | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas veronii | NT2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | Reduced mycelial growth by 25.2% | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas veronii | NT2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | Reduced lesion size by over 56% during the time | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas veronii | BT4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | Reduced mycelial growth by 23% | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas veronii | BT4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas rhodesiae | BT2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | Reduced mycelial growth by 11.3% | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas rhodesiae | BT2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | Reduced lesion size by over 84% during the time | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas cichorii | NT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas cichorii | NT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Sanchez-Bel et al. (2016) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 7;1598 | Rhizophagus irregularis | BEG 121 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | Better Boy | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Significant reduction of necrotic lesions on leaves | NA | NA | Y |
| Ge et al. (2016) | PLoS One | 11(11): e0166079 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | NKG-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | No. 6 Zhongshu | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Inhibition of fungal growth by more than 80% | NA | NA | Y |
| Ge et al. (2016) | PLoS One | 11(11): e0166079 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | NKG-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | No. 6 Zhongshu | NA | Greenhouse | Desease severty | Reduced diameter of leaf lesion by 60% | NA | NKG-1 is controlling B.cinerea when applied as a preventive spray | Y |
| Lian et al. (2017) | BioMed Research International | Https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/9486794 | Streptomyces pratensis | LMM15 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significant reduction of mycelial growth for approx. 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| Lian et al. (2017) | BioMed Research International | Https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/9486794 | Streptomyces pratensis | LMM15 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05 | Tomato | Grey mould | Maofen-8 | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduction by 46.35%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Lim et al. (2017) | The Plant Pathology Journal | 33 : 488-498 | Bacillus velezensis | G341 | Bacillomycin L and fengycin A; dimethylsulfoxide; 1-butanol; and 3-hydroxy-2-butanone (acetoin) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (dual-culture analysis) | Antifungal activity | Significant reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Lim et al. (2018) | The Plant Pathology Journal | 33 : 488-498 | Bacillus velezensis | G341 | Bacillomycin L and fengycin A; dimethylsulfoxide; 1-butanol; and 3-hydroxy-2-butanone (acetoin) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vivo | Antifungal activity | Control value of 82% with 1-fold liquid culture filtrate dilution | NA | NA | Y |
| Masmoudi et al. (2017) | Microbial Research | 197: 29-38 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | BLB371 (wild type) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significant antifungal activity (250 AU/mL) | NA | NA | Y |
| Masmoudi et al. (2017) | Microbial Research | 197: 29-38 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | BLB371 (wild type) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | Cerasiforme | NA | Bioassay | Desease severty | Reduced of necrosis by 64% when Bacillus spores are applied and 78% when supernatant was applied | NA | NA | Y |
| Masmoudi et al. (2017) | Microbial Research | 197: 29-38 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | M3-7 (strains with random mutagenesis) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | The growth inhibition is improved by 12 fold; compared to wild type ( BLB371) | NA | Combination of proper medium and random mutagenesis improved biocontrol abilities | Y |
| Masmoudi et al. (2017) | Microbial Research | 197: 29-38 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | M3-7 (strains with random mutagenesis) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | Cerasiforme | NA | Bioassay | Desease severty | Total reduction of necrosis; compared to wild type ( BLB371) | NA | Combination of proper medium and random mutagenesis improved biocontrol abilities | Y |
| Sarrocco et al. (2017) | Phytopathology | 107: 537-544 | Trichoderma virens | I10 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | SAS 56 | Tomato | Grey mould | Micro-Tom | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | Significantly (p<0.001) reduced number of necrotic lesions | The constitutive gene for endopolygalacturonase (TvPG2) of Trichoderma is respnsible to trigger plant immune response. | NA | Y |
| Gomes et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Plant Science | 8: 880 | Trichoderma harzianum | Comparation of wild type and Δ1epl-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Expression level of representative B05.10 virulence genes | T. harzianum Epl-1 down-regulates the expression of B. cinerea virulence genes after hyphal contact | NA | NA | Y |
| Gomes et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Plant Science | 8: 880 | Trichoderma harzianum | Comparation of wild type and Δ1epl-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Marmande | NA | In vivo (hydroponic culture) | Expression levels of five tomato marker genes involved in the SA- (PR1b1 and PR-P2) or JA/ET(PINI; PINII; and TomLoxA) mediated signaling pathways | T. harzianum Epl-1 protein up-regulates the expression of PR-P2; a gene involved in SA-mediated response | PR-P2 Is also down-regulated in tomato hydroponic cultures Inoculated with 1epl-1 mutant | NA | Y |
| Hu et al. (2017) | Extremophiles | 21:789–803 | Cryptococcus laurentii | LB2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | NA | NA | Decay incidence reduced by approx. 70.83% | NA | Biocontrol activity of the Tibetan yeast against gray mold in cherry tomato at 4 °C | Y |
| Sun et al. (2017) | Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology | 143: 191–198 | NA | NA | Ε-poly-L-lysine (ε-PL) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | 1200 and 1400 mg/L of ε-PL resulted mycelial growth by 100% and 94.96% | NA | NA | Y |
| Sun et al. (2017) | Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology | 143: 191–198 | NA | NA | Ε-poly-L-lysine (ε-PL) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Oulong | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of the lesion size by 79.07%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Soo Shin et al. (2017) | Plant Pathology Journal | 33(3) : 337-344 | Simplicillium lamellicola | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Showed control efficiency of 64.7% and 82.6% at 500- and 250-fold dilutions. | NA | NA | Y |
| Rubio et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 8:2273 | Trichoderma harzianum | T34 (wild typ) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antigungal assay | Reduced colony diameter by approx. 2cm | NA | NA | Y |
| Rubio et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 8:2273 | Trichoderma harzianum | T34 (wild typ) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Marmande | NA | In vivo | Disease severity | Reduced necrotic leaf area by approx. 40% | NA | NA | Y |
| Rubio et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 8:2273 | Trichoderma harzianum | Thmbf1 overexpressing strain | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal assay | No effect on colony diameter | NA | NA | N |
| Rubio et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 8:2273 | Trichoderma harzianum | Thmbf1 overexpressing strain | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Marmande | NA | In vivo | Disease severity | Increased susceptibility to this pathogen. | NA | NA | N |
| Garrigues et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 9:2370 | Penicillium expansum | CECT 20906 | Protein PeAfpA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT 2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal assay | Growth inhibition at minimal inhibitory concentration values 4 mg/mL | NA | NA | Y |
| Garrigues et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 9:2370 | Penicillium expansum | CECT 20906 | Protein PeAfpB | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT 2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal assay | Growth inhibition at minimal inhibitory concentration values 50 mg/mL | NA | NA | Y |
| Garrigues et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 9:2370 | Penicillium expansum | CECT 20906 | Protein PeAfpC | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT 2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal assay | Growth inhibition at minimal inhibitory concentration values >200 mg/mL | NA | NA | N |
| Garrigues et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 9:2370 | Penicillium expansum | CECT 20906 | Protein PeAfpA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT 2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vivo | Antifungal assay | Significant (almost total) leafe demage reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2018) | International Journal of Molecular Science | 19:1371 | Bacillus subtilis | WXCDD105 | NA | Bacterial filtrate | NA | Botrytis cinerea | WD1 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Inhibition rate of 71.57% (dual culture) or 95.28% (effect of bacterial filtrate). | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2018) | International Journal of Molecular Science | 19:1371 | Bacillus subtilis | WXCDD105 | NA | Bacterial filtrate | NA | Botrytis cinerea | WD1 | Tomato | Grey mould | Dongnong 713 | NA | Greenhouse | Antifungal activity; disease severity | Reduction of symptoms by 74.7%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Sun et al. (2018) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 276: 46–53 | NA | NA | Combined bio-fungicides ε-poly-L-lysine and chitooligosaccharide | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Mycelial growth reduced by 90.22%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Sun et al. (2018) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 276: 46–53 | NA | NA | Combined bio-fungicides ε-poly-L-lysine and chitooligosaccharide | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Oulong | Y | In vivo | Disease severty | Reduced diseased leaves with lesions by 66.67%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Kim et al. (2019) | Scientific Reports | 9:13533 | Streptomyces rectiviolaceus | DY46 | 32;33-didehydroroflamycoin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vivo | Disease incidence | Reduced incidence by 88.9% | NA | NA | Y |
| Rosero-Hernández et al. (2019) | Plants | 8:111 | NA | NA | 3-phenyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Reduction of germination by 87.8%; germ tube by 95.7% and sporulation by 88.9% | NA | 1000ppm | Y |
| Rosero-Hernández et al. (2019) | Plants | 8:111 | NA | NA | 3-phenyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Chonto | NA | In planta | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced leaves incidence by 53.1% and leaves severty by 25.6% | NA | 1000ppm | Y |
| Rosero-Hernández et al. (2019) | Plants | 8:111 | NA | NA | 1-Phenylethanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Chonto | NA | In planta | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced leaves incidence by 59.4% and leaves severty by 27.3% | NA | 1000ppm | Y |
| Herrera-Téllez et al. (2019) | International Journal of Molecular Science | 20:2007 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Vita | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | Reduced lesion size by approx. 25% | NA | Inhibition of reactive oxygen species production (ROS) | Y |
| Wang et al. (2019) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry | 67: 6748-6756 | NA | NA | Protein FEAP (purified from Fagopyrum esculentum) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Dose dependent germination inhibition by approx. 30% to 90%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2019) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry | 67: 6748-6756 | NA | NA | Protein FEAP (purified from Fagopyrum esculentum) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Dose dependent mycelial growth inhibition by approx. 20% to 90%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2019) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry | 67: 6748-6756 | NA | NA | Protein FEAP (purified from Fagopyrum esculentum) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | Jinpengwuxian | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severty | Significant reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Liu et al. (2019) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry | 67: 6116-6124 | NA | NA | Melatonin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ACCC 36028 | Tomato | Grey mould | La-bi | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severty | Significant reduction of necrotic lesions (particularly at 50 µM) | Melatonin induces disease resistance by activating jasmonicacid signaling pathway | NA | Y |
| Ji et al. (2019) | Plant Disease | 103: 1991-1997 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | TA-1 | NA | NA | Fluopimomide (fungicide) | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antigfungal activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 67.09% | Effect is higher by combined treatment of fluopimomide and B. methylotrophicus TA-1. | NA | Y |
| Ji et al. (2019) | Plant Disease | 103: 1991-1997 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | TA-1 | NA | NA | Fluopimomide (fungicide) | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Jinpengwuxian | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severty | Reduced disease severty by 58.8% | Effect is higher by combined treatment of fluopimomide and B. methylotrophicus TA-1. | NA | Y |
| Li et al. (2019) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 157: 110962 | NA | NA | Melatonin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | No. 3 Zhengyinfen | NA | In vivo | Symptome severy | Significantly reduced lesion diameter | Improved a reactive oxygen species (ROS) burst; endogenous melatonin and salicylic acid (SA); chitinase (CHI) and β-1;3-glucanase (GLU) | NA | Y |
| Li et al. (2019) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 157: 110962 | NA | NA | Melatonin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | No effect on colony diameter and spore germination | NA | NA | N |
| Barra-Bucarei et al. (2020) | Microorganisms | 8; 65 | Beauveria bassiana | RGM 393; RGM 461; RGM 547; RGM 557; RGM 565; RGM 570; RGM 632; RGM 644; RGM 657; RGM 731 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | RGM 2519 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Reduced growth by 30–36%; depending on the strain | NA | NA | Y |
| Barra-Bucarei et al. (2020) | Microorganisms | 8; 65 | Beauveria bassiana | RGM 393; RGM 461; RGM 547; RGM 557; RGM 565; RGM 570; RGM 632; RGM 644; RGM 657; RGM 731 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | RGM 2519 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In plnta | Disease incidence | Reduced symptoms by 23.1-37.5%; depending on the strain | NA | NA | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Inhbition of colony diameter by approx. 72.1% | The most detected VOCs: ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | Datterini | NA | In vivo | NA | Reduced the incidence by 67% | NA | Artificially inoculated with B. cinerea conidial suspension | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium melanogenum | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Inhbition of colony diameter by approx. 39% | NA | NA | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium melanogenum | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | Datterini | NA | In vivo | NA | Reduced the incidence by38.4% | NA | Artificially inoculated with B. cinerea conidial suspension | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium subglaciale | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Inhbition of colony diameter until approx. 30% | NA | NA | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium subglaciale | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | Datterini | NA | In vivo | NA | Reduced the incidence by 49.2% | NA | Artificially inoculated with B. cinerea conidial suspension | Y |
| Li et al. (2020) | Plant disease | 104: 1298-1304 | Trichoderma atroviride | CCTCCSBW0199 | NA | NA | Brassinolides | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Reduced colony diameter by approx. 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| Li et al. (2020) | Plant disease | 104: 1298-1304 | Trichoderma atroviride | CCTCCSBW0199 | NA | NA | Brassinolides | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Zhongshu No. 5 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced desease spots on leaves by approx. 70% | Induced defense response-related enzyme; such as peroxidase; superoxide dismutase; catalase; and phenylalanine ammonia-lyase were increased in tomato plants treated with a Trichoderma sp. + BR | NA | Y |
| Toral et al. (2020) | Microorganisms | 8; 992 | Bacillus velezensis | XT1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Mina | NA | In vivo | Antifungal activity | Reduction of disease incidence by 50% anddisease severty by 60% | NA | NA | Y |
| Zhao et al. (2020) | Post-harvest Biology and Technology | 162: 111112 | Saccharomyces cerevisiae | EBY100 | Flagellin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severty | Induced disease resistance | NA | NA | Y |
| Zouari et al. (2020) | Antonie van Leeuwenhoek | Https://doi.org/10.1007/s10482-020-01481-8(0123456789().;-volV() 0123458697().;-volV) | Bacillus; Alcaligenes; Providencia and Ochrobactrum | NA | NA | Compost extract | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Total growth inhibition | NA | NA | Y |
| Zouari et al. (2020) | Antonie van Leeuwenhoek | Https://doi.org/10.1007/s10482-020-01481-8(0123456789().;-volV() 0123458697().;-volV) | Bacillus; Alcaligenes; Providencia and Ochrobactrum | NA | NA | Compost extract | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vivo | Disease inhibition | Improved by more than 50% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Azoxystrobin | 23.2% a. i. | Ortiva | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 55.7% | Efficacy did not improve when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Acibenzolar-S-methyl | 50% a.i.; WG | Bion 50WG | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment when applied at 0.025 g/L; DS reduction by 59.9% | Efficacy did not improve when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Phosethyl-Al | 80% a.i | Alliette | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 57.8% | Efficacy did not improve when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Glucohumate complex | Gluco inductor GlucoActivator; N 4%; P₂O₅ 18% | NA | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 52.4% | Efficacy did not improve when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Mineral fertilizer | Alexin 95PS; P₂O₅ 52%; K₂O₄ 2% | Alexin 95PS; | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 69.2% | Efficacy did not improve when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Brassica carinatade fatted seed meal | Biofence; N organic 3%; P 22%; K 2%; organic C 52% - pellets | Biofence | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | No effect when applied once seven days before transplanting | 56% efficancy when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | Bacillus subtilis | QST 713 | NA | 14.6% a.i. | Serenade Max | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 30.7% | 42.7% efficacy when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | Bacillus velezensis | IT45 | NA | 0.95 | Cilus Plus IT45 | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction is similar to the inoculated and untreated control. | 46% efficacy when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | Trichoderma asperellum + Trichoderma gamsii | NA | NA | WP | Remedier | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 32.8 | 38.3%; efficacy when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | Microbial complex of Trichoderma and Bacillus | NA | NA | Glomus spp. 5%; Bacillus megaterium 10⁴ UFCg¯¹; Trichoderma 10¹⁰ UFCg¯¹; | Rizocore | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction is similar to the inoculated and untreated control. | 38.3%; efficacy when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Innocenti et al. (2015) | BioControl | 60: 573–581 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | Granules | RootShield Granules | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | 365.07 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Inhibition | NA | NA | Y |
| Innocenti et al. (2015) | BioControl | 60: 573–581 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | Granules | RootShield Granules | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | 365.07 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Duke type Iceberg | NA | Mesocosm assays | Disease severty | Reduced by 57 and 78 % in dry and wet conditions; respectively. | Plant biomass was increased by T22 under both moisture levels. | Mesocosm assays under extreme soil water content available for plants | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium.oxysporum | Fo251/2 | NA | NA | Biofox product | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium.oxysporum | Fo251/2 | NA | NA | Biofox product | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium.oxysporum | Fo251/2 | NA | NA | Biofox product | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | NA | RootShield Granules | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | 3 g/l of substrate provided very consistent results and showed the best results | Increased growth response In the presence of a very high disease incidence | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | NA | RootShield Granules | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | 3g/l of substrate provided very consistent results and showed the best results | Increased growth response In the presence of a very high disease incidence | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | NA | RootShield Granules | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | 3 g/l of substrate provided very consistent results and showed the best results | Increased growth response In the presence of a very high disease incidence | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Streptomyces griseoviridis strain | K61 | NA | NA | Mycostop | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Streptomyces griseoviridis strain | K61 | NA | NA | Mycostop | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Streptomyces griseoviridis strain | K61 | NA | NA | Mycostop | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | Fo47 | NA | NA | Microsan | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | Fo47 | NA | NA | Microsan | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | Fo47 | NA | NA | Microsan | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum strain ICC012+ T. viride | T. harzianum ICC012 | NA | NA | Remedier | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum strain ICC012+ T. viride | T. harzianum ICC012 | NA | NA | Remedier | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum strain ICC012+ T. viride | T. harzianum ICC012 | NA | NA | Remedier | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma viride | TV1 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma viride | TV1 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma viride | TV1 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium. oxysporum MSA35 | MSA35 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum MSA35 | MSA35 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum MSA35 | MSA35 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | IF23 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 2-3 g/l of substrate | Two out of five trials reduced the biomass produced. | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | IF23 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 2-3 g/l of substrate | Two out of five trials reduced the biomass produced. | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | IF23 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 2-3 g/l of substrate | Two out of five trials reduced the biomass produced. | NA | N |
| Chitarra et al. (2013) | Online https://iris.unito.it/retrieve/handle/2318/146952/25138/136%20PUGLIESE.pdf | NA | NA | NA | Potassium silicate | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Sligh reduction of disease severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Pseudomonas sp. | FC6B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 13.1%. | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 16% | Showed interesting results on pathogen control; but their performance was still variable throughout the trial | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Pseudomonas putida | FC7B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 15% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 19.3% | Showed interesting results on pathogen control; but their performance was still variable throughout the trial | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Pseudomonas sp. | FC8B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 14% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 18.3% | Showed interesting results on pathogen control; but their performance was still variable throughout the trial | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Pseudomonas sp. | FC9B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 16.7% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 21.1% | Showed interesting results on pathogen control; but their performance was still variable throughout the trial | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Pseudomonas sp. | FC24B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 12.4% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 14.9% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Fusarium oxysporum | 251/2 | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 13% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 17.1% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | F. oxysporum | MSA35 | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 10.5% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 14.5% | It is important to consider that; when antagonistic Fusarium strains are used; they may displace pathogenic Fusarium species rather than eradicate infections already present in the seeds | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Bacillus subtilis | QST713 | NA | NA | Serenade | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 11.2% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 15% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | B. subtilis BA41; Streptomyces sp. SB15; Trichoderma harzianum TH02; Pseudomonas proradix 10; Glomus caledonium GM24 Glomus coronatum GU53; Gladius intraradices GB67; Trichoderma spp | NA | NA | NA | Eko Seed | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 13.6% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 16.4% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Streptomyces griseoviridis | NA | NA | NA | Mycostop | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 8.5% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 9.8% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Streptomyces spp. SB14; G. coronatum GO01; G. coronatum GU53; G. caledonium GM24; B. subtilis SR63; Pseudomonas spp. PM46; Ulocladium spp. UO18 | NA | NA | NA | Micosat F | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 8.1% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 11.3% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Trichoderma harzianum ICC012; Trichoderma viridae ICC080 | NA | NA | NA | Remedier | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 15% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 18.3% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Trichoderm harzianum mix of mycorrhyzal non specified strains | NA | NA | NA | Rizocore | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 12.9% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 16.4% | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection | 124: 361–368 | NA | NA | Dimethyl disulfide | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Analena Sintia | Y | Field experiments | Disease severty | Disease severty was ranging from 44.9 to 78.0% during 3 tials | Reduced symptoms by 70; 97 and 99% during 3 trials (60 g/m² of DMDS ) | Soil disinfestation treatments with dimethyl disulfide | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2017) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection | 124: 361–369 | NA | NA | Dimethyl disulfide | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Badina | Y | Field experiments | Disease severty | Disease severty was ranging from 44.9 to 78.0% during 3 tials | Reduced symptoms by 70; 97 and 99% during 3 trials (60 g/m² of DMDS) | Soil disinfestation treatments with dimethyl disulfide | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2017) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection | 124: 361–370 | NA | NA | Dimethyl disulfide | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | . Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | Field experiments | Disease severty | Disease severty was ranging from 21.9 to 50.8% during 3 tials the | Reduced symptoms by 87; 96.8 and 100% during 3 trials (60 g/m² of DMDS) | Soil disinfestation treatments with dimethyl disulfide | Y |
| Thongkamngam and Jaenaksorn (2017) | Plant Protection Science | 53: 85-95 | Fusarium oxysporum | F221-B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | F221-R | Lettuce | Fusarium root rot and wilt | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 42%; after 9 days after inoculation | NA | NA | Y |
| Thongkamngam and Jaenaksorn (2017) | Plant Protection Science | 53: 85-95 | Fusarium oxysporum | F221-B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | F221-G | Lettuce | Fusarium root rot and wilt | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 38.8%; after 9 days after inoculation | NA | NA | Y |
| Thongkamngam and Jaenaksorn (2015) | Plant Protection Science | 53: 85-93 | Fusarium oxysporum | F221-B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | F422-G | Lettuce | Fusarium root rot and wilt | Butterhead | NA | Hydroponic culture | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence and severty by 64% | NA | NA | Y |
| Thongkamngam and Jaenaksorn (2016) | Plant Protection Science | 53: 85-94 | Fusarium oxysporum | F221-B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | F422-G | Lettuce | Fusarium root rot and wilt | Cos | NA | Hydroponic culture | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence and severty by 85.3% | NA | NA | Y |
| Thongkamngam and Jaenaksorn (2017) | Plant Protection Science | 53: 85-95 | Fusarium oxysporum | F221-B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | F422-G | Lettuce | Fusarium root rot and wilt | Red Oak | NA | Hydroponic culture | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence and severty by 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| El-Sayed et al. (2018) | Bioscience Research | 15: 602-609 | Trichoderma asperellum | T34 | NA | NA | T34-Biocontrol | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | AUMC10895 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Aviram | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence for 33.33% | Reduced disease severity for 42.22% | NA | Y |
| El-Sayed et al. (2018) | Bioscience Research | 15: 602-609 | Trichoderma asperellum | T34 | NA | NA | T34-Biocontrol | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | AUMC10895 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Aviram | NA | Field experiments | NA | Reduced disease incidence for 34.26% and 26.45% during two seasons | Reduced disease incidence for 24.45% and 26.67% during two seasons | The unsatisfactory results of T34 biocontrol in the field May be contributed to the climatic variations; the biocontrol agent has poor competence and the product is unstable | N |
| El-Sayed et al. (2018) | Bioscience Research | 15: 602-609 | Three strains of Bacillus polymyxa; two strains of B.macerans; one strain of B. circulans and one strain of Enterobacter agglomerans | NA | NA | NA | ESRU-Bio control | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | AUMC10895 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Aviram | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence for 26.67% | Reduced disease severity for 26.66% | NA | Y |
| El-Sayed et al. (2018) | Bioscience Research | 15: 602-609 | Un-commercial blue-green algal extract in liquid phase entrapping Anabaena flos aquae and Nostoc muscorum | NA | NA | NA | Algae extract | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | AUMC10895 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Aviram | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence for 13.33% | Reduced disease severity for 20% | NA | Y |
| Alamri et al. (2019) | Biological control | 128: 76-84 | Trichoderma harzianum | JF419706 | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum | HQ905450 | Lettuce | Root rot | Paris Island | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced by 29.2% on 25 days old plants and by 20.9% on 50 days old plants | Application of both microorganism reduced disease severty by 37.5% on 25 days old plants and 29.2% on 50 days old plants | NA | Y |
| Alamri et al. (2019) | Biological control | 128: 76-84 | Bacillus subtilis | HQ656002 | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum | HQ905450 | Lettuce | Root rot | Paris Island | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced by 25% on 25 or 50 days old | NA | NA | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Surfactin | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Iturin A | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | Significant reduction of growth from concentration 12.5 mg/L | NA | NA | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Surfactin | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Patriot (crisphead lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 3.75 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Iturin A | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Patriot (crisphead lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0;94 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Surfactin | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Costa Rica No. 4 (romaine lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 3.75 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Iturin A | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Costa Rica No. 4 (romaine lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0;94 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Surfactin | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Hawai No. 2 (red leaf lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0.94 mg/l and 3.75 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Iturin A | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Hawai No. 2 (red leaf lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0;94 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Surfactin | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Marino (green leaf lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0.94 mg/l; 3.75 mg/l and 7.5 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Iturin A | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Marino (green leaf lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0;94 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | Bacillus subtilis | QST 713 | NA | NA | Serenade max | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 60% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | Trichoderma asperellum + Trichoderma gamssi | NA | NA | NA | Remedier | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 54% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | Pseudomonas putida | FC7B + FC8B + FC9B | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 49% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | Trichoderma sp. TW2 | NA | NA | Green compost | ANT’s compost M | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 69% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | ANT's compost V | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 51% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | NA | NA | Azoxystrobin | NA | Ortiva | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 64% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | Trichoderma sp. | TW2 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 44% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Bacillus subtilis | QST 713 | NA | NA | Serenade max | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 35 and 39.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Bacillus subtilis | QST 713 | NA | NA | Serenade max | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 30.6 and 18.2 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Bacillus subtilis | QST 713 | NA | NA | Serenade max | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 54.4 42.5 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Trichoderma asperellum +Trichoderma gamssi | NA | NA | NA | Remedier | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 31.1 and 40 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Trichoderma asperellum +Trichoderma gamssi | NA | NA | NA | Remedier | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 29.4 16.3 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Trichoderma asperellum +Trichoderma gamssi | NA | NA | NA | Remedier | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 31.9 30.6 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Pseudomonas spp. | 9FC | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 31.3 28.8 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Pseudomonas spp. | 9FC | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 32.5 19.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Pseudomonas spp. | 9FC | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 41.2 24.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Fusarium oxysporum | MSA | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 35.6 34.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Fusarium oxysporum | MSA | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 33.8 16.9 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Fusarium oxysporum | MSA | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 36.2 30.6 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Acibenzolar‐S‐methy | NA | Bion 50WG | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 38.1 50.3 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Acibenzolar‐S‐methy | NA | Bion 50WG | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 36.9 24.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Acibenzolar‐S‐methy | NA | Bion 50WG | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 48.1 46.9 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Potassium phosphite P:K 52:42 | NA | Alexin | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 47.5 45.7 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Potassium phosphite P:K 52:42 | NA | Alexin | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 38.1 23.2 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Potassium phosphite P:K 52:42 | NA | Alexin | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 46.2 41.9 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Phosetyl-Aluminium | NA | Aliette | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 51.9 55 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Phosetyl-Aluminium | NA | Aliette | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 41.9 28.2 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Phosetyl-Aluminium | NA | Aliette | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 40 43.1 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Ant's compost 5015V | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 45 66.9 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Ant's compost 5015V | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 40.6 36.9 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Ant's compost 5015V | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 48.1 52.5 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Compost 214 | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 36.3 31.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Compost 214 | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 39.4 24.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Compost 214 | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 44.2 40 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2017) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-108 | NA | NA | NA | Animal bone biochar | ABC | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 39.3 45 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2018) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-109 | NA | NA | NA | Animal bone biochar | ABC | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 35 28.8 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Animal bone biochar | ABC | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 30.8 30.6 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2017) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-108 | NA | NA | Azoxystrobin | NA | Ortiva | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 60 and 51.3 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2018) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-109 | NA | NA | Azoxystrobin | NA | Ortiva | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 48.8 30.7 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Azoxystrobin | NA | Ortiva | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 46.2 57.5 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Cladosporium spp. | ER3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Cladosporium spp. | YNA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Pseudomonas marginalis | GA8-PS4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Trichoderma harzianum | C52 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Trichoderma longipile | 6sr4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Ulocladium spp. | U13 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | Reduction by 94% | NA | Reduction in one of two experiments | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Ulocladium spp. | U16 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Epicoccum sp. | E21 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Bacillus subtilis | PT69 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Paenibacillus polymyxa | 18-25 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified white yeast | PK10 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified pink yeasts | Y44 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified pink yeasts | Y46 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified pink yeasts | Y48 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified fluorescent Pseudomonas spp. | PF13 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | Reduced by 76% and 96%. | NA | Reduction in all experiments | Y |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified fluorescent Pseudomonas spp. | PF14 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | Reduced from 60% to 96%. | NA | Reduction in all experiments | Y |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Unidentified fluorescent Pseudomonas spp. | PF15 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | Reduced from 60% to 96%. | NA | Reduction in all experiments | Y |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | LC8 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | Reduced from 60% to 96%. | NA | Reduction in all experiments | Y |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Card et al. (2002) | New Zealand Plant Protection | 55: 197-201 | Gliocladium catenulatum | NA | NA | NA | Prestop | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Marksman | NA | Glasshouse | Lesion areas | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Fiddaman et al. (2000) | Annals of Applied Biology | 137:223—235 | Bacillus spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | 92/B8 | Lettuce | Grey mould | NA | NA | Leaf disc bioassays | Leaf tissue discoloration | Reduced over 90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiddaman et al. (2000) | Annals of Applied Biology | 137:223—235 | Pseudomonas spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | 92/B8 | Lettuce | Grey mould | NA | NA | Leaf disc bioassays | Leaf tissue discoloration | Reduced over 90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Charmy | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severity (McKinney index) | Reduced by 68;4% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | LM 1307 | N | Greenhouse | Disease severity (McKinney index) | Reduced by 35.8% | The combination of LM 1307 plant varity and Contans®WG showed the best results in pathogen suppresion | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Ninja | Y /N | Greenhouse | Disease severity (McKinney index) | Reduced by 46.7% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Charmy | Y | Greenhouse | Healthy plants | Improved for 66.7% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | LM 1307 | N | Greenhouse | Healthy plants | Improved for 58.4% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2005) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science; Ghent Universityciences | 70/3: 157-168 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans®WG | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Ninja | Y /N | Greenhouse | Healthy plants | Improved for 66.6% | NA | NA | Y |
| Lolas et al. (2005) | Acta Horticulture | 697 ISHS 2005 | Trichoderma virens | Sherwood | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Butterhead lettuce | Grey rot | Esmeralda | NA | Greenhouse (hydroponic float system) | Disease incidence | Significant lower incidence (P<0.01) | NA | Should be used as a preventive biocontrol agent | Y |
| McQuilken et al. (1994) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 10: 20-26 | Filamentous fungi and yeasts; Penicillium chrysogenurn; P. brevicompactum; Mucor hiemalis and Trichoderma spp.; Debaryomyces hansenii | NA | NA | Compost extract (containing BCA:microorganism) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BCI3 | Lettuce | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Conidial germination | Significant (P < 0.05) reduction | NA | Not better reduction than in treatments with iprodion | Y |
| McQuilken et al. (1994) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 10: 20-26 | Filamentous fungi and yeasts; Penicillium chrysogenurn; P. brevicompactum; Mucor hiemalis and Trichoderma spp.; Debaryomyces hansenii | NA | NA | Compost extract (containing BCA:microorganism) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BCI3 | Lettuce | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth | Significant (P < 0.05) reduction | NA | Not better reduction than in treatments with iprodion | Y |
| McQuilken et al. (1994) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 10: 20-26 | Filamentous fungi and yeasts; Penicillium chrysogenurn; P. brevicompactum; Mucor hiemalis and Trichoderma spp.; Debaryomyces hansenii | NA | NA | Compost extract (containing BCA:microorganism) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BCI3 | Lettuce | Grey mould | Hudson | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty (severty index) | Significant (P < 0.002) reduction by 22.8 | NA | NA | Y |
| McQuilken et al. (1994) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 10: 20-26 | Filamentous fungi and yeasts; Penicillium chrysogenurn; P. brevicompactum; Mucor hiemalis and Trichoderma spp.; Debaryomyces hansenii | NA | NA | Compost extract (containing BCA:microorganism) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BCI3 | Lettuce | Grey mould | Hudson | NA | Glasshouse | Number of marketable plants | Significant (P < 0.001) increase by 37.2% | NA | NA | Y |
| McQuilken et al. (1994) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 10: 20-26 | Filamentous fungi and yeasts; Penicillium chrysogenurn; P. brevicompactum; Mucor hiemalis and Trichoderma spp.; Debaryomyces hansenii | NA | NA | Compost extract (containing BCA:microorganism) | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BCI3 | Lettuce | Grey mould | Hudson | NA | Glasshouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Growth rate unafected with Y4ᴬ treatments of 10 µg ml¯¹ Y4 but was enhanced on with 100µg and 1000µg ml¯¹ . | NA | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Little Gem | NA | Detached leaf bioassays | Infected leaf area | Y3ᴬ reduced disease by 50%; Y4ᴬ to 90% and Y20ᴬ by 85% | NA | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Little Gem | NA | Glasshouse | Overall disease assessment | Y4ᴬ reduced disease by approx. 70% | NA | Inoculation was carried out by placing two barley seeds infected with R solani at the base of the growing plant adjacent to the stem and then spraying each plant with B. cincrea spore suspension. | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Berlo | NA | Detached leaf bioassays | Infected leaf area | Y3ᴬ reduced infection by 58%; Y4ᴬ by 72%; Y20ᴬ by 69%. | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ each reduced disease levels by 5-14 % | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Berlo | NA | Glasshouse | Overall disease assessment | Y4ᴬ reduced disease by approx. 50% | NA | Inoculation was carried out by placing two barley seeds infected with R solani at the base of the growing plant adjacent to the stem and then spraying each plant with B. cincrea spore suspension. | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Norden | NA | Detached leaf bioassays | Infected leaf area | Y3ᴬ reduced infection by 58%; Y4ᴬ by 72%; Y20ᴬ by 69%. | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ each reduced disease levels by 5-14 % | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Novita | NA | Detached leaf bioassays | Infected leaf area | Y3ᴬ reduced infection by 58%; Y4ᴬ by 72%; Y20ᴬ by 69%. | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ each reduced disease levels by 5-14 % | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Patricia | NA | Detached leaf assays | Infected leaf area | Y3ᴬ reduced infection by 58%; Y4ᴬ by 72%; Y20ᴬ by 69%. | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ each reduced disease levels by 5-14 % | NA | Y |
| Reglinski et al. (1995) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protcction | 102: 257 - 266 | Saccharomyces cereuisiae | NA | Y3ᴬ; Y4ᴬ and Y20ᴬ water soluble yeast cell wall extracts | Addition of adjuvants | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Lettuce | Grey mould | Patricia | NA | Glasshouse | Overall disease assessment | Y4ᴬ reduced disease by approx. 70% | NA | Inoculation was carried out by placing two barley seeds infected with R solani at the base of the growing plant adjacent to the stem and then spraying each plant with B. cincrea spore suspension. | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 96% | NA | Once infection had been established; none of the antagonists tended to cause a large reduction in severity of disease or sporulation on stem segments. | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | Reduction by more than 75% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus luteus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 50% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus luteus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 39% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus albidus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 37% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus albidus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 30% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus laurentii var. flavescens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Cryptococcus laurentii var. flavescens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 40% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium catenulatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 97% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium catenulatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 89% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium catenulatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | Reduction by more than 75% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium roseum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 78% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium roseum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 78% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Gliocladium roseum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | Reduction by more than 75% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma hamatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 51% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma hamatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 34% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma viride | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 41% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma viride | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 16% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma viride | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Chaetomium globosum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 68% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Chaetomium globosum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 66% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Ulocladium atrum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 75% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Ulocladium atrum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 68% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus pumilus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 15% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus pumilus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 15% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus pumilus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 17% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Bacillus sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease symptoms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Pseudomonas sp. | Isolate 1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 78% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Pseudomonas sp. | Isolate 1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 55% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Pseudomonas sp. | Isolate 2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Sporulation | Reduction by more than 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| Dik et al. (1999) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 105: 115–122 | Pseudomonas sp. | Isolate 2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc700 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | Y | Bioassay with stem segments | Disease inhibition | Reduction by more than 57% | NA | NA | Y |
| Altomare et al. (2000) | Journal of Natural Products | 63: 1131-1135 | Fusarium semitectum | NA | Fusapyrone and deoxyfusapyrone | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ITEM 966 | Tomato | NA | NA | NA | Disk diffusion assays | Antifungal activity | Fusapyrone was more active causing 29.3 mm inhibition zone while deoxyfusapyrone caused 13.5 mm; in comparation with antifungal antibiotic nystatine of 31.2 mmdeoxyfusapyrone | Fusapyrone was mostly fungicidal at 5 µg/disk against B. cinerea | NA | Y |
| Altomare et al. (2000) | Journal of Natural Products | 63: 1131-1135 | Fusarium semitectum | NA | Fusapyrone and deoxyfusapyrone | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ITEM 966 | Tomato | NA | NA | NA | Leaf puncture assay | Disease symptoms | Only fusapyrone was active | Fusapyrone caused severe symptoms on tomato leaves at 5 × 10-⁴and 10-⁴ M | NA | N |
| Altomare et al. (2000) | Journal of Natural Products | 63: 1131-1135 | Fusarium semitectum | NA | Fusapyrone and deoxyfusapyrone | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ITEM 966 | Tomato | NA | NA | NA | Cutting assay | Disease symptoms | No symptoms were observed on tomato cuttings treated with 10-³ M | Symptom of phytotoxicity (chlorosis of leaf veins) to cuttings treated with fusapyrone was detected at the concentration of 10-⁵ M; and complete wilting (leaves and stems) was observed at 10-⁴ | NA | N |
| Altomare et al. (2000) | Journal of Natural Products | 63: 1131-1135 | Fusarium semitectum | NA | Fusapyrone and deoxyfusapyrone | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ITEM 966 | Tomato | NA | NA | NA | Seedlings assay | Disease symptoms | No phytotoxic activity in the tomato seedling germination assay | The doses of 10-⁴ and 10-⁵ M; deoxyfusapyrone stimulated the elongation of rootlets; the values being more than 120% of the control | NA | N |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Pseudomonas putida | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus cereus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Enterobacter agglomerans | B8 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 5.2 mm of diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus subtilis | AGS-K | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 8.4 mm of diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus subtilis | AGS-4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 8.0 mm of diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus subtilis | BACT-O | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 6.0 mm of diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus subtilis | BACT-10 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 22.8 mm of diameter | Significantly increased the total fruit yield | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Bacillus subtilis | BACT-10 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | Trust | NA | In vivo | Lesion length | Significantly decreased lesion length | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Rhodosporium diobovatum | S33 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Significant inhibition by 5.4 mm of diameter | NA | Antibiosis may be one of the mechanism responsible for control of this disease | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Rhodosporium diobovatum | S33 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | Trust | NA | In vivo | Lesion length | Significantly decreased lesion length | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | RootShield® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | No effect | NA | The survival of T. harzianum on stems is a key factor for achieving effective control. The poor activity often shown by T. harzianum against B. cinerea under severe disease pressure was due to its poor survival on leaf surface | N |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | RootShield® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | Trust | NA | In vivo | Lesion length | Significantly decreased lesion length | NA | NA | Y |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Gliocladium virens | NA | NA | NA | SoilGard® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Utkhede et al. (2001) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 23: 253–259 | Gliocladium virens | NA | NA | NA | SoilGard® | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Stem canker | Trust | NA | In vivo | Lesion length | Significantly decreased lesion length | NA | NA | Y |
| Audenaert et al. (2002) | The American Phytopathological Society | 15: 1147–1156 | Pseudomonas aeruginosa | 7NSK2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | R16 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Greenhouse | Lesion spreading | Reduced lesion spreading and induced resistance to B. cinerea | Pyocyanin and pyochelin; rather than salicylic acid; are the determinants for induced resistance | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Fungitoxicity assay | Decreased mycelium growth rate during the exponential phase by 0.33 cm/day. | Maximalmycelium growth reached 7 days after incubation (compared to 6 days in presence of methanole). | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (liquid medium) | Fungitoxicity assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Production of p-nitrophenylbutyrate esterases | Induced | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Production of laccases | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Membrane leakage | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | Kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | Roma | NA | In vivo | Leason area | Reduced by 2.2 mm² | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxicity assay | Decreased mycelium growth rate during the exponential phase by 0.76 cm/day. | Maximal mycelium growth reached 9 days after incubation (compared to 6 days in presence of methanole ) | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (liquid medium) | Fungitoxicity assay | Inhibition by 80.8% in minimum medium and 36% in malt-yeast extract medium. | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Production of p-nitrophenylbutyrate esterases and laccases | Induced | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Production of laccases | Induced | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Membrane leakage | Induced 3 times | NA | NA | Y |
| Cotoras et al. (2004) | Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemestry | 5: 2821−2826 | Pseudognaphalium vira vira | NA | 3β-Hydroxy-kaurenoic acid | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | G29 | Tomato | Grey mould | Roma | NA | In vivo | Leason area | Reduced by 4.9 mm² | NA | NA | Y |
| Meziane et al.; . (2005) | Molecular Plant Pathology | 6: 177–185 | Pseudomonas putida | WCS358 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | R16 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassays for induced resistance | Lesions spreading | Significant reduction | Lipopolysaccharides and pseudobactin are responsible for the ISR | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2006) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Sciences; Ghent University | 71: 897-908 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Reduction of the mycelial radial growth by 76% | NA | NA | Y |
| Fiume et al. (2006) | Communications in Agricultural and Applied Biological Sciences; Ghent University | 71: 897-908 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Trichodex | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Nikita | NA | Greenhouse | Symptom severity | 4 kg/ha of trichodex after the fruit setting controlled with very effectiveness the gray mould | Trichodex at 400g/hL gave the best results; decreasing the disease over 50% compared to untreated control and over 70% compared to chemical control. | NA | Y |
| Cho et al. (2006) | Pest Management Science | 62:414–418 | NA | NA | Dehydro-α-lapachone (isolated from Catalpa ovata stems) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Complete mycelial inhibition at doses above 0.41mg/l | NA | NA | Y |
| Cho et al. (2006) | Pest Management Science | 62:414–418 | NA | NA | Dehydro-α-lapachone (isolated from Catalpa ovata stems) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vivo | Antifungal activity | Inhibition by 63% with 500mg/l and 31% with 250mg/l | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Pseudomonas sp. | CHAO-Rif | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | Reduction of approx. 6mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Pseudomonas sp. | CHAO-Rif | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | Reduction of approx. 6mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Pseudomonas sp. | CHAO-Rif | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxic activity | Caused inhibition zone of 6mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Cupriavidus campinensis | OxB | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | Reduction of approx. 6mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Cupriavidus campinensis | OxB | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | Reduction of approx. 6mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Cupriavidus campinensis | OxB | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxic activity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Bacillus cereus | OxC | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | Reduction of approx. 2mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Bacillus cereus | OxC | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Bacillus cereus | OxC | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxic activity | Caused inhibition zone of 1mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxD | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxD | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxD | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxic activity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxE | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxE | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymaker | NA | Bioassay | Lesion diameter | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Schoonbeek et al. (2007) | The American Phytopathological Society | 20: 1535–1544 | Variovarox spp. | OxE | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BMM | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Fungitoxic activity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pantoea ananatis | 125P12 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Effect (data not shown) | Showed a-tomatine resistance what suggests the advantage to resist on/in the leaf tissue and ability to produce metabolic compounds such as AHL and IAA. | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pantoea ananatis | 125P12 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 4.2. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pantoea agglomerans | 124NP3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Effect (data not shown) | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pantoea agglomerans | 124NP3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 10.4. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus sp. | 73ND23 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Effect (data not shown) | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus sp. | 73ND23 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 12.5. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus licheniformis | 52ND12 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 6.3. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Erwinia persicinus | 113NP38 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 14.6. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus megaterium | 53NP31 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 12.5. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus subtilis | 72ND21 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Effect (data not shown) | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus subtilis | 72ND21 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 14.6. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus sp. | 84ND13 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Effect (data not shown) | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Bacillus sp. | 84ND13 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 16.7. | NA | NA | Y |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pseudomonas sp. | 124NP20 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pseudomonas sp. | 124NP20 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 18.8. | NA | NA | N |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pseudomonas sp. | 94NP18 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Enya et al. (2007) | Microbial Ecology | 53: 524–536 | Pseudomonas sp. | 94NP18 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | MAFF305019 | Tomato | Grey mould | Hausumomotarou | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduced to the value of 22.9. | NA | NA | N |
| Lu et al. (2008) | Brazilian Journal of Microbiology | 39:701-707 | Streptomyces lydicus | A01 | Natamycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Zhongshu No.6 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease rate and disease index | Reduced disease rate and disease index by 35.1 and 8.1; respectively; after 5 dpi. | Reduced disease rate and disease index by 33.7 and 14; respectively; after 10 dpi. | NA | Y |
| Lu et al. (2008) | Brazilian Journal of Microbiology | 39:701-707 | Streptomyces lydicus | A01 | Natamycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Zhongshu No.6 | NA | Diffusion bioassay | Antifungal activity | Effect with mycelial inhibition zone of 4.03mm. | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2009) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemestry | 57: 5750–5755 | Chloranthus henryi | NA | Dimeric sesquiterpene; CHE-23C | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significant growth inhibition with MIC value of 8μg/mL | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2009) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemestry | 57: 5750–5755 | Chloranthus henryi | NA | Dimeric sesquiterpene; CHE-23C | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Seokwang | NA | Greenhouse | Desease severty | No significant effect (7.2%) with concentration of 11μg/ml | With concentration of 100μg/mL the controle effect was 36% | This activity was less than the activity of fludioxonil (82% with 5μg/ml and 100% with 50μg/ml) | N |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Epicoccun nigrum | 126 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Epicoccun nigrum | 126 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced by 22% | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Epicoccun nigrum | 126 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 110 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 110 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 118 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 118 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced by 22% | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 118 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 248 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination by 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 248 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 252 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Trichoderma harzianum | 252 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 22 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 22 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 24 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 24 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium semitecum | 25 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium semitecum | 25 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 105 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly reduced spore germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 105 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced by 20% | NA | NA | Y |
| Monaco et al. (2009) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 42: 729–737 | Fusarium equiseti | 105 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc11 | Tomato | Grey mould | Larga vida | NA | Growth chamber | Symptom severty | Significant reduction of lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Macrocystis pyrifera (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Macrocystis integrifolia (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Lessonia nigrescens (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Lessonia trabeculata (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | Protection rate more than 72% | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Durvillaea antarctica (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Gracilaria chilensis (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Porphyra columbina (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Gigartina skottsbergii (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Jiménez et al. (2011) | Marine Drugs | 9: 739-756 | Ulva costata (algae) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Patron | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Hyun Ji et al. (2013) | Mycobiology | 41(4): 234-242 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | CNU114001 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Reduction of mycelial growth by 51. 09% with concentration of 200 ppm | NA | NA | Y |
| Hyun Ji et al. (2013) | Mycobiology | 41(4): 234-242 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | CNU114001 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Reduction of infcted leaves by over 52% | NA | NA | Y |
| Zhang et al. (2013) | Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology | 97:9525–9534 | Bacillus atrophaeus | CAB-1 | Fengycin; putative phage-related pre-neck appendage protein and VOCs | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significant effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Medina et al. (2013) | Frontiers in Plant Science | Vol. 14; DOI:10.3389/fpls.2013.00206 | Trichoderma harzianum | T-78 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | Castlemart | NA | Bioassay | Disease severty | Reduction of lesion diameter by approx. 5mm | Induced ISR depends on JA;SA; and ABA hormones | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Medina et al. (2013) | Frontiers in Plant Science | Vol. 14; DOI:10.3389/fpls.2013.00206 | Trichoderma harzianum | T-78 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | Moneymake | NA | Bioassay | Disease severty | Reduction of lesion diameter by approx. 4mm | Induced ISR depends on JA;SA; and ABA hormones | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Medina et al. (2013) | Frontiers in Plant Science | Vol. 14; DOI:10.3389/fpls.2013.00206 | Trichoderma harzianum | T-78 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | UC82B | NA | Bioassay | Disease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Martínez-Medina et al. (2013) | Frontiers in Plant Science | Vol. 14; DOI:10.3389/fpls.2013.00206 | Trichoderma harzianum | T-78 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | Betterboy | NA | Bioassay | Disease severty | Reduction of lesion diameter by approx. 5mm | Induced ISR depends on JA;SA; and ABA hormones | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2013) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 161: 151–157 | NA | NA | Lactoferrin (LF) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ToBc09 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significantly inhibited spore germination and germ tube elongation by LF when the concentration was 25 mg/L or more. | NA | The mechanisms by which LF decreased gray mould decay of tomato plant may be directly related to the severe damage to the conidia plasma membrane and loss of cytoplasmic materials from the hyphae. | Y |
| Wang et al. (2013) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 161: 151–157 | NA | NA | Lactoferrin (LF) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ToBc09 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro assay of spores plasma membrane integrity | Membrane integrity | LF (50 mg/L) decreased to 68% at 2 h. | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2013) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 161: 151–157 | NA | NA | Lactoferrin (LF) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ToBc09 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro measurement of cellular leakage and MDA content | The leakage of cytoplasmic contents | Leakage of methane dicarboxylic aldehyde; carbohydrate and protein increased as the dose of LF increased. | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2013) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 161: 151–157 | NA | NA | Lactoferrin (LF) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ToBc09 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro determination of SOD and CAT activity and ATP content | SOD and CAT activities | The activities of superoxide dismutase and catalase in spores treated with LF were also 1.3; twice as high as those in the control at 6 h; whereas ATP content was 1.5 times lower | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2013) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 161: 151–157 | NA | NA | Lactoferrin (LF) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ToBc09 | Tomato | Grey mould | Qingyan 1 | NA | In planta | Antifungal activity | Significant curative effect (76.3%; 100 mg/L) against gray mould; compared with the preventive effect (52.6%; 100 mg/L). | NA | NA | Y |
| Harel et al. (2014) | Phytopathology | 104: 150-7 | Trichoderma harzianum | T39 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | BcI16 | Tomato | Grey mould | 5811- Ram | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | 0.4% T39 suspension; reduced disease severity by 84% at 5 dpi | NA | NA | Y |
| Mouekouba et al. (2014) | PLoS ONE | 9: e102690 | Clonostachys rosea | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Line 704f | NA | In vivo | Induced resistance | Higher levels of PAL; PPO; GST; NO; SA and GA3 activity and upregulation of WRKY and MAPK. | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.71 % homology with Bacillus mojavensis NBRC 15718ᵀ) | BL1 | Fengycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro dual culture assay | Antifungal activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 46% over control | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.71 % homology with Bacillus mojavensis NBRC 15718ᵀ) | BL1 | Fengycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity of cell-free supernatant | Antifungal activity of 40 (AU ml¯¹) inhibited the growth of pathogen | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.71 % homology with Bacillus mojavensis NBRC 15718ᵀ) | BL1 | Fengycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro paper disk-agar assay method | Antifungal activity | At conc. Of 62.50 lg ml¯¹ caused inhibition zone of 7.5mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.71 % homology with Bacillus mojavensis NBRC 15718ᵀ) | BL1 | Fengycin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Detached leaflets assay | Disease severty | Reduced disease severity till 50 % | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.93 % homology with Brevibacterium halotolerans DSM 8802ᵀ) | BT5 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro dual culture assay | Antifungal activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 42% over control | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.93 % homology with Brevibacterium halotolerans DSM 8802ᵀ) | BT5 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity of cell-free supernatant | Antifungal activity of 40 (AU ml¯¹) inhibited the growth of pathogen | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.93 % homology with Brevibacterium halotolerans DSM 8802ᵀ) | BT5 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro paper disk-agar assay method | Antifungal activity | 62.50 lg ml¯¹ caused inhibition zone of 6.2mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99.93 % homology with Brevibacterium halotolerans DSM 8802ᵀ) | BT5 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Detached leaflets assay | Disease severty | Reduced disease severity till 50 % | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus subtilis) | BR8 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro dual culture assay | Antifungal activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 27% over control | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus subtilis) | BR8 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity of cell-free supernatant | Antifungal activity of 10 (AU ml¯¹) inhibited the growth of pathogen | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus subtilis) | BR8 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro paper disk-agar assay method | Antifungal activity | 62.50 lg ml¯¹ caused inhibition zone of 5.3mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus subtilis) | BR8 | Iturin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Detached leaflets assay | Disease severty | Reduced disease severity till 50 % | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens BCRC 11601ᵀ) | BF11 | Fengycin and bacillomycin D | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro dual culture assay | Antifungal activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 53% over control | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens BCRC 11601ᵀ) | BF11 | Fengycin and bacillomycin D | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity of cell-free supernatant | Antifungal activity of 40 (AU ml¯¹) inhibited the growth of pathogen | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens BCRC 11601ᵀ) | BF11 | Fengycin and bacillomycin D | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro paper disk-agar assay method | Antifungal activity | At conc. of 7.81 lg ml¯¹ caused inhibition zone of 5.5mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Kefi et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiol Biotechnology | 31:1967–1976 | Bacillus spp. (99 % homology with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens BCRC 11601ᵀ) | BF11 | Fengycin and bacillomycin D | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Detached leaflets assay | Disease severty | Reduced disease severity till 11 % | NA | NA | Y |
| Salas-Marina et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Plant Science | 23; 77 | Trichoderma virens | Gv29-8 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Antifungal assay | Disease severty | Significan reduction of leaves damage area by approx. 18% | Protein Sm1 mainly responsible for ISR | NA | Y |
| Salas-Marina et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Plant Science | 23; 77 | Trichoderma atroviride | IMI 206040 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Antifungal assay | Disease severty | Significan reduction of leaves damage area by approx. 10% | Protein Epl1 mainly responsible for ISR | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora viridifaciens | AL4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora saelicesensis | AL16 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora chokoriensis | AL20 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora humi | ALF1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora narathiwatensis | ALF2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora coxensis | ALF4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora saelicesensis | ALF7 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora saelicesensis | ALFb5 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora saelicesensis | ALFb5 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Roma | NA | Greenhouse | Symptom severty | Reduced lesion size by approx. 2mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora saelicesensis | ALFb7 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora echinospora | ALFb1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora tulbaghiae | ALFpr18c | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora tulbaghiae | ALFpr18c | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Roma; Moneymaker and Castlemart | NA | Greenhouse | Symptom severty | Reduced lesion size by approx. 3mm | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora lupini | ALFpr19a | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Martínez-Hidalgo et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:922 | Micromonospora cremea | ALFr4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic assay | Significantly inhibited | NA | NA | Y |
| Pérez et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:1181 | Trichoderma parareesei | IMI 113135 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium; cellophane membranes) | Antifungal assay | Colony growth reduced by 22.7% | NA | NA | Y |
| Pérez et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:1181 | Trichoderma parareesei | IMI 113135 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (liquid medium) | Antifungal assay | Significant inhibition of hyphal growth from conidia | NA | NA | Y |
| Pérez et al. (2015) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 6:1181 | Trichoderma parareesei | IMI 113135 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Marmande | NA | In vivo (greenhouse) | Disease severty | No significant reduction of necrotic leaf area | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium aurantiacum | BT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium aurantiacum | BT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium aurantiacum | MT8 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium aurantiacum | MT8 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium spp. | GT4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Exiguobacterium spp. | GT4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Staphylococcus xylosus | BT5 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Staphylococcus xylosus | BT5 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pantoea eucalypti | NT6 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | Reduced mycelial growth by 29.1% | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pantoea eucalypti | NT6 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | Reduced lesion size by over 56% during the time | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | MT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | Reduced mycelial growth by 52.7% | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | MT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | Induced severty for 1-fold | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas veronii | NT2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | Reduced mycelial growth by 25.2% | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas veronii | NT2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | Reduced lesion size by over 56% during the time | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas veronii | BT4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | Reduced mycelial growth by 23% | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas veronii | BT4 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas rhodesiae | BT2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | Reduced mycelial growth by 11.3% | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas rhodesiae | BT2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | Reduced lesion size by over 84% during the time | NA | NA | Y |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas cichorii | NT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (solid medium) | Antagonistic assay | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Romero et al. (2016) | Research in Microbiology | 167: 222-233 | Pseudomonas cichorii | NT3 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Río Grande | NA | Biocontrol assay | Desease severty | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Sanchez-Bel et al. (2016) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 7;1598 | Rhizophagus irregularis | BEG 121 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | Better Boy | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Significant reduction of necrotic lesions on leaves | NA | NA | Y |
| Ge et al. (2016) | PLoS One | 11(11): e0166079 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | NKG-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | No. 6 Zhongshu | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Inhibition of fungal growth by more than 80% | NA | NA | Y |
| Ge et al. (2016) | PLoS One | 11(11): e0166079 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | NKG-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | No. 6 Zhongshu | NA | Greenhouse | Desease severty | Reduced diameter of leaf lesion by 60% | NA | NKG-1 is controlling B.cinerea when applied as a preventive spray | Y |
| Lian et al. (2017) | BioMed Research International | Https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/9486794 | Streptomyces pratensis | LMM15 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significant reduction of mycelial growth for approx. 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| Lian et al. (2017) | BioMed Research International | Https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/9486794 | Streptomyces pratensis | LMM15 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05 | Tomato | Grey mould | Maofen-8 | NA | In vivo | Desease severty | Reduction by 46.35%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Lim et al. (2017) | The Plant Pathology Journal | 33 : 488-498 | Bacillus velezensis | G341 | Bacillomycin L and fengycin A; dimethylsulfoxide; 1-butanol; and 3-hydroxy-2-butanone (acetoin) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro (dual-culture analysis) | Antifungal activity | Significant reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Lim et al. (2018) | The Plant Pathology Journal | 33 : 488-498 | Bacillus velezensis | G341 | Bacillomycin L and fengycin A; dimethylsulfoxide; 1-butanol; and 3-hydroxy-2-butanone (acetoin) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vivo | Antifungal activity | Control value of 82% with 1-fold liquid culture filtrate dilution | NA | NA | Y |
| Masmoudi et al. (2017) | Microbial Research | 197: 29-38 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | BLB371 (wild type) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Significant antifungal activity (250 AU/mL) | NA | NA | Y |
| Masmoudi et al. (2017) | Microbial Research | 197: 29-38 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | BLB371 (wild type) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | Cerasiforme | NA | Bioassay | Desease severty | Reduced of necrosis by 64% when Bacillus spores are applied and 78% when supernatant was applied | NA | NA | Y |
| Masmoudi et al. (2017) | Microbial Research | 197: 29-38 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | M3-7 (strains with random mutagenesis) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | The growth inhibition is improved by 12 fold; compared to wild type ( BLB371) | NA | Combination of proper medium and random mutagenesis improved biocontrol abilities | Y |
| Masmoudi et al. (2017) | Microbial Research | 197: 29-38 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | M3-7 (strains with random mutagenesis) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | Cerasiforme | NA | Bioassay | Desease severty | Total reduction of necrosis; compared to wild type ( BLB371) | NA | Combination of proper medium and random mutagenesis improved biocontrol abilities | Y |
| Sarrocco et al. (2017) | Phytopathology | 107: 537-544 | Trichoderma virens | I10 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | SAS 56 | Tomato | Grey mould | Micro-Tom | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | Significantly (p<0.001) reduced number of necrotic lesions | The constitutive gene for endopolygalacturonase (TvPG2) of Trichoderma is respnsible to trigger plant immune response. | NA | Y |
| Gomes et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Plant Science | 8: 880 | Trichoderma harzianum | Comparation of wild type and Δ1epl-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Expression level of representative B05.10 virulence genes | T. harzianum Epl-1 down-regulates the expression of B. cinerea virulence genes after hyphal contact | NA | NA | Y |
| Gomes et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Plant Science | 8: 880 | Trichoderma harzianum | Comparation of wild type and Δ1epl-1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Marmande | NA | In vivo (hydroponic culture) | Expression levels of five tomato marker genes involved in the SA- (PR1b1 and PR-P2) or JA/ET(PINI; PINII; and TomLoxA) mediated signaling pathways | T. harzianum Epl-1 protein up-regulates the expression of PR-P2; a gene involved in SA-mediated response | PR-P2 Is also down-regulated in tomato hydroponic cultures Inoculated with 1epl-1 mutant | NA | Y |
| Hu et al. (2017) | Extremophiles | 21:789–803 | Cryptococcus laurentii | LB2 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | NA | NA | Decay incidence reduced by approx. 70.83% | NA | Biocontrol activity of the Tibetan yeast against gray mold in cherry tomato at 4 °C | Y |
| Sun et al. (2017) | Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology | 143: 191–198 | NA | NA | Ε-poly-L-lysine (ε-PL) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | 1200 and 1400 mg/L of ε-PL resulted mycelial growth by 100% and 94.96% | NA | NA | Y |
| Sun et al. (2017) | Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology | 143: 191–198 | NA | NA | Ε-poly-L-lysine (ε-PL) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Oulong | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of the lesion size by 79.07%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Soo Shin et al. (2017) | Plant Pathology Journal | 33(3) : 337-344 | Simplicillium lamellicola | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Showed control efficiency of 64.7% and 82.6% at 500- and 250-fold dilutions. | NA | NA | Y |
| Rubio et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 8:2273 | Trichoderma harzianum | T34 (wild typ) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antigungal assay | Reduced colony diameter by approx. 2cm | NA | NA | Y |
| Rubio et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 8:2273 | Trichoderma harzianum | T34 (wild typ) | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Marmande | NA | In vivo | Disease severity | Reduced necrotic leaf area by approx. 40% | NA | NA | Y |
| Rubio et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 8:2273 | Trichoderma harzianum | Thmbf1 overexpressing strain | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal assay | No effect on colony diameter | NA | NA | N |
| Rubio et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 8:2273 | Trichoderma harzianum | Thmbf1 overexpressing strain | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Marmande | NA | In vivo | Disease severity | Increased susceptibility to this pathogen. | NA | NA | N |
| Garrigues et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 9:2370 | Penicillium expansum | CECT 20906 | Protein PeAfpA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT 2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal assay | Growth inhibition at minimal inhibitory concentration values 4 mg/mL | NA | NA | Y |
| Garrigues et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 9:2370 | Penicillium expansum | CECT 20906 | Protein PeAfpB | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT 2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal assay | Growth inhibition at minimal inhibitory concentration values 50 mg/mL | NA | NA | Y |
| Garrigues et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 9:2370 | Penicillium expansum | CECT 20906 | Protein PeAfpC | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT 2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal assay | Growth inhibition at minimal inhibitory concentration values >200 mg/mL | NA | NA | N |
| Garrigues et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 9:2370 | Penicillium expansum | CECT 20906 | Protein PeAfpA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | CECT 2100 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vivo | Antifungal assay | Significant (almost total) leafe demage reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2018) | International Journal of Molecular Science | 19:1371 | Bacillus subtilis | WXCDD105 | NA | Bacterial filtrate | NA | Botrytis cinerea | WD1 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Inhibition rate of 71.57% (dual culture) or 95.28% (effect of bacterial filtrate). | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2018) | International Journal of Molecular Science | 19:1371 | Bacillus subtilis | WXCDD105 | NA | Bacterial filtrate | NA | Botrytis cinerea | WD1 | Tomato | Grey mould | Dongnong 713 | NA | Greenhouse | Antifungal activity; disease severity | Reduction of symptoms by 74.7%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Sun et al. (2018) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 276: 46–53 | NA | NA | Combined bio-fungicides ε-poly-L-lysine and chitooligosaccharide | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Mycelial growth reduced by 90.22%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Sun et al. (2018) | International Journal of Food Microbiology | 276: 46–53 | NA | NA | Combined bio-fungicides ε-poly-L-lysine and chitooligosaccharide | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | B05.10 | Tomato | Grey mould | Oulong | Y | In vivo | Disease severty | Reduced diseased leaves with lesions by 66.67%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Kim et al. (2019) | Scientific Reports | 9:13533 | Streptomyces rectiviolaceus | DY46 | 32;33-didehydroroflamycoin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vivo | Disease incidence | Reduced incidence by 88.9% | NA | NA | Y |
| Rosero-Hernández et al. (2019) | Plants | 8:111 | NA | NA | 3-phenyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Reduction of germination by 87.8%; germ tube by 95.7% and sporulation by 88.9% | NA | 1000ppm | Y |
| Rosero-Hernández et al. (2019) | Plants | 8:111 | NA | NA | 3-phenyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Chonto | NA | In planta | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced leaves incidence by 53.1% and leaves severty by 25.6% | NA | 1000ppm | Y |
| Rosero-Hernández et al. (2019) | Plants | 8:111 | NA | NA | 1-Phenylethanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Chonto | NA | In planta | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced leaves incidence by 59.4% and leaves severty by 27.3% | NA | 1000ppm | Y |
| Herrera-Téllez et al. (2019) | International Journal of Molecular Science | 20:2007 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Vita | NA | In vivo | Disease severty | Reduced lesion size by approx. 25% | NA | Inhibition of reactive oxygen species production (ROS) | Y |
| Wang et al. (2019) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry | 67: 6748-6756 | NA | NA | Protein FEAP (purified from Fagopyrum esculentum) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Dose dependent germination inhibition by approx. 30% to 90%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2019) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry | 67: 6748-6756 | NA | NA | Protein FEAP (purified from Fagopyrum esculentum) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Dose dependent mycelial growth inhibition by approx. 20% to 90%. | NA | NA | Y |
| Wang et al. (2019) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry | 67: 6748-6756 | NA | NA | Protein FEAP (purified from Fagopyrum esculentum) | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | Jinpengwuxian | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severty | Significant reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Liu et al. (2019) | Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry | 67: 6116-6124 | NA | NA | Melatonin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | ACCC 36028 | Tomato | Grey mould | La-bi | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severty | Significant reduction of necrotic lesions (particularly at 50 µM) | Melatonin induces disease resistance by activating jasmonicacid signaling pathway | NA | Y |
| Ji et al. (2019) | Plant Disease | 103: 1991-1997 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | TA-1 | NA | NA | Fluopimomide (fungicide) | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antigfungal activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 67.09% | Effect is higher by combined treatment of fluopimomide and B. methylotrophicus TA-1. | NA | Y |
| Ji et al. (2019) | Plant Disease | 103: 1991-1997 | Bacillus methylotrophicus | TA-1 | NA | NA | Fluopimomide (fungicide) | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Jinpengwuxian | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severty | Reduced disease severty by 58.8% | Effect is higher by combined treatment of fluopimomide and B. methylotrophicus TA-1. | NA | Y |
| Li et al. (2019) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 157: 110962 | NA | NA | Melatonin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | No. 3 Zhengyinfen | NA | In vivo | Symptome severy | Significantly reduced lesion diameter | Improved a reactive oxygen species (ROS) burst; endogenous melatonin and salicylic acid (SA); chitinase (CHI) and β-1;3-glucanase (GLU) | NA | Y |
| Li et al. (2019) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 157: 110962 | NA | NA | Melatonin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | No effect on colony diameter and spore germination | NA | NA | N |
| Barra-Bucarei et al. (2020) | Microorganisms | 8; 65 | Beauveria bassiana | RGM 393; RGM 461; RGM 547; RGM 557; RGM 565; RGM 570; RGM 632; RGM 644; RGM 657; RGM 731 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | RGM 2519 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Reduced growth by 30–36%; depending on the strain | NA | NA | Y |
| Barra-Bucarei et al. (2020) | Microorganisms | 8; 65 | Beauveria bassiana | RGM 393; RGM 461; RGM 547; RGM 557; RGM 565; RGM 570; RGM 632; RGM 644; RGM 657; RGM 731 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | RGM 2519 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In plnta | Disease incidence | Reduced symptoms by 23.1-37.5%; depending on the strain | NA | NA | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Inhbition of colony diameter by approx. 72.1% | The most detected VOCs: ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | Datterini | NA | In vivo | NA | Reduced the incidence by 67% | NA | Artificially inoculated with B. cinerea conidial suspension | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium melanogenum | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Inhbition of colony diameter by approx. 39% | NA | NA | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium melanogenum | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | Datterini | NA | In vivo | NA | Reduced the incidence by38.4% | NA | Artificially inoculated with B. cinerea conidial suspension | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium subglaciale | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Inhbition of colony diameter until approx. 30% | NA | NA | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2020) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 36:171 | Aureobasidium subglaciale | NA | Ethanol; 3-methyl-1-butanol; 2-methyl-1-propanol | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | Bc1 | Tomato | Grey mould | Datterini | NA | In vivo | NA | Reduced the incidence by 49.2% | NA | Artificially inoculated with B. cinerea conidial suspension | Y |
| Li et al. (2020) | Plant disease | 104: 1298-1304 | Trichoderma atroviride | CCTCCSBW0199 | NA | NA | Brassinolides | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Reduced colony diameter by approx. 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| Li et al. (2020) | Plant disease | 104: 1298-1304 | Trichoderma atroviride | CCTCCSBW0199 | NA | NA | Brassinolides | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Zhongshu No. 5 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced desease spots on leaves by approx. 70% | Induced defense response-related enzyme; such as peroxidase; superoxide dismutase; catalase; and phenylalanine ammonia-lyase were increased in tomato plants treated with a Trichoderma sp. + BR | NA | Y |
| Toral et al. (2020) | Microorganisms | 8; 992 | Bacillus velezensis | XT1 | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | Mina | NA | In vivo | Antifungal activity | Reduction of disease incidence by 50% anddisease severty by 60% | NA | NA | Y |
| Zhao et al. (2020) | Post-harvest Biology and Technology | 162: 111112 | Saccharomyces cerevisiae | EBY100 | Flagellin | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Cherry tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severty | Induced disease resistance | NA | NA | Y |
| Zouari et al. (2020) | Antonie van Leeuwenhoek | Https://doi.org/10.1007/s10482-020-01481-8(0123456789().;-volV() 0123458697().;-volV) | Bacillus; Alcaligenes; Providencia and Ochrobactrum | NA | NA | Compost extract | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Total growth inhibition | NA | NA | Y |
| Zouari et al. (2020) | Antonie van Leeuwenhoek | Https://doi.org/10.1007/s10482-020-01481-8(0123456789().;-volV() 0123458697().;-volV) | Bacillus; Alcaligenes; Providencia and Ochrobactrum | NA | NA | Compost extract | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Tomato | Grey mould | NA | NA | In vivo | Disease inhibition | Improved by more than 50% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Azoxystrobin | 23.2% a. i. | Ortiva | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 55.7% | Efficacy did not improve when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Acibenzolar-S-methyl | 50% a.i.; WG | Bion 50WG | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment when applied at 0.025 g/L; DS reduction by 59.9% | Efficacy did not improve when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Phosethyl-Al | 80% a.i | Alliette | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 57.8% | Efficacy did not improve when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Glucohumate complex | Gluco inductor GlucoActivator; N 4%; P₂O₅ 18% | NA | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 52.4% | Efficacy did not improve when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Mineral fertilizer | Alexin 95PS; P₂O₅ 52%; K₂O₄ 2% | Alexin 95PS; | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 69.2% | Efficacy did not improve when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | NA | NA | Brassica carinatade fatted seed meal | Biofence; N organic 3%; P 22%; K 2%; organic C 52% - pellets | Biofence | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | No effect when applied once seven days before transplanting | 56% efficancy when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | Bacillus subtilis | QST 713 | NA | 14.6% a.i. | Serenade Max | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 30.7% | 42.7% efficacy when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | Bacillus velezensis | IT45 | NA | 0.95 | Cilus Plus IT45 | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction is similar to the inoculated and untreated control. | 46% efficacy when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | Trichoderma asperellum + Trichoderma gamsii | NA | NA | WP | Remedier | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction by 32.8 | 38.3%; efficacy when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Crop protection | 85: 23-32 | Microbial complex of Trichoderma and Bacillus | NA | NA | Glomus spp. 5%; Bacillus megaterium 10⁴ UFCg¯¹; Trichoderma 10¹⁰ UFCg¯¹; | Rizocore | F.oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | MYA3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla | Y | Greenhouse | Disease severty | In pre-planting treatment the reduction is similar to the inoculated and untreated control. | 38.3%; efficacy when an extra treatment was applied after transplanting | NA | Y |
| Innocenti et al. (2015) | BioControl | 60: 573–581 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | Granules | RootShield Granules | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | 365.07 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | NA | NA | In vitro | Antifungal activity | Inhibition | NA | NA | Y |
| Innocenti et al. (2015) | BioControl | 60: 573–581 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | Granules | RootShield Granules | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | 365.07 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Duke type Iceberg | NA | Mesocosm assays | Disease severty | Reduced by 57 and 78 % in dry and wet conditions; respectively. | Plant biomass was increased by T22 under both moisture levels. | Mesocosm assays under extreme soil water content available for plants | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium.oxysporum | Fo251/2 | NA | NA | Biofox product | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium.oxysporum | Fo251/2 | NA | NA | Biofox product | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium.oxysporum | Fo251/2 | NA | NA | Biofox product | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | NA | RootShield Granules | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | 3 g/l of substrate provided very consistent results and showed the best results | Increased growth response In the presence of a very high disease incidence | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | NA | RootShield Granules | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | 3g/l of substrate provided very consistent results and showed the best results | Increased growth response In the presence of a very high disease incidence | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum | T22 | NA | NA | RootShield Granules | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | 3 g/l of substrate provided very consistent results and showed the best results | Increased growth response In the presence of a very high disease incidence | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Streptomyces griseoviridis strain | K61 | NA | NA | Mycostop | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Streptomyces griseoviridis strain | K61 | NA | NA | Mycostop | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Streptomyces griseoviridis strain | K61 | NA | NA | Mycostop | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | Fo47 | NA | NA | Microsan | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | Fo47 | NA | NA | Microsan | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | Fo47 | NA | NA | Microsan | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum strain ICC012+ T. viride | T. harzianum ICC012 | NA | NA | Remedier | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum strain ICC012+ T. viride | T. harzianum ICC012 | NA | NA | Remedier | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma harzianum strain ICC012+ T. viride | T. harzianum ICC012 | NA | NA | Remedier | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma viride | TV1 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma viride | TV1 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Trichoderma viride | TV1 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium. oxysporum MSA35 | MSA35 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum MSA35 | MSA35 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum MSA35 | MSA35 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 3 g/l of substrate | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | IF23 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Lattuga verde | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 2-3 g/l of substrate | Two out of five trials reduced the biomass produced. | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | IF23 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Foglia di quercia rossa | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 2-3 g/l of substrate | Two out of five trials reduced the biomass produced. | NA | N |
| Gilardi et al. (2007) | Phytoparasitica | 35: 457-465 | Fusarium oxysporum | IF23 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | FOL 10 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Batavia gentilina | Y | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Significant results at 2-3 g/l of substrate | Two out of five trials reduced the biomass produced. | NA | N |
| Chitarra et al. (2013) | Online https://iris.unito.it/retrieve/handle/2318/146952/25138/136%20PUGLIESE.pdf | NA | NA | NA | Potassium silicate | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Sligh reduction of disease severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Pseudomonas sp. | FC6B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 13.1%. | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 16% | Showed interesting results on pathogen control; but their performance was still variable throughout the trial | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Pseudomonas putida | FC7B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 15% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 19.3% | Showed interesting results on pathogen control; but their performance was still variable throughout the trial | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Pseudomonas sp. | FC8B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 14% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 18.3% | Showed interesting results on pathogen control; but their performance was still variable throughout the trial | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Pseudomonas sp. | FC9B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 16.7% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 21.1% | Showed interesting results on pathogen control; but their performance was still variable throughout the trial | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Pseudomonas sp. | FC24B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 12.4% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 14.9% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Fusarium oxysporum | 251/2 | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 13% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 17.1% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | F. oxysporum | MSA35 | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 10.5% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 14.5% | It is important to consider that; when antagonistic Fusarium strains are used; they may displace pathogenic Fusarium species rather than eradicate infections already present in the seeds | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Bacillus subtilis | QST713 | NA | NA | Serenade | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 11.2% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 15% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | B. subtilis BA41; Streptomyces sp. SB15; Trichoderma harzianum TH02; Pseudomonas proradix 10; Glomus caledonium GM24 Glomus coronatum GU53; Gladius intraradices GB67; Trichoderma spp | NA | NA | NA | Eko Seed | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 13.6% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 16.4% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Streptomyces griseoviridis | NA | NA | NA | Mycostop | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 8.5% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 9.8% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Streptomyces spp. SB14; G. coronatum GO01; G. coronatum GU53; G. caledonium GM24; B. subtilis SR63; Pseudomonas spp. PM46; Ulocladium spp. UO18 | NA | NA | NA | Micosat F | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 8.1% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 11.3% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Trichoderma harzianum ICC012; Trichoderma viridae ICC080 | NA | NA | NA | Remedier | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 15% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 18.3% | NA | Y |
| Lopez-Reyes et al. (2014) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 96: 535-539 | Trichoderm harzianum mix of mycorrhyzal non specified strains | NA | NA | NA | Rizocore | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | FUSLAT 10 RB | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Crispilla Blanca | NA | Glasshouse | Disease severty | Disease index reduced for approx. 12.9% | Number of infected plants reduced for approx. 16.4% | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2016) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection | 124: 361–368 | NA | NA | Dimethyl disulfide | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Analena Sintia | Y | Field experiments | Disease severty | Disease severty was ranging from 44.9 to 78.0% during 3 tials | Reduced symptoms by 70; 97 and 99% during 3 trials (60 g/m² of DMDS ) | Soil disinfestation treatments with dimethyl disulfide | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2017) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection | 124: 361–369 | NA | NA | Dimethyl disulfide | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Badina | Y | Field experiments | Disease severty | Disease severty was ranging from 44.9 to 78.0% during 3 tials | Reduced symptoms by 70; 97 and 99% during 3 trials (60 g/m² of DMDS) | Soil disinfestation treatments with dimethyl disulfide | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2017) | Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection | 124: 361–370 | NA | NA | Dimethyl disulfide | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | . Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | Field experiments | Disease severty | Disease severty was ranging from 21.9 to 50.8% during 3 tials the | Reduced symptoms by 87; 96.8 and 100% during 3 trials (60 g/m² of DMDS) | Soil disinfestation treatments with dimethyl disulfide | Y |
| Thongkamngam and Jaenaksorn (2017) | Plant Protection Science | 53: 85-95 | Fusarium oxysporum | F221-B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | F221-R | Lettuce | Fusarium root rot and wilt | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 42%; after 9 days after inoculation | NA | NA | Y |
| Thongkamngam and Jaenaksorn (2017) | Plant Protection Science | 53: 85-95 | Fusarium oxysporum | F221-B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | F221-G | Lettuce | Fusarium root rot and wilt | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Reduced mycelial growth by 38.8%; after 9 days after inoculation | NA | NA | Y |
| Thongkamngam and Jaenaksorn (2015) | Plant Protection Science | 53: 85-93 | Fusarium oxysporum | F221-B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | F422-G | Lettuce | Fusarium root rot and wilt | Butterhead | NA | Hydroponic culture | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence and severty by 64% | NA | NA | Y |
| Thongkamngam and Jaenaksorn (2016) | Plant Protection Science | 53: 85-94 | Fusarium oxysporum | F221-B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | F422-G | Lettuce | Fusarium root rot and wilt | Cos | NA | Hydroponic culture | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence and severty by 85.3% | NA | NA | Y |
| Thongkamngam and Jaenaksorn (2017) | Plant Protection Science | 53: 85-95 | Fusarium oxysporum | F221-B | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum f.sp. lactucae | F422-G | Lettuce | Fusarium root rot and wilt | Red Oak | NA | Hydroponic culture | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence and severty by 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| El-Sayed et al. (2018) | Bioscience Research | 15: 602-609 | Trichoderma asperellum | T34 | NA | NA | T34-Biocontrol | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | AUMC10895 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Aviram | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence for 33.33% | Reduced disease severity for 42.22% | NA | Y |
| El-Sayed et al. (2018) | Bioscience Research | 15: 602-609 | Trichoderma asperellum | T34 | NA | NA | T34-Biocontrol | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | AUMC10895 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Aviram | NA | Field experiments | NA | Reduced disease incidence for 34.26% and 26.45% during two seasons | Reduced disease incidence for 24.45% and 26.67% during two seasons | The unsatisfactory results of T34 biocontrol in the field May be contributed to the climatic variations; the biocontrol agent has poor competence and the product is unstable | N |
| El-Sayed et al. (2018) | Bioscience Research | 15: 602-609 | Three strains of Bacillus polymyxa; two strains of B.macerans; one strain of B. circulans and one strain of Enterobacter agglomerans | NA | NA | NA | ESRU-Bio control | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | AUMC10895 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Aviram | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence for 26.67% | Reduced disease severity for 26.66% | NA | Y |
| El-Sayed et al. (2018) | Bioscience Research | 15: 602-609 | Un-commercial blue-green algal extract in liquid phase entrapping Anabaena flos aquae and Nostoc muscorum | NA | NA | NA | Algae extract | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | AUMC10895 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Aviram | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence and severty | Reduced disease incidence for 13.33% | Reduced disease severity for 20% | NA | Y |
| Alamri et al. (2019) | Biological control | 128: 76-84 | Trichoderma harzianum | JF419706 | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum | HQ905450 | Lettuce | Root rot | Paris Island | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced by 29.2% on 25 days old plants and by 20.9% on 50 days old plants | Application of both microorganism reduced disease severty by 37.5% on 25 days old plants and 29.2% on 50 days old plants | NA | Y |
| Alamri et al. (2019) | Biological control | 128: 76-84 | Bacillus subtilis | HQ656002 | NA | NA | NA | F. oxysporum | HQ905450 | Lettuce | Root rot | Paris Island | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced by 25% on 25 or 50 days old | NA | NA | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Surfactin | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Iturin A | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | Significant reduction of growth from concentration 12.5 mg/L | NA | NA | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Surfactin | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Patriot (crisphead lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 3.75 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Iturin A | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Patriot (crisphead lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0;94 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Surfactin | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Costa Rica No. 4 (romaine lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 3.75 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Iturin A | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Costa Rica No. 4 (romaine lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0;94 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Surfactin | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Hawai No. 2 (red leaf lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0.94 mg/l and 3.75 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Iturin A | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Hawai No. 2 (red leaf lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0;94 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Surfactin | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Marino (green leaf lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0.94 mg/l; 3.75 mg/l and 7.5 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Fujita and Yokota (2019) | Disease control | 85: 44-48 | Bacillus subtilis | ATCC21556 | Iturin A | NA | NA | Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | F9501 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Marino (green leaf lettuce) | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduction of disease severity with conc. 0;94 mg/l | NA | Methabolite applied by soil amendment | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | Bacillus subtilis | QST 713 | NA | NA | Serenade max | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 60% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | Trichoderma asperellum + Trichoderma gamssi | NA | NA | NA | Remedier | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 54% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | Pseudomonas putida | FC7B + FC8B + FC9B | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 49% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | Trichoderma sp. TW2 | NA | NA | Green compost | ANT’s compost M | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 69% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | ANT's compost V | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 51% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | NA | NA | Azoxystrobin | NA | Ortiva | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 64% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cucu et al. (2019) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 126: 905-918 | Trichoderma sp. | TW2 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelsky | Y/N (moderate) | In situ | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 44% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Bacillus subtilis | QST 713 | NA | NA | Serenade max | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 35 and 39.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Bacillus subtilis | QST 713 | NA | NA | Serenade max | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 30.6 and 18.2 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Bacillus subtilis | QST 713 | NA | NA | Serenade max | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 54.4 42.5 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Trichoderma asperellum +Trichoderma gamssi | NA | NA | NA | Remedier | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 31.1 and 40 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Trichoderma asperellum +Trichoderma gamssi | NA | NA | NA | Remedier | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 29.4 16.3 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Trichoderma asperellum +Trichoderma gamssi | NA | NA | NA | Remedier | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 31.9 30.6 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Pseudomonas spp. | 9FC | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 31.3 28.8 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Pseudomonas spp. | 9FC | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 32.5 19.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Pseudomonas spp. | 9FC | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 41.2 24.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Fusarium oxysporum | MSA | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 35.6 34.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Fusarium oxysporum | MSA | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 33.8 16.9 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | Fusarium oxysporum | MSA | NA | NA | Agroinnova | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 36.2 30.6 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Acibenzolar‐S‐methy | NA | Bion 50WG | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 38.1 50.3 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Acibenzolar‐S‐methy | NA | Bion 50WG | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 36.9 24.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Acibenzolar‐S‐methy | NA | Bion 50WG | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 48.1 46.9 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Potassium phosphite P:K 52:42 | NA | Alexin | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 47.5 45.7 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Potassium phosphite P:K 52:42 | NA | Alexin | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 38.1 23.2 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Potassium phosphite P:K 52:42 | NA | Alexin | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 46.2 41.9 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Phosetyl-Aluminium | NA | Aliette | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 51.9 55 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Phosetyl-Aluminium | NA | Aliette | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 41.9 28.2 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Phosetyl-Aluminium | NA | Aliette | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 40 43.1 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Ant's compost 5015V | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 45 66.9 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Ant's compost 5015V | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 40.6 36.9 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Ant's compost 5015V | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 48.1 52.5 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Compost 214 | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 36.3 31.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Compost 214 | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 39.4 24.4 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Green compost | Compost 214 | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 44.2 40 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2017) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-108 | NA | NA | NA | Animal bone biochar | ABC | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 39.3 45 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2018) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-109 | NA | NA | NA | Animal bone biochar | ABC | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 35 28.8 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | NA | Animal bone biochar | ABC | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 30.8 30.6 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2017) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-108 | NA | NA | Azoxystrobin | NA | Ortiva | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Novelski | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 60 and 51.3 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2018) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-109 | NA | NA | Azoxystrobin | NA | Ortiva | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Volare | Less than Novelski and Gentilina | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 48.8 30.7 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gilardi et al. (2019) | Journal of Phytopathology | 167: 98-110 | NA | NA | Azoxystrobin | NA | Ortiva | F. oxysporum f. sp. lactucae | Mya3040 | Lettuce | Fusarium wilt | Gentilina | Y/N (moderate) | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Reduced for 46.2 57.5 in two trials | NA | Artificially infested | Y |
| Gallou et al. (2011) | Physiological and Molecular Plant Pathology | 76: 20-26 | Rhizophagus irregularis | MUCL 41833 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | MUCL 43257 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Surface of leaf damage - leaf infection index | Reduction of the leaf infection index after 1; 2; and 4 days | NA | NA | Y |
| Gallou et al. (2011) | Physiological and Molecular Plant Pathology | 76: 20-26 | Rhizophagus irregularis | MUCL 41833 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | MUCL 43258 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | AUDPC | Redcution of the AUDPC by 21% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gallou et al. (2011) | Physiological and Molecular Plant Pathology | 76: 20-26 | Rhizophagus irregularis | MUCL 41833 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | MUCL 43259 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Gene expression in potato (ERF3; GST1; Lox; MAPK; PAL; PR1 and PR2) | Induction of PR1 and PR2 genes in the leaves of AM potato plants inoculated with the foliar pathogen; which indicated that the AM fungal systemic resistance to this pathogen was associated to the induction of these two PR genes | Elicitation effect | NA | Y |
| An et al. (2010) | Crop Protection | 29: 1406-1412 | 126 PGPR (plant growth promoting rhizobacteria) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC40718 | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Pot | Disease severity + growth promotion | Disease severiry decreased by 20-25% with 4 PGPR | The most effective bacterial isolates Burkholderia gladioli TRH423-3; Miamiensis avidus TRH427-2; Acinetobacter quenomosp KRJ502-1; Bacillus cereus KRY505-3 | Increase in callose formation | Y |
| An et al. (2010) | Crop Protection | 29: 1406-1412 | 126 PGPR (plant growth promoting rhizobacteria) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC40718 | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Pot | Plant growth promotion | Growth promotion with the strain THR427-2 | NA | NA | Y |
| An et al. (2010) | Crop Protection | 29: 1406-1412 | NA | NA | DL-3-amino butyric acid (BABA) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC40718 | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Pot | Disease severity | Leaf damages reduced by 50% | Increase in callose formation | NA | Y |
| An et al. (2010) | Crop Protection | 29: 1406-1412 | NA | NA | DL-3-amino butyric acid (BABA) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC40718 | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Pot | Plant growth promotion | No enhanced growth of the plant | NA | NA | N |
| Andreu et al. (2006) | Pest management science | 62: 162-170 | NA | NA | DL-3-amino butyric acid (BABA) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | R2R3R6R7R9; matingtype A2 | Potato | Late blight | Kennebec | Y | In vitro | Growth on tuber + disease severity in whole tubers | Strong reduction of growth on tuber | Reduction of disease severity by 3 times | NA | Y |
| Andreu et al. (2006) | Pest management science | 62: 162-170 | NA | NA | DL-3-amino butyric acid (BABA) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | R2R3R6R7R9; matingtype A2 | Potato | Late blight | Russet Brubank | N | In vitro | Disease severity in whole tubers | NA | Reduction of disease severity by 2;5 times | NA | Y |
| Andreu et al. (2006) | Pest management science | 62: 162-170 | NA | NA | DL-3-amino butyric acid (BABA) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | R2R3R6R7R9; matingtype A2 | Potato | Late blight | Ranger Russet | N | In vitro | Disease severity in whole tubers | NA | No reduction of disease severity | NA | N |
| Andreu et al. (2006) | Pest management science | 62: 162-170 | NA | NA | DL-3-amino butyric acid (BABA) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | R2R3R6R7R9; matingtype A2 | Potato | Late blight | Shepody | Y | In vitro | Growth on tuber + disease severity in whole tubers | Strong reduction of growth on tuber | Reduction of disease severity by 3 times | NA | Y |
| Andreu et al. (2006) | Pest management science | 62: 162-170 | NA | NA | Fosetyl-aluminium | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | R2R3R6R7R9; matingtype A2 | Potato | Late blight | Kennebec | Y | In vitro | Growth on tuber + disease severity in whole tubers | Strong reduction of growth on tuber | Reduction of disease severity by 3 times | NA | Y |
| Andreu et al. (2006) | Pest management science | 62: 162-170 | NA | NA | Fosetyl-aluminium | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | R2R3R6R7R9; matingtype A2 | Potato | Late blight | Russet Brubank | N | In vitro | Disease severity in whole tubers | NA | Reduction of disease severity by 2;5 times | NA | Y |
| Andreu et al. (2006) | Pest management science | 62: 162-170 | NA | NA | Fosetyl-aluminium | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | R2R3R6R7R9; matingtype A2 | Potato | Late blight | Ranger Russet | N | In vitro | Disease severity in whole tubers | NA | No reduction of disease severity | NA | N |
| Andreu et al. (2006) | Pest management science | 62: 162-170 | NA | NA | Fosetyl-aluminium | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | R2R3R6R7R9; matingtype A2 | Potato | Late blight | Shepody | Y | In vitro | Growth on tuber + disease severity in whole tubers | Strong reduction of growth on tuber | Reduction of disease severity by 5 times | NA | Y |
| Bae et al. (2016) | Biological control | 92: 128-138 | NA | NA | Ethyl-acetate extracts from 128 Trichoderma species | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC 43071 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonism test | 8 filtrates showed 100% inhibitory effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Bae et al. (2016) | Biological control | 92: 128-138 | NA | NA | Filtrates from Trichoderma atroviride KACC 40552 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC 43071 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Minimum inbitory concentration + disk diffusion test + antibiosis test | MIC: 100 µg/10ml | DD: 8% inhibition | AB test: 27% inhibition | N |
| Bae et al. (2016) | Biological control | 92: 128-138 | NA | NA | Filtrates from Trichoderma gamsii KACC 40553 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC 43071 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Minimum inbitory concentration + disk diffusion test + antibiosis test | MIC: 100 µg/10ml | DD: 7% inhibition | AB test: 62% inhibition | N |
| Bae et al. (2016) | Biological control | 92: 128-138 | NA | NA | Filtrates from Trichoderma atroviride KACC 40557 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC 43071 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Minimum inbitory concentration + disk diffusion test + antibiosis test | MIC: 100 µg/10ml | DD: 13% inhibition | AB test: 57% inhibition | N |
| Bae et al. (2016) | Biological control | 92: 128-138 | NA | NA | Filtrates from Trichoderma harzianum KACC 40871 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC 43071 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Minimum inbitory concentration + disk diffusion test + antibiosis test | MIC: 100 µg/10ml | DD: 16% inhibition | AB test: 7% inhibition | N |
| Bae et al. (2016) | Biological control | 92: 128-138 | NA | NA | Filtrates from Trichoderma virens KACC 40929 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC 43071 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Minimum inbitory concentration + disk diffusion test + antibiosis test | MIC: 10 µg/10ml | DD: 69% inhibition | AB test: 100% inhibition | Y |
| Bae et al. (2016) | Biological control | 92: 128-138 | NA | NA | Filtrates from Trichoderma brevicompactum KACC 40931 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC 43071 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Minimum inbitory concentration + disk diffusion test + antibiosis test | MIC: 1 µg/10ml | DD: 93% inhibition | AB test: 66% inhibition | Y |
| Bae et al. (2016) | Biological control | 92: 128-138 | NA | NA | Filtrates from Trichoderma brevicompactum KACC 41707 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC 43071 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Minimum inbitory concentration + disk diffusion test + antibiosis test | MIC: 1 µg/10ml | DD: 81% inhibition | AB test: 34% inhibition | Y |
| Bae et al. (2016) | Biological control | 92: 128-138 | NA | NA | Filtrates from Trichoderma virens KACC 41717 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | KACC 43071 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Minimum inbitory concentration + disk diffusion test + antibiosis test | MIC: 1 µg/10ml | DD: 87% inhibition | AB test: 67% inhibition | Y |
| Cooke and Little (2001) | Pest Management Science | 58: 17-25 | NA | NA | Fosetyl-aluminium | NA | Aliette | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Pot / in vitro | Disease incidence in whole tubers | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Cooke and Little (2001) | Pest Management Science | 58: 17-25 | NA | NA | Fosetyl-aluminium | NA | Aliette | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | King Edward | N | Pot / in vitro | Disease incidence in whole tubers | Reduction by 20% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cooke and Little (2001) | Pest Management Science | 58: 17-25 | NA | NA | Fosetyl-aluminium | NA | Aliette | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Russet Burbank | N | Pot / in vitro | Disease incidence in whole tubers | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Cooke and Little (2001) | Pest Management Science | 58: 17-25 | NA | NA | Phosphonic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Pot / in vitro | Disease incidence in whole tubers | Reduction by 50% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cooke and Little (2001) | Pest Management Science | 58: 17-25 | NA | NA | Phosphonic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | King Edward | N | Pot / in vitro | Disease incidence in whole tubers | No significant reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Cooke and Little (2001) | Pest Management Science | 58: 17-25 | NA | NA | Phosphonic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Russet Burbank | N | Pot / in vitro | Disease incidence in whole tubers | Reduction by ±60% | NA | NA | Y |
| Cooke and Little (2001) | Pest Management Science | 58: 17-25 | NA | NA | Fosetyl-aluminium | NA | Aliette | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Dundrod | NA | Field | Disease incidence on tubers | No effect on blight | NA | NA | N |
| Cooke and Little (2001) | Pest Management Science | NA | NA | NA | Fosetyl-aluminium | NA | Aliette | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Field | Disease incidence on tubers | No effect on blight | NA | NA | N |
| Cooke and Little (2001) | Pest Management Science | 58: 17-25 | NA | NA | Phosphonic acid (potassium phosphonate or dipotassium phosphoate) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Dundrod | NA | Field | Disease incidence on tubers | Tuber blight reduction at a concentration of 4 kg/ha | 2 applications are better than 1 application to control tuber blight (40% reduction) | 5 to 6 sprays of phosphonic acid (2 kg/ha) at intervals 10-14 days resulted in the least tuber infection (but not economical). In trials where the effect of timing and rate of application was studied (2-4 kg/ha); a single treatment of 4 kg/ha applied mid- or late season proved the most effective | Y |
| Cooke and Little (2001) | Pest Management Science | 58: 17-25 | NA | NA | Phosphonic acid (potassium phosphonate or dipotassium phosphoate) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Field | Disease incidence on tubers | Tuber blight reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Chowdappa et al. (2013) | Biological Control | 65: 109-117 | Bacillus subtilis | OTPB1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | PIT 30 | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonism test | Pathogen growth 7 times reduced | NA | NA | Y |
| Chowdappa et al. (2013) | Biological Control | 65: 109-117 | Trichoderma harzianum | OTPB3 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | PIT 30 | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonism test | Pathogen growth 3;9 times reduced | NA | NA | Y |
| Chowdappa et al. (2013) | Biological Control | 65: 109-117 | Bacillus subtilis | OTPB1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | PIT 30 | Tomato | Late blight | Arka vikas | Y | Pot | Growth of plant + ability of BCA and host to produce growth hormone + defence enzymes + disease incidence | Plant growth increase (DW; leaf area; root growth) | BCA produce growth hormone (IAA + GA3) + induce increased production in plant + PPA/POD/SOD activities increased | Infection level 3;1 times reduced | Y |
| Chowdappa et al. (2013) | Biological Control | 65: 109-117 | Trichoderma harzianum | OTPB3 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | PIT 30 | Tomato | Late blight | Arka vikas | Y | Pot | Growth of plant + ability of BCA and host to produce growth hormone + defence enzymes + disease incidence | Plant growth increase (DW; leaf area; root growth) | BCA produce growth hormone (IAA + GA3) + induce increased production in plant + PPA/POD/SOD activities increased | Infection level 5 times reduced | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2017) | Biological Control | 114: 144-149 | Aureobasidium pullulans | L1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonism test | Antagonism test: colonie growth 2;8 times reduced | NA | NA | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2017) | Biological Control | 114: 144-149 | Aureobasidium pullulans | L1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Marmande | NA | Pot | AUDPC | AUDPC reduced 1;4-1;6 times | Application of BCA 24h before or 16 h after pathogen application is effective; The application of BCA before application of pathogen is more effective. | Production of B-1-3 glucanase increased | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2017) | Biological Control | 114: 144-149 | Aureobasidium pullulans | L8 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonism test | Antagonism test: colonie growth 2;5 times reduced | NA | NA | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2017) | Biological Control | 114: 144-149 | Aureobasidium pullulans | L8 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Marmande | NA | Pot | AUDPC | AUDPC reduced 1;4-2;5 times | Application of BCA 24h before or 16 h after pathogen application is effective; The application of BCA before application of pathogen is more effective. | Production of B-1-3 glucanase increased | Y |
| Di Francesco et al. (2017) | Biological Control | 114: 144-149 | Aureobasidium pullulans | NA | DSM14940 + DSM 14941 | NA | Botector | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Marmande | NA | Pot | AUDPC | AUDPC reduced by 40-50% | Application of BCA 24h before or 16 h after pathogen application is effective; The application of BCA before application of pathogen is more effective. | NA | Y |
| Ajay and Sunaina (2005) | Potato Journal | 32: 179-180 | Bacillus cereus | B4 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Dual test - growth of the pathogen | Growth reduction from 45;9 to 59;5% | NA | NA | Y |
| Ajay and Sunaina (2005) | Potato Journal | 32: 179-181 | Bacillus subtilis | B5 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Dual test - growth of the pathogen | Growth reduction from 67;2 to 91;2% | Most effective bioeffecteur | NA | Y |
| Ajay and Sunaina (2005) | Potato Journal | 32: 179-182 | Bacillus pentothenticus | BM11 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Dual test - growth of the pathogen | Growth reduction from 37;7 to 49;6% | NA | NA | Y |
| Kim et al. (2001) | Pest Management Science | 57: 554-559 | NA | NA | Phomalactone | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth of the pathogen - germination | IC50 : 0;83 mg/L | Minimum inhibitory concentration = 2;5 mg/L | Inhibition of zoospore germination and sporangial germination from 8 to 12 mg/L | Y |
| Kim et al. (2001) | Pest Management Science | 57: 554-559 | NA | NA | 5;6-dihydro--5-hydroxy-6-prop-2-enyl--2H-pyrane-2-one produit par Nigrospora sphaerica T3 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Seokwang | NA | In vivo | Disease rating | Reduced by 37% at 100 mg/L and 87% at 500 mg/L before inoculation and 14% to 51% 1 day after inoculation | Effective only when applied 1 day before or after inoculation | NA | Y |
| Kim et al. (2004) | Pest Management Science | 60: 803-808 | NA | NA | Methanol extract of 183 plants | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Seokwang | NA | In vivo | Disease rating | 4 plant extracts are efficient >90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus amyloliquefasciens | AB05 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | 72% of inhibition of mycelial growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus amyloliquefasciens | AB05 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | % disease suppresion | 62% of disease suppression | Production of root + shoot increased + chlorophylle content increased | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus subtilis | AB10 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | 72% of inhibition of mycelial growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus subtilis | AB10 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | % disease suppresion | 56% of disease suppression | Production of root + shoot increased + chlorophylle content increased | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus sp. | AB11 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | 80% of inhibition of mycelial growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus sp. | AB11 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | % disease suppresion | 63% of disease suppression | Production of root + shoot increased + chlorophylle content increased | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus subtilis | AB12 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | 80% of inhibition of mycelial growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus subtilis | AB12 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | % disease suppresion | 65% of disease suppression | Production of root + shoot increased + chlorophylle content increased | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus subtilis | AB14 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | 65% of inhibition of mycelial growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus subtilis | AB14 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | % disease suppresion | 24% of disease suppression | Production of root + shoot increased + chlorophylle content increased | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Paenibacillus polymyxa | AB15 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | 82% of inhibition of mycelial growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Paenibacillus polymyxa | AB15 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | % disease suppresion | 74% of disease suppression | Production of root + shoot increased + chlorophylle content increased | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus subtilis subsp subtilis | AB17 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | 78% of inhibition of mycelial growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Lamsal et al. (2013) | Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 23: 885-892 | Bacillus subtilis subsp subtilis | AB17 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | % disease suppresion | 61% of disease suppression | Production of root + shoot increased + chlorophylle content increased | NA | Y |
| Li et al. (2013) | Biological Control | 67: 462-468 | Epicoccum nigrum | XF1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 01-002 (mating type A1; isolated from China) | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Dual test | 51% of growth inhibition | Hyphae of P. infestans seems to be degenerated and stunted; and distorded | Sporangia germination inhibited until 100% after 72-120 hours | Y |
| Li et al. (2013) | Biological Control | 67: 462-468 | Epicoccum nigrum | XF1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 01-002 (mating type A1; isolated from China) | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | Detached leaves | Disease reduction | Diesease control efficacy from 49 to 93% from oncentration of 106 to 109 of conidia/ml suspension | NA | NA | Y |
| Li et al. (2013) | Biological Control | 67: 462-468 | Epicoccum nigrum | XF1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 01-002 (mating type A1; isolated from China) | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | 66% to 89% of control efficacy from 96 to 1 hours before inoculation | NA | NA | Y |
| Li et al. (2013) | Biological Control | 67: 462-468 | Epicoccum nigrum | XF1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 01-002 (mating type A1; isolated from China) | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | Field | Disease severity | From 19 to 78% of control efficacy from 48 to 1 jours before inoculation | No effect when applied 96 hours before inoculation | NA | Y |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | Foliar potential antagonists | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Detached leaves | Control of disease | On 208 potential antagonist isolates (from samples of leaves and stems of tomato plants cultivated in organic and conventional systems) 19 filamentous fungi; 6 bacterial; and 4 yeast isolates were selected as potential biocontrol agents | Isolate 138 (Aspergillus sp.) was effective in reducing late blight severity. In the first experiment; isolates 138; 266 (Candida sp.); and 404 (Cryptococcus sp.) reduced average late blight severity by 17.4%; 22.2%; and 32.4%; respectively | No difference in sporangia germination | Y |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | 23 rhizobacteria | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Greenhouse | AUDPC | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | Aspergillus sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Greenhouse | AUDPC | Reduction of late blight severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | Candida sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Greenhouse | Late blight severity | Reduction of late blight severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | Cellulomonas flavigena | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Greenhouse | Late blight severity | Reduction of late blight severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | Cryptococcus sp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Greenhouse | Late blight severity | Reduction of late blight severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | Aspergillus sp. + Bacillus cereus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Greenhouse | Late blight severity | Reduction of late blight severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | Candida sp. + Bacillus cereus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Greenhouse | Late blight severity | Reduction of late blight severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | Cellulomonas flavigena + Bacillus cereus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Greenhouse | Late blight severity | Reduction of late blight severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | Cryptococcus sp. + Bacillus cereus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Greenhouse | Late blight severity | Reduction of late blight severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Lourenço Junior et al. (2006) | Biological Control | 38: 331-340 | Bacillus cereus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Santa Clara | NA | Greenhouse | Late blight severity | Reduction of late blight severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Aluminium acetate | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 78% | Sporulation decreased by 99;7% | Germination decreased by 82% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Aluminum chloride | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | No effect on mycelial growth | Sporulation decreased by 100% | Germination decreased by 75% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Aluminium | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 78% | Sporulation decreased by 100% | Germination decreased by 78% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Ascorbyl palmitate C22H38O7 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 77% | Sporulation decreased by 90% | NA | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Calcium propionate C6H10CaO4 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 79% | Sporulation decreased by 100% | Germination decreased by 71% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Potassium sorbate C6H7O2K | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 95% | Sporulation decreased by 100% | Germination decreased by 67% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Sodium benzoate C7H5O2Na | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 88% | Sporulation decreased by 100% | Germination decreased by 67% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Sodium bicarbonate NaHCO3 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 79% | Sporulation decreased by 90% | Germination decreased by 66% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Sodium hypochlorite ClNaO | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 39% | Sporulation decreased by 100% | Germination decreased by 59% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Sodium metabisulfite Na2S2O5 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 79% | Sporulation decreased by 100% | Germination decreased by 80% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Sodium tartate C4H4O6Na + 2H2O | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 100% | No effect | Germination decreased by 61% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Phosphonic acid | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 53% | Sporulation decreased by 100% | Germination decreased by 75% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Propyl-paraben C10H12O3 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 100% | Sporulation decreased by 100% | Germination decreased by 65% | Y |
| Mills et al. (2004) | Postharvest Biology and Technology | 34: 341-350 | NA | Copper sulfate CuSO4 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | #1040A-4 US 8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelial growth + sporulation + germination of spores | Mycelial growth reduced by 100% | Sporulation decreased by 100% | Germination decreased by 77% | Y |
| Wang et al. (2007) | Frontiers of Agricultural China | 1: 43-46 | NA | Foliage of Galla chinensis; | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Agria | NA | Detached leaves + pot + in vitro | Control efficacy + test on tuber slices | Control efficacy at 96.67% on detached leaves | Control efficacy at 64;29% after 7 days; no effect 9 days after inoculation | No effect on P. infestans development on tuber slices | Y |
| Wang et al. (2007) | Frontiers of Agricultural China | 1: 43-46 | NA | Roots of Potentilla erecta | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Agria | NA | Box + pot (greenhouse) + in vitro | Control efficacy + test on tuber slices | No effect on detached leaves | No effect on plant | No effect on P. infestans development on tuber slices | N |
| Wang et al. (2007) | Frontiers of Agricultural China | 1: 43-46 | NA | Foliage of Rheum rhabarbarum | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Agria | NA | Box + pot (greenhouse) + in vitro | Control efficacy + test on tuber slices | No effect on detached leaves | No effect on plant | No effect on P. infestans development on tuber slices | N |
| Wang et al. (2007) | Frontiers of Agricultural China | 1: 43-46 | NA | Roots of rheum rhabarbarum | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Agria | NA | Box + pot (greenhouse) + in vitro | Control efficacy + test on tuber slices | Control efficacy at 81.11% on detached leaves | Control efficacy between 91;67 and 72;22%; 7 and 9 days after inoculation | No effect on P. infestans development on tuber slices | Y |
| Wang et al. (2007) | Frontiers of Agricultural China | 1: 43-46 | NA | Foliage of Salviae officinalis | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Agria | NA | Box + pot (greenhouse) + in vitro | Control efficacy + test on tuber slices | No effect on detached leaves | No effect on plant | No effect on P. infestans development on tuber slices | N |
| Wang et al. (2007) | Frontiers of Agricultural China | 1: 43-46 | NA | Bark of Sophora flavescens | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Agria | NA | Box + pot (greenhouse) + in vitro | Control efficacy + test on tuber slices | Control efficacy at 75.56% on detached leaves; only at 2% (no effect at 0;5 and 1%) | Control efficacy at 75% at 2% (no effect at 0;5 and 1%); 7 days after inoculation (no effect after 9 days) | No effect on P. infestans development on tuber slices | Y |
| Wang et al. (2007) | Frontiers of Agricultural China | 1: 43-46 | NA | Fruits of Terminalia chebula | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Agria | NA | Box + pot (greenhouse) + in vitro | Control efficacy + test on tuber slices | Control efficacy at 70.00% on detached leaves; only at 2% (no effect at 0;5 and 1%) | Control efficacy at 70;24% at 1% (no effect at 0;5 and 2%); 7 days after inoculation (no effect after 9 days) | No effect on P. infestans development on tuber slices | Y |
| Tran et al. (2007) | New Phytologist | 175: 731-742 | P. fluorescens | SS101 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 90128 (A2 mating type; race 1.3.4.6.7.8.10.11) | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence + effect of BCA or molecule on lesion growth + deposition of antagonists on roots and lower part of plants | Disease incidence reduced by 90% | Existing lesions did not grow as the control | When applied to lower leaves or roots or seed treatment; BCA did not reduced disease incidence but did on leasion area | Y |
| Tran et al. (2007) | New Phytologist | 175: 731-743 | NA | NA | Massetolide A (cyclic lpp) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 90128 (A2 mating type; race 1.3.4.6.7.8.10.11) | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | NA | Disease incidence reduced but less than P. florescences at the concentration 100 mg/L | Existing lesions did not grow as the control (as the BCA from the concentration 50 mg/L) | When applied to lower leaves or roots; BCA did not reduced disease incidence but did on leasion area (as BCA) | Y |
| Bengtsson et al. (2015) | Potato Research | 58:83-90 | P. koreensis 2.74 | CBS125413 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE03058 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Biotron | Biomass of pathogen on leaves + lesion | No decrease of P. infestans on leaves | No effect on lesions | NA | N |
| Bengtsson et al. (2015) | Potato Research | 58:83-90 | P. koreensis 2.74 | CBS125413 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE03058 | Potato | Late blight | Ovatio | N | Biotron | Biomass of pathogen on leaves + lesion | No decrease of P. infestans on leaves | No effect on lesions | NA | N |
| Bengtsson et al. (2015) | Potato Research | 58:83-90 | NA | NA | Biosurfactant from P. koreensis 2.74 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE03058 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Biotron | Biomass of pathogen on leaves + lesion | No decrease of P. infestans on leaves | No effect on lesions | NA | N |
| Bengtsson et al. (2015) | Potato Research | 58:83-90 | NA | NA | Biosurfactant from P. koreensis 2.74 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE03058 | Potato | Late blight | Ovatio | N | Biotron | Biomass of pathogen on leaves + lesion | Quantity of P. infestans of leaves decreased by 3 | Decrease of leasionarea | NA | Y |
| Ajay and Sunaina (2005) | Potato journal | 32: 179-180 | Bacillus cereus | B4 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Dual test | 46% of growth reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Ajay and Sunaina (2005) | Potato journal | 32: 179-181 | Bacillus subtilis | B5 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Dual test | 91% of growth reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Ajay and Sunaina (2005) | Potato journal | 32: 179-182 | Bacillus pentothenticus | BM11 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Dual test | 50% of growth reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Hultberg et al. (2010) | BioControl | 55: 543-550 | NA | NA | Biosurfactant of P. koreensis 2.74 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE03058 mating type A1 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Reduction until 88% of the growth only at the highest concentration (1 mg/ml) | No effect on the sporangia production | NA | N |
| Hultberg et al. (2010) | BioControl | 55: 543-550 | NA | NA | Biosurfactant of P. koreensis 2.74 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE03058 mating type A2 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leaves | Lesion diameter | Significant reduction in the diameter of lesions | NA | Y | |
| Hultberg et al. (2010) | BioControl | 55: 543-550 | NA | NA | Biosurfactant of P. koreensis 2.74 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE03058 mating type A3 | Potato | Late blight | Ovatio | N | Detached leaves | Lesion diameter | Significant reduction in the diameter of lesions | NA | NA | Y |
| Hultberg et al. (2010) | BioControl | 55: 543-550 | P. koreensis 2.74 | CBS 125413 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE03058 mating type A4 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leaves | Lesion diameter | Significant reduction in the diameter of lesions | Increasing the concentration of the bacteria in the suspension sprayed on the leaves did not result in increased disease reduction | NA | Y |
| Hultberg et al. (2010) | BioControl | 55: 543-550 | P. koreensis 2.74 | CBS 125413 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE03058 mating type A5 | Potato | Late blight | Ovatio | N | Detached leaves | Lesion diameter | Significant reduction in the diameter of lesions | Increasing the concentration of the bacteria in the suspension sprayed on the leaves did not result in increased disease reduction | NA | Y |
| Hunziker et al. (2015) | Applied and Environmental Microbiology | 81: 821-830 | NA | NA | Volatiles compounds issued from bacteria (Pseudomonas and others) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Impact of volatils against growth | P. Vranovensis; P. marginalis; P. moraviensis; P.chlororaphis and P. margilanis R82 inhibits growth of P. infestans | P. moravinsis R01; P. veronii R02; P. chlororaphis R47; P. fluorescens R76; P. frederksbergensis S04 and S24 and P. jejessenii S34 induces reduced growth | NA | Y |
| Hunziker et al. (2015) | Applied and Environmental Microbiology | 81: 821-830 | NA | NA | 1-undecene and undecane | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Zoospore release | Dose-dependent mycelium inhibition was observed for 1-undecene which was much stronger than that obtained with its reduced form; undecane | The total amount of sporangia was significantly reduced in a concentration-dependent manner in 1-undecene treatments compared to the control treatment; | This molecule directly impacted zoospore release as well as direct germination of the sporangia | Y |
| Kurzawinska and Mazur (2009) | Folia horticulturae | 21/2: 13-23 | Pythium oligandrum | NA | NA | NA | Polyversum | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | IBIS | NA | Field | Disease's development | Tubers treated or/with a spray treatment on plant reduced disease development | Yield was increase when tubers and plant were both treated and tuber infection decrease when treated or/with plant treatement | NA | Y |
| Kurzawinska and Mazur (2010) | Folia horticulturae | 21/2: 13-24 | NA | NA | Chitosan | NA | Biochikol 020 PC | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | IBIS | NA | Field | Disease's development | Tubers treated or/with a spray treatment on plant reduced disease development | Yield was increase when tubers and plant were both treated and tuber infection decrease when treated or/with plant treatement | NA | Y |
| Kurzawinska and Mazur (2011) | Folia horticulturae | 21/2: 13-25 | Pythium oligandrum | NA | NA | NA | Polyversum | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Polyversum applied at 0;05% to 0;2% was efficient against P. infestans growth | Most efficient concentration : 0;2% (51;36% of growth inhibition) | NA | Y |
| Kurzawinska and Mazur (2009) | Folia horticulturae | 21/2: 13-26 | NA | NA | Chitosan | NA | Biochikol 020 PC | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Only efficient at 2% (43;55% of growth inhibition) | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2005) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 99: 836-843 | NA | NA | Neomycin (0;1 to 10 µg/ml) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | No regrowth at concentration 10 | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2005) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 99: 836-843 | NA | NA | Paromomycin (0;1to 100 µg/ml) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | No regrowth at concentrations 1 and 10; 20 and 40 | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2005) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 99: 836-843 | NA | NA | Ribostamycin (0;1 to 10 µg/ml) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | No regrowth at concentrations 1 and 10 | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2005) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 99: 836-843 | NA | NA | Streptomycin (0;1 to 10 µg/ml) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | No regrowth at concentration 10 | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2005) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 99: 836-843 | NA | NA | Neomycin (100 and 500 µg/ml) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Disease reduction | Between 20 and 80% of disease reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2005) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 99: 836-843 | NA | NA | Paromomycin (100; 250 and 500 µg/ml) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Disease reduction | 99% of disease reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Lee et al. (2005) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 99: 836-843 | NA | NA | Ribostamycin (100 and 500 µg/ml) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Disease reduction | 28% of disease reduction | NA | NA | N |
| Lee et al. (2005) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 99: 836-843 | NA | NA | Streptomycin (100 and 500 µg/ml) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Disease reduction | Between 48 and 76% of disease reduction | NA | NA | Y |
| Li et al. (2014) | PLoS ONE | 9e:97197 | NA | NA | Curdlan b-1;3-Glucooligosaccharides (mix of DP 3; glucotriose; DP 4 glucotetraose; DP 5; glucopentaose; DP 6; glucohexaose; and DP 7; glucoseptaose | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | JN | Potato | Late blight | McCain G1 | NA | Greenhouse | Lesion estimation + accumulation of antioxydant enzymes + H2O2 | Increase in SA and GLU and chitinases and PAL concentrations | B-1;3-glucopentaose (DP 5) is the molecule to fully elicit the defense responses in potato leaves. | The ratio of lesion area (RLA) decreased when the plants were treated with CurdOs at 1 d before infection of the pathogen. P. infestans caused an average of 15.82%65.44% RLA on leaves; whereas the RLA dropped to 7.79%63.03% when leaves were treated with CurdOs | Y |
| Li et al. (2014) | PLoS ONE | 9e:97197 | NA | NA | Laminarin | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | JN | Potato | Late blight | McCain G2 | NA | Greenhouse | Accumulation of antioxydant enzymes + H2O2 | Increase in SA and GLU and chitinases and PAL concentrations (lower than CurdOs for SA and GLU) | NA | NA | Y |
| Machinandiarena et al. (2012) | Journal of plant physiology | NA | NA | NA | Potassium phosphite (10 mL per plant (3 L/ha) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Race R2 R3 R6 R7 R9; mating type A2 | Potato | Late blight | Kennebec | NA | Greenhouse - detached leaves | Lesion area + H2O2 + O2;- + callose accumulation | Increase in H2O2 accumulation by 5 times and O2;- by 7 times and callose by 7 times | Reduction of plant lesion | KPhi-treatment potentiated StWRKY expression at 24 and 48 hpi; reaching its highest level at 48 hpi (2.6-fold induction). Similarly; StNPR1 expression was induced by KPhi reatment only at 48 hpi (1.7-fold induction) being also its highest expression level. The increase of the expression of StPR1 reached its highest level after 48 hpi; showing a 5.4-fold induction as compared with leaves from water-treated plants. On the other hand; the expression of StIPII showed a high constitutive expression for both; KPhi-treated and water-treated plants; showing a dramatic down regulation until 48 hpi. However; at 72 hpi in KPhi-treated plants; this value was not significantly different than the basal expression of this gene in both treatments | Y |
| Maksimov et al. (2014) | Applied Biochemistry and Microbiology | 50: 173-178 | Bacillus subtilis | 26D | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 1.2 | Potato | Late blight | Rannaya Rosa | NA | Growth chamber | Symptoms area | Reduction of symptoms area by 1;5 times | NA | NA | Y |
| Maksimov et al. (2014) | Applied Biochemistry and Microbiology | 50: 173-178 | NA | NA | Jasmonic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 1.2 | Potato | Late blight | Rannaya Rosa | NA | Growth chamber | Symptoms area | Reduction of symptoms area by 5 times | NA | NA | Y |
| Maksimov et al. (2014) | Applied Biochemistry and Microbiology | 50: 173-178 | NA | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 1.2 | Potato | Late blight | Rannaya Rosa | NA | Growth chamber | Symptoms area | Reduction of symptoms area by 0;7 times | NA | NA | Y |
| Maksimov et al. (2014) | Applied Biochemistry and Microbiology | 50: 173-178 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | Jasmonic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 1.2 | Potato | Late blight | Rannaya Rosa | NA | Growth chamber | Symptoms area | Reduction of symptoms area by 5 times | After 72h; JA coupled with B. subtilis induces a induction of peroxydases activity by 3 times | NA | Y |
| Maksimov et al. (2014) | Applied Biochemistry and Microbiology | 50: 173-178 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 1.2 | Potato | Late blight | Rannaya Rosa | NA | Growth chamber | Symptoms area | Reduction of symptoms area by 0;8 times | B. subtilis coupled with SA induces a reduction of symptoms area by 5 times and a induction of peroxidases activity | NA | Y |
| Moushib et al. (2013) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 136: 261-271 | NA | NA | Sugar beet extract | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE030558 (mating type A1; virulent on plants carrying R1; R3; R4; R7; R10; R11; where R denotes a resistance gene) | Potato | Late blight | Desiree | Y | Greenhouse | Detached leaves | Reduction in lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Moushib et al. (2013) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 136: 261-271 | NA | NA | Sugar beet extract | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE030558 (mating type A1; virulent on plants carrying R1; R3; R4; R7; R10; R11; where R denotes a resistance gene) | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Greenhouse | Lesion diameter on detached leaves | Reduction in lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Moushib et al. (2013) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 136: 261-271 | NA | NA | Sugar beet extract | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE030558 (mating type A1; virulent on plants carrying R1; R3; R4; R7; R10; R11; where R denotes a resistance gene) | Potato | Late blight | Ovatio | N | Greenhouse | Lesion diameter on detached leaves | Reduction in lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Moushib et al. (2013) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 136: 261-271 | NA | NA | DL-3-amino butyric acid (BABA) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE030558 (mating type A1; virulent on plants carrying R1; R3; R4; R7; R10; R11; where R denotes a resistance gene) | Potato | Late blight | Desiree | Y | Greenhouse | Lesion diameter on detached leaves | Reduction in lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Moushib et al. (2013) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 136: 261-271 | NA | NA | DL-3-amino butyric acid (BABA) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE030558 (mating type A1; virulent on plants carrying R1; R3; R4; R7; R10; R11; where R denotes a resistance gene) | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Greenhouse | Lesion diameter on detached leaves | Reduction in lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Moushib et al. (2013) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 136: 261-271 | NA | NA | DL-3-amino butyric acid (BABA) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE030558 (mating type A1; virulent on plants carrying R1; R3; R4; R7; R10; R11; where R denotes a resistance gene) | Potato | Late blight | Ovatio | N | Greenhouse | Lesion diameter on detached leaves | Reduction in lesion diameter | NA | NA | Y |
| Moushib et al. (2013) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 136: 261-271 | NA | NA | Sugar beet extract | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | SE030558 (mating type A1; virulent on plants carrying R1; R3; R4; R7; R10; R11; where R denotes a resistance gene) | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth + sporangial germination | No direct effect on P. infestans growth and sporangial germination | NA | NA | N |
| O'herlihy et al. (2003) | Folia Geobotanica | 38: 201-207 | Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi | NA | NA | NA | Vaminoc | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Golden wonder | NA | Field | Detached leaves: chitinase activity | Chitinase activity was reduced | NA | NA | Y |
| O'herlihy et al. (2003) | Folia Geobotanica | 38: 201-208 | Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi | NA | NA | NA | Vaminoc | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Golden wonder | NA | Field | Disease evaluation | Disease progression was delayed in the AMF treatment | Yield was equivalent to the classical fungicide treatment and increased by 2 in comparison with the control | NA | Y |
| Olanya and Larkin (2006) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 16: 901-917 | NA | NA | Essential oils of lavender | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Different isolates | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | From 28;7% to 69;7 of inhibition | A concentration of 1000 ppm is 5;5 times more efficient than 100 ppm | NA | Y |
| Olanya and Larkin (2006) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 16: 901-917 | NA | NA | Essential oils of oregano | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Different isolates | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | From 82;7 to 99;7% of inhibition | 1000 ppm = 100 ppm | NA | Y |
| Olanya and Larkin (2006) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 16: 901-917 | NA | NA | Essential oils of thyme | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Different isolates | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | From 50;3% to 94;4% of inhibition | A concentration of 1000 ppm is 1;8 times more efficient than 100 ppm | NA | Y |
| Olanya and Larkin (2006) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 16: 901-917 | NA | NA | Essential oils of thyme borneal | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Different isolates | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | From 87;1% to 99;4% of inhibition | A concentration of 1000 ppm is 1;1 times more efficient than 100 ppm | NA | Y |
| Olanya and Larkin (2006) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 16: 901-917 | Bacillus substilis | QST713 | NA | NA | Serenade | Phytophthora infestans | Different isolates | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | 100% of inhibition | 1000 ppm = 100 ppm | NA | Y |
| Olanya and Larkin (2006) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 16: 901-917 | NA | NA | Essentials oils of oregano | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8; genotype 100/111/122; isolate 00-109 | Potato | Late blight | Shepody | NA | Growth chamber | Disease incidence and severity | Disease incidence reduced by 20% | No effect on severity | Reduction in leasion number | Y |
| Olanya and Larkin (2006) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 16: 901-917 | Bacillus substilis | QST713 | NA | NA | Serenade | Phytophthora infestans | US-8; genotype 100/111/122; isolate 00-109 | Potato | Late blight | Shepody | NA | Growth chamber | Disease incidence and severity | Disease incidence reduced by 20% | Disease severity decreased by 10% | Reduction in leasion number | Y |
| Olanya and Larkin (2006) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 16: 901-917 | Effective Microorganisms (EM-1TM) (Lactobacillus sp.; yeast; phototrophic bacteria) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8; genotype 100/111/122; isolate 00-109 | Potato | Late blight | Shepody | NA | Growth chamber | Disease incidence and severity | No effect on disease incidence | No effect on severity | Reduction in leasion number | N |
| Olanya and Larkin (2006) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 16: 901-917 | NA | NA | Compost tea | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8; genotype 100/111/122; isolate 00-110 | Potato | Late blight | Shepody | NA | Growth chamber | Disease incidence and severity | No effect on disease incidence | No effect on severity | No reduction of the lesion number | N |
| Park et al. (2005) | FEMS Microbiology Letters | 252: 309-313 | NA | NA | Chaetovirin A from Cheatomium globosum F0142 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | MIB value: 33;3 µg/ml | NA | NA | Y |
| Park et al. (2005) | FEMS Microbiology Letters | 252: 309-313 | NA | NA | Chaetovirin A from Cheatomium globosum F0142 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Disease severity | Chaetoviridin A was also moderately active against P. infestans on tomato plants | NA | NA | Y |
| Park et al. (2005) | FEMS Microbiology Letters | 252: 309-313 | NA | NA | Chaetovirin B from Cheatomium globosum F0142 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | MIB value: >100 µg/ml | NA | NA | N |
| Park et al. (2005) | FEMS Microbiology Letters | 252: 309-313 | NA | NA | Chaetovirin B from Cheatomium globosum F0142 | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Disease severity | No effect on disease severity | NA | NA | N |
| Porz et al. (2008) | European Journal of Pathology | 122: 197-206 | NA | NA | 50 µg/ml of allicin | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | % germination + germ tube lenght | Reduction in % of germination | Germ tube lenght from sporangia and cysts reduced by 7 times | NA | Y |
| Porz et al. (2008) | European Journal of Pathology | 122: 197-206 | NA | NA | Garlic bulb extract containing 50 µg/ml of allicin | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | Hoffmanns Rentita® | NA | In vivo | Disease incidence | A concentration of 800 µg/ml is phytotoxic for plants | Spraying with garlic juice very effectively reduced disease development; with a 1:50 dilution (110 μg ml−1 allicin) suppressing lesion development completely | Spraying leaves before P; infestans inoculation is effective against disease development whereas after inoculation doesn't work | Y |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | Phytophthora cryptogea | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | St. Catalina | N | Field | Late blight infection | No effect on infection | NA | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | Phytophthora cryptogea | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Moncerrate | N | Field | Late blight infection | No effect on infection | NA | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | Phytophthora cryptogea | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | St Cecilia | Y | Field | Late blight infection | Reduction of late blight infection by 10 times | NA | NA | Y |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | NA | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | St. Catalina | N | Field | Late blight infection | Reduction of late blight infection by 5 | NA | NA | Y |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | NA | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Moncerrate | N | Field | Late blight infection | Reduction of late blight infection by 6 | NA | NA | Y |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | NA | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | St Cecilia | Y | Field | Late blight infection | SA promoted late blight infection | NA | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | Phytophthora cryptogea | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Growth chamber | Late blight infection | No reduction of the plant infection | No effect on the tuber infection | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | Phytophthora cryptogea | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Hertha | N | Growth chamber | Late blight infection | No reduction of the plant infection | No effect on the tuber infection | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | Phytophthora cryptogea | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Ovatio | N | Growth chamber | Late blight infection | No reduction of the plant infection | No effect on the tuber infection | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | NA | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Growth chamber | Late blight infection | No reduction of the plant infection | No effect on the tuber infection | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | NA | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Hertha | N | Growth chamber | Late blight infection | No reduction of the plant infection | No effect on the tuber infection | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | NA | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Ovatio | N | Growth chamber | Late blight infection | No reduction of the plant infection | No effect on the tuber infection | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | Phytophthora cryptogea | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Growth chamber | Late blight infection | No reduction of the plant infection | No effect on the tuber infection | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | Phytophthora cryptogea | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Hertha | N | Growth chamber | Late blight infection | No reduction of the plant infection | Stimulation of the tuber infection | NA | N |
| Quintanilla and Brishammar (1998) | Potato Research | 41: 135-142 | Phytophthora cryptogea | NA | Salicilic acid | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Ovatio | N | Growth chamber | Late blight infection | Stimulation of the infection | No effect on the tuber infection | NA | N |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of thyme | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | Mandel and Kerrs Pink | NA | Greenhouse and in vitro | Radial growth and disease measurement | Growth reduced by 90% | Reduction of around 40% of disease symptoms | Phytotoxic effect | N |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of Caraway | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | Mandel and Kerrs Pink | NA | Greenhouse and in vitro | Radial growth and disease measurement | No reduction of growth | Reduction of around 30% of disease symptoms | Phytotoxic effect | N |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essentials oils Hyssop | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | Mandel and Kerrs Pink | NA | Greenhouse and in vitro | Radial growth and disease measurement | Growth reduced by 35% to 50% | Reduction of around 75% of disease symptoms | No phytotoxic effect | Y |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of Norway spruce | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | No reduction of growth | NA | NA | N |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of Dill | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | Mandel and Kerrs Pink | NA | Greenhouse and in vitro | Radial growth and disease measurement | Growth reduced by 5% | Reduction of around 20% of disease symptoms | No phytotoxic effect | Y |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of Southernwood | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduced by 20% | NA | NA | Y |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of Golden rob | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | No reduction of growth | NA | NA | N |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of common juniper | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduced by 25% | NA | NA | Y |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of lavender | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduced by 10% | NA | NA | N |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of rosemary | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduced by 35% | NA | NA | Y |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of yarrow | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduced by 45% | NA | NA | Y |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of oregano | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduced by 60% | NA | NA | Y |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of coriander | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduced by 30% | NA | NA | Y |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of lemon balm | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduced by 70% | NA | NA | Y |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of peppermint | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | Mandel and Kerrs Pink | NA | Greenhouse and in vitro | Radial growth and disease measurement | Growth reduced by 65% | No effect on disease symptoms | Phytotoxic effect | N |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of chamomille | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduced by 15% | NA | NA | N |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of feverfew | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | No reduction of growth | NA | NA | N |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of black cottonwood | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduction of 10% | NA | NA | N |
| Quintanilla et al. (2002) | Potato Research | 45: 225-235 | NA | NA | Essential oils of downy birch | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 981092 and QL1099 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Radial growth | Growth reduction of 40% | NA | NA | Y |
| Sharma et al. (2012) | European Journal on Plant Pathology | NA | NA | NA | Horn meal (fertilizers) + strenghteners | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 101 and 108 | Tomato | Late blight | Cerise rot and celsior | NA | Greenhouse | AUDPC + sporulation capacity per cm² at 6 DAI | No effect on AUDPC; neither sporulation capacity | No interaction with strenghteners | NA | N |
| Sharma et al. (2012) | European Journal on Plant Pathology | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | BioFeed (fertilizer) + strenghteners | Phytophthora infestans | 101 and 108 | Tomato | Late blight | Cerise rot and celsior | NA | Greenhouse | AUDPC + sporulation capacity per cm² at 6 DAI | Slight effect of the fertiliser alone | No interaction with strenghteners | NA | Y |
| Sharma et al. (2012) | European Journal on Plant Pathology | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Bio-ILSA (fertilizer) + strenghteners | Phytophthora infestans | 101 and 108 | Tomato | Late blight | Cerise rot and celsior | NA | Greenhouse | AUDPC + sporulation capacity per cm² at 6 DAI | Slight effect of the fertiliser alone | No interaction with strenghteners | NA | Y |
| Sharma et al. (2012) | European Journal on Plant Pathology | NA | NA | NA | Alfalfa extract | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 101 and 108 | Tomato | Late blight | Cerise rot and celsior | NA | Greenhouse | AUDPC + sporulation capacity per cm² at 6 DAI | AUDPC reduced from 30 to 60% depending of the cultivar and the pathogen isolate | Sporulation capacity reduced from 10 for 50% depending of the cultivar and the pathogen isolate | NA | Y |
| Sharma et al. (2012) | European Journal on Plant Pathology | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | PEN | Phytophthora infestans | 101 and 108 | Tomato | Late blight | Cerise rot and celsior | NA | Greenhouse | AUDPC + sporulation capacity per cm² at 6 DAI | AUDPC reduced from 30 to 60% depending of the cultivar and the pathogen isolate | Sporulation capacity reduced from 10 for 50% depending of the cultivar and the pathogen isolate | NA | Y |
| Sharma et al. (2012) | European Journal on Plant Pathology | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | QUALITY | Phytophthora infestans | 101 and 108 | Tomato | Late blight | Cerise rot and celsior | NA | Greenhouse | AUDPC + sporulation capacity per cm² at 6 DAI | AUDPC reduced from 10 to 75% depending of the cultivar and the pathogen isolate | Sporulation capacity reduced from 10 for 50% depending of the cultivar and the pathogen isolate | NA | Y |
| Sharma et al. (2012) | European Journal on Plant Pathology | NA | NA | NA | BABA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | 101 and 108 | Tomato | Late blight | Supermarmande | NA | Detached leaves or leaf disk | AUDPC + sporulation capacity per cm² at 6 DAI | AUDPC quite totally inhibited | Sporulation capacity reduced from 50 for 100% depending of the cultivar and the pathogen isolate | NA | Y |
| Son et al. (2007) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 104: 692-698 | NA | NA | Bikaverin (from Fusarium oxysporum EF119) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth | MIC > 100 µg/ml | IC50 : 60 µg/ml | NA | N |
| Son et al. (2007) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 104: 692-699 | NA | NA | Fusaric acid (from Fusarium oxysporum EF119) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth | MIC = 11 µg/ml | IC50: 1 µg/ml | NA | Y |
| Son et al. (2007) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 104: 692-700 | NA | NA | Bikaverin (from Fusarium oxysporum EF119) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vivo | Disease severity | From 7 to 71% of disease reduction according to the concentration | NA | NA | Y |
| Son et al. (2007) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 104: 692-701 | NA | NA | Fusaric acid (from Fusarium oxysporum EF119) | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vivo | Disease severity | From 29 to 96% of disease reduction according to the concentration | NA | NA | Y |
| Son et al. (2007) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 104: 692-702 | NA | NA | Fermentation broth of Fusarium | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Tomato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vivo | Disease severity | Fermentation broth effectively suppressed the development of late blight by 90 to 96% according to the dilution | NA | NA | Y |
| Soytong and Ratanacherdchai (2005) | Journal of Agricultural Technology | 1: 19-32 | NA | NA | Cheatomium mycofungicide | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Mycelium growth | Mycelium growth reduced by 42;91% | Spore production reduced by 50% | NA | Y |
| Soytong and Ratanacherdchai (2005) | Journal of Agricultural Technology | 1: 19-32 | NA | NA | Chaetomium-mycofungicide + biofertilizer | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Atlanta | NA | Field | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 18;75%% | Increase of number of tubers and weight of tubers | NA | Y |
| Soytong and Ratanacherdchai (2005) | Journal of Agricultural Technology | 1: 19-32 | NA | NA | Chaetomium-mycofungicide + biofertilizer + chemical fertilizer | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Atlanta | NA | Field | Disease severity | Disease reduction by 15;62 to 34;37% | Increase of number of tubers and weight of tubers | NA | Y |
| Alaux et al. (2018) | Crop Protection | NA | Rhizophagus irregularis MUCL 41833 | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Field | AUDPC | When pressure low; reduction of symptoms | When pressure high; no difference | No difference in tuber weight and number | Y |
| Alaux et al. (2018) | Crop Protection | NA | Rhizophagus irregularis MUCL 41834 | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Nicolas | N | Field | AUDPC | NA | When pressure high; no difference | NA | N |
| Shanthiyaa et al. (2013) | Crop Protection | 52: 33-38 | Chaetomium isolates | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth of the pathogen | Reduction of the growth from 44.5% to 72.3% | NA | NA | Y |
| Shanthiyaa et al. (2013) | Crop Protection | 52: 33-38 | Chaetomium globosum | Cg-6 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Kufri Jyothi | Y | Field | Disease index + yield | Reduction of 22%-24% of the disease | Yield increases | Tuber treatment | Y |
| Shanthiyaa et al. (2013) | Crop Protection | 52: 33-38 | Chaetomium globosum | Cg-6 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Kufri Jyothi | Y | Field | Disease index + yield | Reduction of 12%-16% of the disease | Yield increases | Soil application | Y |
| Shanthiyaa et al. (2013) | Crop Protection | 52: 33-38 | Chaetomium globosum | Cg-6 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Kufri Jyothi | Y | Field | Disease index + yield | Reduction of 8%-12% of the disease | Yield increases | Foliar treatment + soil application | Y |
| Shanthiyaa et al. (2013) | Crop Protection | 52: 33-38 | Chaetomium globosum | Cg-6 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Kufri Jyothi | Y | Field | Disease index + yield | Reduction of 28% of the disease | Yield increases | 3 treatments | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Pseudomonas putida | P1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 50-60% growth inhibition | 10-40% protection on detached leaves | 50-70% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Pseudomonas putida | P2 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 0-65% growth inhibition | 30-40% protection on detached leaves | NA | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Bacillus subtilis | J1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 40-80% growth inhibition | 0-20% protection on detached leaves | 30-50% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Bacillus subtilis | B1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 70-80% growth inhibition | 10-40% protection on detached leaves | 60% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Bacillus subtilis | B3 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 60-80% growth inhibition | 0% protection on detached leaves | 40-50% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Serratia plymuthica | DF1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 40-65% growth inhibition | Protection >75% detached leaves | 35-50% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Bacillus pumilus | B2 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 60-80% growth inhibition | 10-40% protection on detached leaves | 20-25% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Bacillus pumilus | M1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 60-85% growth inhibition | 0% protection on detached leaves | 40-70% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Bacillus pumilus | W1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 60%-80% of growth inhibition | 0% protection on detached leaves | 20-45% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Bacillus pumilus | Y1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 60%-80% of growth inhibition | 0% protection on detached leaves | 30-35% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | DF35 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 35-80% growth inhibition | 20-40% protection on detached leaves | 15-30% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | DF37 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 50-85% growth inhibition | 0-40% protection on detached leaves | 15-30% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | DF40 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 60-80% growth inhibition | 0% protection on detached leaves | 20-25% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Pseudomonas viridilivida | DF3 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 0-50% growth inhibition | 10-20% protection on detached leaves | 20% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Rahnella aquatilis | W2 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 90% growth inhibition | 20-40% protection on detached leaves | 50-60% protection on plant | Y |
| Daayf et al. (2003) | Canadian J of Plant Pathology | 25: 276-284 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | C1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | US-8 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | In vitro + detached leaves + pot culture | Growth of the pathogen | 70% and >90% of growth inhibition | 0% protection on detached leaves | 20-30% protection on plant | Y |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Leaves of Rheum rhabarbarum; | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Effect only when applied 1h after inoculation | Effect only when applied after inoculation 90 min | NA | Y |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Helianthus annuus | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Taraxacum officinale | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Sambucus nigra | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | NA | NA | NA | NA |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Leaves; stems and flowers of Solidago canadensis | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Good effect on detached leaves | Effect on plant only when application 24h before | NA | Y |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Artemisia vulgaris | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Effect only when applied 24h before inoculation | No effect on plant | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Impatiens parviflora | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Reduction on leaf infection | No effect on plant | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Oenothera biennis | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No effect on detached leaves | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Urtica dioica | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Reduction on leaf infection | No effect on plant | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Trichodex | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Good effect on detached leaves | Reduction only when applied 24h before inoculation | NA | Y |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Vitalin 1 | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Good effect on detached leaves | No effect on plant | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Vitalin 2 | NA | NA | NA | Vitalin 2 | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Effect only when applied 24h before inoculation | No effect on plant | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Vitalin 3 | NA | NA | NA | Vitalin 3 | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No effect on detached leaves | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Vitalin 4 | NA | NA | NA | Vitalin 4 | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No effect on detached leaves | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | Phytovit | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No effect on detached leaves | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | BIOPro | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No effect on detached leaves | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | Serenade | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Good effect on detached leaves | Good effect on plant | NA | Y |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | Sonata | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | NA | NA | NA | NA |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | FZB55 | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | NA | NA | NA | NA |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Mixture of microorganisms | NA | NA | NA | EM5 | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Slight effect when applied 24h before inoculation | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Streptomyces spp. | NA | NA | NA | Erhizovit | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No effect on detached leaves | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No effect on detached leaves | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Plant extract | NA | Elot-Vis | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Reduction on detached leaves | Effect only when application 24h before inoculation | NA | Y |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Harpi protein | NA | Messenger | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | Stimulation of the growth of the pathogen | NA | NA | N |
| Stephan et al. (2005) | European J. of Plant Pathology | 112: 235-246 | NA | NA | Copper oxychloride | NA | Atempo | Phytophthora infestans | P. infestans | Potato | Late blight | Segura | NA | Detached leaves + pot culture | Affected leaf area + audpc | No or slight effect | Good reduction on plant | NA | Y |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Bacillus amyloliquefasciens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110022 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro + greenhouse + field | Direct antagonisms + late blight severity | Good reduction of the growth | Good effect in greenhouse | No effect in field | N |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Bacillus cereus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110023 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Direct antagonisms | Slight effect on the growth | NA | NA | N |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Bacillus lichenformis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110024 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Direct antagonisms | No-slight effect | NA | NA | N |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Bacillus megaterium | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110025 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Direct antagonisms | Slight effect on the growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Mycoplasma mycoides | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110026 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Direct antagonisms | Good effect | One strain protect plant in greenhouse | NA | Y |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Bacillus pumilus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110027 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro + greenhouse + field | Direct antagonisms + late blight severity | Slight -good effect | NA | NA | Y |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110028 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro + greenhouse + field | Direct antagonisms + late blight severity | Good effect | No effect in greenhouse - onr effect of one strain | Good effect in field | Y |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Bacillus simplex | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110029 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Greenhouse | Late blight severity | NA | No effect in greenhouse | NA | N |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Bacillus sonorensis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110030 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Direct antagonisms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Pseudomonas alkyphenolia | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110031 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Direct antagonisms | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Pseudomonas brenneri | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110032 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro + greenhouse + field | Direct antagonisms + late blight severity | Good reduction of the growth | Good effect in greenhouse | No effect in field | N |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Pseudomonas chlororaphis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110033 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro + greenhouse + field | Direct antagonisms + late blight severity | Good reduction of the growth | Good effect in greenhouse | NA | Y |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110034 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Direct antagonisms | Good reduction of the growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Pseudomonas helmanticensis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110035 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro + greenhouse | Direct antagonisms + late blight severity | Good reduction of the growth | No effect in greenhouse | NA | N |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Pseudomonas protegens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110036 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro + greenhouse + field | Direct antagonisms + late blight severity | Good reduction of the growth | Good effect in greenhouse | Good effect in field | Y |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Pseudomonas putida | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110037 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Direct antagonisms | Good reduction of the growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Caulier et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | Volume 9; article 143 | Pseudomonas salomonii | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | CRA-W110038 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro | Direct antagonisms | Good reduction of the growth | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas putida | R32 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | Invitro | Mycelial growth | Reduction of the mycelial growth | Reduction in zoospore release | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas putida | R32 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leave | Infection severity | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas putida | R32 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Lady Claire | NA | Detached leave | Infection severity | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas putida | R32 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Victoria | NA | Detached leave | Infection severity | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas chlororaphis | R47 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | Invitro | Mycelial growth | Reduction of the mycelial growth | Reduction in zoospore release | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas chlororaphis | R47 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leave | Growth of the pathogen | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas chlororaphis | R47 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Lady Claire | NA | Detached leave | NA | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas chlororaphis | R47 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Victoria | NA | Detached leave | NA | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | R76 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leave | Growth of the pathogen | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | R76 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Lady Claire | NA | Detached leave | NA | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | R76 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Victoria | NA | Detached leave | NA | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | R84 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leave | Growth of the pathogen | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | R84 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Lady Claire | NA | Detached leave | NA | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | R84 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Victoria | NA | Detached leave | NA | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | S04 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leave | Growth of the pathogen | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | S04 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Lady Claire | NA | Detached leave | NA | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | S04 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Victoria | NA | Detached leave | NA | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas frederiksbergensis | S19 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | Invitro | Mycelial growth | Reduction of the mycelial growth | Reduction in zoospore release | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas frederiksbergensis | S19 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leave | Growth of the pathogen | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas frederiksbergensis | S19 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Lady Claire | NA | Detached leave | NA | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas frederiksbergensis | S19 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Victoria | NA | Detached leave | NA | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | S34 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leave | Growth of the pathogen | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | S34 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Lady Claire | NA | Detached leave | NA | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas | S34 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Victoria | NA | Detached leave | NA | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | S35 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | Invitro | Mycelial growth | Reduction of the mycelial growth | Reduction in zoospore release | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | S35 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leave | Growth of the pathogen | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | S35 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Lady Claire | NA | Detached leave | NA | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | S35 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Victoria | NA | Detached leave | NA | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas fluorescesns | S49 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | NA | NA | Invitro | Mycelial growth | Reduction of the mycelial growth | Reduction in zoospore release | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas fluorescesns | S49 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | Detached leave | Growth of the pathogen | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas fluorescesns | S49 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Lady Claire | NA | Detached leave | NA | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2018) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 58: 17-25 | Pseudomonas fluorescesns | S49 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | Rec01 | Potato | Late blight | Victoria | NA | Detached leave | NA | Decrease in infection severity | NA | NA | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2019) | Phytopathology | 109: 1555-1565 | Pseudomonas frederiksbergensis | S19 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro + detached leaves | Growth of the pathogen | Efficient to reduce growth | Recovery is possible | Reduction of sporangiophore developement | Y |
| De Vrieze et al. (2019) | Phytopathology | 109: 1555-1565 | Pseudomonas | R76 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro + detached leaves | Growth of the pathogen | Efficient against some P. infestans strains | Recovery is possible | Slight reduction of sporangiophore developement | N |
| De Vrieze et al. (2019) | Phytopathology | 109: 1555-1565 | Pseudomonas chlororaphis | R47 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora infestans | NA | Potato | Late blight | Bintje | Y | In vitro + detached leaves | Growth of the pathogen | Really effcient to reduce growth in vitro | Efficient once the 1st exposure | Reduction of sporangiophore developement | Y |
| Agusti et al. (2011) | J. of Plant Pathology | 93: 363-372 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | EPS817 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | 489 | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Germination of encysted zoospore | Reduction of germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Agusti et al. (2011) | J. of Plant Pathology | 93: 363-372 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | EPS817 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | 489 | Strawberry | Crown rot | Diamante | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | No significant effect on the disease severity | NA | NA | N |
| Agusti et al. (2011) | J. of Plant Pathology | 93: 363-372 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | EPS894 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | 489 | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Germination of encysted zoospore | Reduction of germination | NA | NA | Y |
| Agusti et al. (2011) | J. of Plant Pathology | 93: 363-372 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | EPS894 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | 489 | Strawberry | Crown rot | Diamante | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity | Effect on disease severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Norman and Hooker (2000) | Mycological Research | 104: 1069-1073 | Claroideoglomus etunicatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Sporangial production | Reduction of sporangial production | NA | NA | Y |
| Norman and Hooker (2000) | Mycological Research | 104: 1069-1073 | Claroideoglomus etunicatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | Cambridge Favourite | NA | Pot culture | Sporangial production | Reduction of sporangial production | NA | NA | Y |
| Norman and Hooker (2000) | Mycological Research | 104: 1069-1073 | Glomus monosporum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Sporangial production | Reduction of sporangial production | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Raoultella terrigena | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic test | Reduction by 40% of mycelium growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Raoultella terrigena | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic test | Reduction by 40% of mycelium growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Raoultella terrigena | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | Elsanta (Frigo) and Honeoye | Y | Greenhouse | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 44% | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Raoultella terrigena | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Elsanta (Frigo) and Honeoye | Y | Greenhouse | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 57% | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Raoultella terrigena | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | Elsanta (Frigo) | Y | Field | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 35% | No reduction of disease incidence (when pressure is high) | Artificial inoculation of the pathogen in soil | N |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Raoultella terrigena | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Elsanta (Frigo) | Y | Field | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 35% (when pressure is low) | No reduction of disease incidence (when pressure is high) | Artificial inoculation of the pathogen in soil | N |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Raoultella terrigena | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophtora spp. | NA | Strawberry | NA | Elsanta (Frigo) | Y | Field | Disease index | No reduction of disease incidence (when pressure is low year 1) | Reduction of disease index by 45% (when pressure is low) | Naturally infested soil | N |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Raoultella terrigena | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophtora spp. | NA | Strawberry | NA | Elsanta (Frigo) | Y | Field (organic) | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 51;5%% (when pressure is low) | NA | Naturally infested soil | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic test | Reduction by 37% of mycelium growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic test | Reduction by 38% of mycelium growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | Elsanta (Frigo) and Honeoye | Y | Greenhouse | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 41% | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Elsanta (Frigo) and Honeoye | Y | Greenhouse | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 51% | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | Elsanta (Frigo) | Y | Field | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 23;5% (when pressure is low) | Reduction of disease index by 27% (when pressure is high) | Artificial inoculation of the pathogen in soil | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Elsanta (Frigo) | Y | Field | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 30% (when pressure is low) | No reduction of disease incidence (when pressure is high) | Artificial inoculation of the pathogen in soil | N |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophtora spp. | NA | Strawberry | NA | NA | NA | Field | Disease index | No reduction of disease incidence (when pressure is high) | No reduction of disease incidence (when pressure is high) | Naturally infested soil | N |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophtora spp. | NA | Strawberry | NA | NA | NA | Field (organic) | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 50% (when pressure is low) | NA | Naturally infested soil | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | 2R1-7 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic test | Reduction by 35% of mycelium growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | 2R1-7 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic test | Reduction by 35% of mycelium growth | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | 2R1-7 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | Elsanta (Frigo) and Honeoye | Y | Greenhouse | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 59% | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | 2R1-7 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Elsanta (Frigo) and Honeoye | Y | Greenhouse | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 49% | NA | NA | Y |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | 2R1-7 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | Elsanta (Frigo) | Y | Field | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 45% (when pressure is low) | No reduction of disease incidence (when pressure is high) | Artificial inoculation of the pathogen in soil | N |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | 2R1-7 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Elsanta (Frigo) | Y | Field | Disease index | Reduction of disease index by 40% (when pressure is low) | No reduction of disease incidence (when pressure is high) | Artificial inoculation of the pathogen in soil | N |
| Anandhakumar and Zeller (2008) | J. of Plant diseases and Protection | 115: 49-56 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | 2R1-7 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophtora spp. | NA | Strawberry | NA | Elsanta (Frigo) | Y | Field | Disease index | No reduction of disease incidence (when pressure is high) | NA | Naturally infested soil | N |
| Porras et al. (2007) | Plant Disease | 91: 142-146 | T. asperellum + T. atroviride | T11 + ICC012 T25 / TV1 | NA | NA | Tusal | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | Field | Disease incidence | Reduction of 76.6% of the disease incidence | Reduction of the number of propagules density in soil | NA | Y |
| Kurze et al. (2001) | Plant Disease | 85: 529-534 | Serratia plymuthica | HRO-C48 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | Field | Disease incidence + yield | Reduction of the disease incidence | Yield increased | NA | Y |
| Gulati et al. (2001) | Tri-trophic interactions in the rhizosphere (conference chapter) | 24: 51-55 | Pseudomonas putida | I-112 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Reduction of pathogen growth by 65% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gulati et al. (2001) | Tri-trophic interactions in the rhizosphere (conference chapter) | 24: 51-55 | Pseudomonas putida | I-112 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Reduction of pathogen growth by 65% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gulati et al. (2001) | Tri-trophic interactions in the rhizosphere (conference chapter) | 24: 51-55 | Pseudomonas putida | I-112 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum + Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot + red stele root rot | Elsanta | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Reduction of disease incidence after 49; 60 and 72 days | NA | NA | Y |
| Gulati et al. (2001) | Tri-trophic interactions in the rhizosphere (conference chapter) | 24: 51-55 | Erwinia herbicola | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Reduction of pathogen growth by 75% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gulati et al. (2001) | Tri-trophic interactions in the rhizosphere (conference chapter) | 24: 51-55 | Erwinia herbicola | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Reduction of pathogen growth by 35% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gulati et al. (2001) | Tri-trophic interactions in the rhizosphere (conference chapter) | 24: 51-55 | Erwinia herbicola | G-584 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum + Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot + red stele root rot | Elsanta | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Reduction of disease incidence after 49; 60 and 72 days | NA | NA | Y |
| Gulati et al. (2001) | Tri-trophic interactions in the rhizosphere (conference chapter) | 24: 51-55 | Paenibacillus marcerans | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Reduction of pathogen growth by 90% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gulati et al. (2001) | Tri-trophic interactions in the rhizosphere (conference chapter) | 24: 51-55 | Paenibacillus marcerans | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonist test | Reduction of pathogen growth by 50% | NA | NA | Y |
| Gulati et al. (2001) | Tri-trophic interactions in the rhizosphere (conference chapter) | 24: 51-55 | Paenibacillus marcerans | G-V1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum + Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot + red stele root rot | Elsanta | NA | Greenhouse | Disease incidence | Reduction of disease incidence after 60 and 72 days | NA | NA | Y |
| Mark and Cassels (1996) | Plant and Soil | 185: 233-239 | Claroideoglomus claroideum | BEG31 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Wild strawberry | Red stele root rot | Clone 25 | Y | Greenhouse | NA | Decrease in the disease severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Mark and Cassels (1996) | Plant and Soil | 185: 233-239 | Claroideoglomus claroideum | BEG31 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Wild strawberry | Red stele root rot | Clone 66 | Y | Greenhouse | NA | Decrease in the disease severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Mark and Cassels (1996) | Plant and Soil | 185: 233-239 | Claroideoglomus claroideum | BEG31 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Wild strawberry | Red stele root rot | Clone 86 | Y | Greenhouse | NA | Decrease in the disease severity | NA | NA | Y |
| Mark and Cassels (1996) | Plant and Soil | 185: 233-239 | Claroideoglomus claroideum | BEG31 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Wild strawberry | Red stele root rot | Clone 78 | N | Greenhouse | NA | No better resistance | NA | NA | N |
| Valois et al. (1996) | Applied and Environmental Microbiology | 62: 1630-1635 | Various strains of non phytopathogenic actinomycetes | EF-36; EF-39; EF-91; EF-94; EF-96; EF-14; EF-22; EF-25; EF-27; EF-34; EF-43; EF-72; EF-76; EF-97; DVD1; DVD3; DVD4; N106 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | Rubi ML200 | Raspberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | Growth inhibition | NA | NA | Y |
| Valois et al. (1996) | Applied and Environmental Microbiology | 62: 1630-1635 | Various strains of non phytopathogenic actinomycetes | EF-6; EF-13; EF-16; EF-17; EF-18; EF-29; EF-37; EF-45; EF-100; EF-101; EF-105; EF-117; EF-119; DVX2; DVX3 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | Rubi ML201 | Raspberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition | No growth inhibition | NA | NA | N |
| Valois et al. (1996) | Applied and Environmental Microbiology | 62: 1630-1635 | Various strains of non phytopathogenic actinomycetes | EF72; EF22; EF34; EF14; EF97; EF76; EF27; EF43; DVD3; EF25; DVD4 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Raspberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease index | Good effect on the disease index | EF76 was identified as Streptomyces hygroscopicus var; gledanus | NA | Y |
| Valois et al. (1996) | Applied and Environmental Microbiology | 62: 1630-1635 | Various strains of non phytopathogenic actinomycetes | N106; DVD1 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | NA | Raspberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease index | No effect on the disease index | NA | NA | N |
| Eikemo et al. (2003) | Plant Disease | 87: 345-350 | NA | NA | Acibenzolar-S-methyl | NA | Bion WG 50 | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease score | Reduction of the disease development | NA | NA | Y |
| Eikemo et al. (2003) | Plant Disease | 87: 345-350 | NA | NA | Chitosan | Produit de l'exosquelette des arthropodes (crustacés) ou de l'endosquelette des céphalopodes (calmars...) ou encore de la paroi des champignons. | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease score | Reduction of the disease development | The treatment 2 days before inoculation resulted in a higher disease score than treatment 20 days before inoculation | NA | Y |
| Eikemo et al. (2003) | Plant Disease | 87: 345-350 | NA | NA | Acibenzolar-S-methyl | NA | Bion WG 50 | Phytophthora fragariae | Fragariae | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease score | Reduction of the disease development | NA | NA | Y |
| Eikemo et al. (2003) | Plant Disease | 87: 345-350 | NA | NA | Chitosan | Produit de l'exosquelette des arthropodes (crustacés) ou de l'endosquelette des céphalopodes (calmars...) ou encore de la paroi des champignons. | NA | Phytophthora fragariae | Fragariae | Strawberry | Red stele root rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease score | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Vestberg et al. (1994) | Agricultural Science in Finland | 3: 289-295 | Funneliformis mosseae | V57 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Jonsok | Y | Greenhouse | Health index | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Vestberg et al. (1994) | Agricultural Science in Finland | 3: 289-295 | Glomus hoi | V98 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Jonsok | Y | Greenhouse | Health index | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Vestberg et al. (1994) | Agricultural Science in Finland | 3: 289-295 | Claroideoglomus claroideum | V158 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Jonsok | Y | Greenhouse | Health index | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Vestberg et al. (1994) | Agricultural Science in Finland | 3: 289-295 | Funneliformis mosseae | V57 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Jonsok | Y | Field | Health index | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Vestberg et al. (1994) | Agricultural Science in Finland | 3: 289-295 | Glomus hoi | V98 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Jonsok | Y | Field | Health index | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Vestberg et al. (1994) | Agricultural Science in Finland | 3: 289-295 | Claroideoglomus claroideum | V158 | NA | NA | NA | Phytophthora cactorum | NA | Strawberry | Crown rot | Jonsok | Y | Field | Health index | No effect | NA | NA | N |
| Baniasadipour and Bonjar (2014) | Journal of Biologica control | 28(4): 225-233 | Streptomycetes spp. B; F and S | Isolate B; F and S | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce rot | NA | NA | In vitro and green house test | In vitro inhibition assay; and disease suppression test of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum in vivo | Direct antagonistic effect of Streptomyces spp. B; F and S against Sclerotinia sclerotioru; and reduced disease severity in green house experiment | NA | NA | Yes |
| Abdullah et al. (2008) | Crop Protection | 27: 1354 - 1359 | Trichoderma harzianum | KucF010 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | White mold; sclerotinia wilt or stalk rot | NA | NA | In vitro and in vivo tests | Inhibition test on mycelia and sclerotia and in planta biocontrol assay | Inhibition of mycelia and sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum; and effective suppression of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum on infected plants | NA | NA | Yes |
| Abdullah et al. (2008) | Crop Protection | 27: 1354 - 1359 | NA | NA | NA | NA | T. harzianum (PlantShield HC) and Glicoladium virens (SoilGard) | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | White mold; sclerotinia wilt or stalk rot | NA | NA | In vitro and in vivo tests | Inhibition test on mycelia and sclerotia and in planta biocontrol assay | Inhibition of mycelia and sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum; and effective suppression of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum on infected plants | NA | NA | Yes |
| Abdullah et al. (2008) | Crop Protection | 27: 1354 - 1359 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | KucB001 and KucB002 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | White mold; sclerotinia wilt or stalk rot | NA | NA | In vitro and in vivo tests | Inhibition test on mycelia and sclerotia and in planta biocontrol assay | Inhibition of mycelia and sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum; and effective suppression of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum on infected plants | NA | NA | Yes |
| Fatouros et al. (2018) | Plant Pathology | 67: 418 - 425 | Paenibacillus alvei | K165 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce rot | Tom Thumb | NA | In vitro and field experiment | Biocontrol assay; and expression of pathogenesis-related (PR1); lipoxygenase (LOX) and ethylene response factor 1 (ERF1) genes | Suppression of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum by Paenibacillus alvei K165; and up-regulation of PR1; LOX and ERF1 | NA | NA | Yes |
| Shaw et al. (2016) | Molecular Plant Pathology | 17(9): 1425 - 1441 | Trichoderma hamatum GD12 | GD12 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Webb's Wonderful | NA | In vitro and in vivo | Transcriptional studies of Trichoderma hamatum GD12 in interaction with Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | Biocontrol potential of Trichoderma hamatum GD12 against Sclerotinia sclerotiorum involves the synthesis and secretion of antifungal compounds | NA | NA | Yes |
| Rabeendran et al. (2006) | Biological control | 39: 352 - 362 | T. hamatum (LU593; LU592; LU595 | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Field | % infection | 592: no effect; 595 good effect; 593: effect at late stage | NA | NA | Yes |
| Rabeendran et al. (2006) | Biological control | 39: 352 - 362 | T. rossicum LU596 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Effect at early stage of the infection | NA | NA | Yes |
| Rabeendran et al. (2006) | Biological control | 39: 352 - 362 | T. virens LU555; LU556 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | 555: godd effect in field; 556 no effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Rabeendran et al. (2006) | Biological control | 39: 352 - 362 | C. minitans LU112 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Good effect in field | NA | NA | Yes |
| Rabeendran et al. (2006) | Biological control | 39: 352 - 362 | Clonostachys rosea | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Effect at early stage of the infection | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitrampalam et al. (2010) | Biological control | 55(2010): 92-96 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans™ | Sclerotinia minor | NA | Lettuce | Letuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | Field | NA | Ok | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitprampalam et al. (2008) | Plant Disease | 92: 1625-1634 | C. minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans | Sclerotinia minor and sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | Field experiment | Lettuce drop disease incidence | Reduction of the disease incidence in field as noted by the number of healthy heads | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitprampalam et al. (2008) | Plant Disease | 92: 1625-1634 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Plants shield | Sclerotinia minor and sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | NA | Lettuce drop disease incidence | Reduction of the disease incidence in field as noted by the number of healthy heads | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitprampalam et al. (2008) | Plant Disease | 92: 1625-1634 | B. Subtilis | NA | NA | NA | Companion (. Subtilis) | Sclerotinia minor and sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | NA | Lettuce drop disease incidence | Reduction of the disease incidence in field as noted by the number of healthy heads | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitprampalam et al. (2008) | Plant Disease | 92: 1625-1634 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Supresevit (T. harzianum) | Sclerotinia minor and sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | NA | Lettuce drop disease incidence | Reduction of the disease incidence in field as noted by the number of healthy heads | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitprampalam et al. (2008) | Plant Disease | 92: 1625-1634 | Gliocladium virens | NA | NA | NA | Soilgard | Sclerotinia minor and sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | NA | Lettuce drop disease incidence | Reduction of the disease incidence in field as noted by the number of healthy heads | NA | NA | Yes |
| Shaw et al. (2016) | Molecular plant pathology | 17(9); 1425-1441 | Trichoderma hamatum | GD12 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum (M448) | M448 | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Webb's Wonderful | NA | Growth chamber | Plant growth | The biocontrol agent promotes plant growth when it interacts antagonistically with Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | No direct study of plant protection in this study | NA | Yes |
| Chen et al. (2016) | Frontiers in microbiology | 7; 714 | Streptomyces exfoliatus FT05W | FT05W | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | (FW598) | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Capitata | NA | Growth chamber/field | In vitro and in vivo assay Protection assay | The biocontrol agents inhibited mycelial growth of the phytopathogen by more than 75% | In vivo S.cyaneus protected lettuce from drop by 100% | NA | Yes |
| Chen et al. (2016) | Frontiers in microbiology | 7; 714 | Streptomyces cyaneus | ZEA17I | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | (FW598) | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Capitata | NA | Growth chamber/field | In vitro and in vivo assay Protection assay | The biocontrol agents inhibited mycelial growth of the phytopathogen by more than 75% | In vivo S.cyaneus protected lettuce from drop by 100% | NA | Yes |
| Rodríguez et al. (2011) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 110(5); 1177-1186 | Clonostachys rosea | BAFC3874 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | BAFC225/BAFC2232 | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Greenhouse | In vitro assay Protection assay | Clonostachys rosea strain BAFC3874 was proved to be an effective antagonist against the aggressive soil‐borne pathogen S. sclerotiorum in greenhouse experiments | The inoculation of C. rosea 48h before the pathogen allowed for the establishment of the inhibitory effects over pathogen growth | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. hamatum | TMCS-3 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | Good effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. hamatum. | TMMS-21 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | Good effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. koningii | TKMS-7 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | Good effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. koningii. | TK | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. hamatum | TMMS-16 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. hamatum. | TMMS-19 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | Good effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Gliocladium sp. | GSS-10 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. hamanum | TRMS-32 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Gliocladium sp. | ; GSS-16 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Coniothyrium sp. | CMS-23 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. harzianum | TRMS- 15 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. harzianum | TRSS-9 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Trichoderma viride | TV | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | Good effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. aureoviride | TASS | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Trichoderma sp. | TCS- I | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Chaetomium sp. | CSS-5 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. harzianum | TRCS-5 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Aspergillus sp. | AMS-20 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Fusarium sp. | FMS-26 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. harzianum | TRMS-13 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| McQuilken et al. (1997) | Biocontrol science and technology | 7: 23-36 | C. minitans | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Glasshouse and field | S. sclerotiorum viability | Ok | NA | NA | Yes |
| Adams and Fravel (1990) | Phytopathology | 80: 1120-1124 | Sporidesmium sclerotivorum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Field | Disease inceidence; S. minor survival in soil | Reduction of the incidence; especially at the highest concentration | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. asperellum | T2 | Filtrate from exudates (volatils or not) | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS10 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. hamatum | T3 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS11 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. harzianum | T6 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS12 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. asperellum | T12 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS13 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. harzianum | T14 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS14 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. hamatum | T14 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS15 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. hamatum | T19 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS16 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. asperellu | T20 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS17 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. virens | T21 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS18 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Van beneden et al. (2010) | Soil Biology and Biochemistry | 42(8); 1268-1274 | NA | NA | Lignin | NA | NA | R. solani | S001-2 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | Pot experiments | Sclerotial viability; soil microbial community structure; Ligninolytic enzyme activities | Soil-dependentreduction of sclerotial viability after lignin addition + increased mycoparasitism by Trichoderma | Changes in microbial community structure after lignin amendment | NA | Yes |
| Elias et al. (2016) | Summa Phytopathologica | 42(3); 216-221 | T. asperelloides | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor and S. sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Tainá | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Control S. minor and S. sclerotiorum in lettuce seedlings grown in Petri dishes and in pots | S. minor and S. sclerotiorum controled lettuce drop in vitro and in pot experiments (more effective against S. minor) | NA | NA | Yes |
| Elias et al. (2016) | Summa Phytopathologica | 42(3); 216-221 | T. asperellum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor and S. sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Tainá | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Control S. minor and S. sclerotiorum in lettuce seedlings grown in Petri dishes and in pots | S. minor and S. sclerotiorum controled lettuce drop in vitro and in pot experiments (more effective against S. minor) | NA | NA | Yes |
| Budge and whipps (1991) | Plant Pathology | 40(1); 59-66 | Trichoderma harzianum | HH3 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Celery and lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Glasshouses | Disease and marketable yield | C. minitans reduced the number of sclerotia recovered and spread to infect sclerotia in other plots | NA | NA | NA |
| Budge and whipps (1991) | Plant Pathology | 40(1); 59-66 | Trichoderma sp. | B1 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Celery and lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Glasshouses | Disease and marketable yield | C. minitans reduced the number of sclerotia recovered and spread to infect sclerotia in other plots | NA | NA | NA |
| Budge and whipps (1991) | Plant Pathology | 40(1); 59-66 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Celery and lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Glasshouses | Disease and marketable yield | C. minitans reduced the number of sclerotia recovered and spread to infect sclerotia in other plots | NA | NA | NA |
| Budge et al. (1995) | Biological control | 5(4); 513-522 | Coniothyrium minitans | IMI 134523 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Hudson | NA | Glasshouses | Sclerotia count; disease incidence | Reduced infection of Sclerotinia | NA | NA | Yes |
| Budge et al. (1995) | Biological control | 5(4); 513-522 | Gliocladium virens | G20 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Hudson | NA | Glasshouses | Sclerotia count; disease incidence | Reduced infection of Sclerotinia | NA | NA | Yes |
| Jones and Stewart (1997) | Proceedings of the New Zealand Plant Protection Conference | Vol. 50; pp. 154-158 | Trichoderma harzianum | C52 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Yateslake | NA | Glasshouses | Disease score | Disease reduction between 55 and 78% with T. harzianum | NA | NA | Yes |
| Jones and Stewart (1997) | Proceedings of the New Zealand Plant Protection Conference | Vol. 50; pp. 154-158 | Trcihoderma virens | TV1 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Yateslake | NA | Glasshouses | Disease score | Disease reduction between 55 and 78% with T. harzianum | NA | NA | Yes |
| Budge and whipps (2001) | Phytopathology | 91(2); 221-227 | Coniothyrium minitans | IMI 134523 | NA | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Hudson | NA | Greenhouse | Number of S. sclerotiorum infected plants; number of sclerotia present | Disease control in C. minitans with a single application of iprodione was equivalent to prophylactic sprays with iprodione every 2 weeks | NA | NA | Yes |
| Smith et al. (2013) | Journal of General Plant Pathology | 79(1); 74-85 | T. atroviride; T. koningiopsis; T. asperellum; T. spirale; T. harzianum; T. Brevicompactum and T. longibrachiatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | In vitro | Viability of Sclerotia and Sclerotia parasitism | Trichoderma asperellumTh034; T. atroviride Th002 and T. harzianum Th203 prevented germination of more than 70 % of sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum in bioassay test | NA | NA | Yes |
| Monteiro et al. (2013) | Journal of Agricultural Science | 5(4); 214 | B. subtiis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition in vitro | Reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Monteiro et al. (2013) | Journal of Agricultural Science | 5(4); 214 | B. subtiis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease control | Healthier plants for only one cultivar on three | NA | NA | Yes |
| Pane et al. (2017) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 148(3); 687-697 | NA | NA | Solanum melongena L. Extracts | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor Jagger | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Penelope | NA | In vitro + pot experiment | Sclerotinia drop disease symptoms; fungal development | Fungal development was inhibited by the extracts; reduction of disease symptoms | NA | NA | Yes |
| Pane et al. (2017) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 148(3); 687-697 | NA | NA | S. aethiopicum L. extracts | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor Jagger | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Penelope | NA | In vitro + pot experiment | Sclerotinia drop disease symptoms; fungal development | Fungal development was inhibited by the extracts; reduction of disease symptoms | NA | NA | Yes |
| Zaccardelli et al. (2020) | Agriculture | 10(2); 30 | Bacillus amyloliquesfaceiens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor and Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Rocket damping-off symptoms; mycelial growth | Mycelial growth reduction and biocontrol were observed | NA | NA | Yes |
| Zaccardelli et al. (2020) | Agriculture | 10(2); 30 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor and Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Rocket damping-off symptoms; mycelial growth | Mycelial growth reduction and biocontrol were observed | NA | NA | Yes |
| Hicks et al. (2014) | Phytopathologia Mediterranea | 53(3): 502 - 514 | Trichoderma viride | LU144 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | Green house and field trial | Plant growth promotion and disease suppression | Significant suppression of Rhizoctonia solani on potato; and increase in tuber weight | NA | NA | Yes |
| Bautista et al. (2007) | Acta Biologica Colombiana | 12(1): 19-32 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | IBUNPf 063 and IBUNPf 033 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitroand green house test | Root colonization; plant growth promotion and disease suppression | Enhanced potato growth and excellent disease suppression | NA | NA | Yes |
| Khaldi et al. (2016) | Journal of Phytopathology | 164: 40 - 51 | Penicillium; Aspergillus and Talaromyces | NA | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | Nicola | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Effect of compost and associated fungi on growth; and suppression of Rhizoctonia solani on potato | Compost and associated fungi Penicillium; Aspergillus and Talaromycesenhances potato growth and suppressed Rhizoctonia solani | NA | NA | Yes |
| Khedher et al. (2015) | Comptes Rendus Biologies | 338: 784 - 792 | Bacillus subtilis | V26 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | Spunta | NA | In vitro and green house test | Plant growth promotion and suppression of Rhizoctonia solani on potato | Enhanced plant growth promotion and significant suppression of Rhizoctonia solani by Bacillus subtilis V26 on potato | NA | NA | Yes |
| Mrabet et al. (2013) | Phytopathologia Mediterranea | 52(3): 449 - 456 | Pseudomonas reinekei | S8.Fb11 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | Spunta & Nicola | NA | In vitro and green house test + field | Plant growth promotion and suppression of Rhizoctonia solani on potato | Enhanced plant growth promotion and significant suppression of Rhizoctonia solani on potato | NA | NA | Yes |
| Tariq et al. (2010) | Brazilian Journal of Microbiology | 41: 439 - 451 | Pseudomonas spp. | StT2 and StS3 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani Khun | AG3 | Potato | Black scurf | Cardinal | NA | In vitro and green house test | Plant growth promotion and biocontrol efficacy | Display of plant growth potentials and disease suppression | NA | NA | Yes |
| Van den boogert and jager (1984) | Soil Biology and Biochemistry | 24(2); 157-164 | Verticillium biguttatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | AG3 | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitro + greenhouse + field | Soil population density; present of fungi on below ground plant parts | Relation between R. solani and V. biguttatum population dynamics | NA | NA | Yes |
| Van den boogert and jager (1985) | Soil Biology and Biochemistry | 24(2); 157-165 | Gliocladium roseum; Trichoderma hamatum andHormiactis fimicola | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | AG4 | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitro + greenhouse + field | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA |
| Grosch et al. (2005) | Canadian Journal of Microbiology | 51(4); 345-353 | Pseudomonas fluorescens B1; Pseudomonas fluorescens B2 et Serratia plymuthica B4; | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | AG-3 (isolate Ben 3) | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | Growth chamber + field | Disease severity on potato sprouts | High potential of endophytes under field conditions | NA | NA | Yes |
| Murdoch and Leach (1993) | American Potato Journal | 70(9); 625-634 | Laetisaria | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | Greenhouse | R. solani infection and population levels | Reduction of R. solani level and infection | NA | NA | Yes |
| Tsror et al. (2001) | Crop Protection | 20(2); 145-150 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | Nicola | NA | Field | Black scurf symptoms were measured | Trichoderma harzianum and nonpathogenic Rhizoctonia reduced disease symptoms | NA | NA | Yes |
| Tsror et al. (2002) | Crop Protection | 20(2); 145-151 | Nonpathogenic Rhizoctonia | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | Nicola | NA | Field | Black scurf symptoms were measured | Trichoderma harzianum and nonpathogenic Rhizoctonia reduced disease symptoms | NA | NA | Yes |
| Yao et al. (2002) | Mycorrhiza | 12(5); 235-242 | Glomus etunicatum or G. intraradices | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | AG-3 | Potato | Black scurf | Goldrush and LP89221 | NA | Greenhouse | Disease severity; mortality rate; root colonization levels; various growth parameters; and shoot mineral content | Plant responses to mycorrhizal inoculation is influenced by the cultivar | Vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi protected potato plants | NA | Yes |
| Faltin et al. (2004) | Canadian journal of microbiology | 50(10); 811-820 | Bacteria | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitro & in vivo | Antagonistic mechanisms and indole-3-acetic acid production | Strategy to select and assess antagonistic bacteria was developed | NA | NA | Yes |
| Brewer and Larkin (2005) | Crop Protection | 24(11); 939-950 | Paenibacillus polymyxa; Pseudomonas fluorescens; Penicillium sp.; Trichoderma sp.; | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani (RS31B) | RS31B | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | Greenhouses | Stem canker and black scurf symptoms were measured | L. arvalis ZH-1; R. zeae LRNE17E reduced black scarf symptoms | B. subtilis and T. virens better controled stem canker than each organism alone | NA | Yes |
| Brewer and Larkin (2006) | Crop Protection | 24(11); 939-951 | Rhizoctonia zeae; known biocontrol isolates including Laetisaria arvalis; Verticillium biguttatum; Cladorrhinum foecundissimum; and | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani (RS31B) | RS31B | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | Greenhouses | Stem canker and black scurf symptoms were measured | L. arvalis ZH-1; R. zeae LRNE17E reduced black scarf symptoms | B. subtilis and T. virens better controled stem canker than each organism alone | NA | Yes |
| Brewer and Larkin (2007) | Crop Protection | 24(11); 939-952 | Stilbella aciculosa; and commercial products of Bacillus subtilis (Kodiak); Trichoderma virens (SoilGard); and T. harzianum (RootShield). | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani (RS31B) | RS31B | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | Greenhouses | Stem canker and black scurf symptoms were measured | L. arvalis ZH-1; R. zeae LRNE17E reduced black scarf symptoms | B. subtilis and T. virens better controled stem canker than each organism alone | NA | Yes |
| Shahroki et al. (2005) | Biotechnology | 4; 132-138 | Streptomyces olivaceus | Strain 115 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani Kuhn | AG-3 | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitro | Antagonistic activity | Streptomyces olivaceus strain 115 showed strong in vitro antagonistic activity against R. solani | NA | NA | Yes |
| Wilson et al. (2008) | Plant Pathology | 57(1); 152-161 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | Isolate R11; anastomosis group (AG) 3 | Potato | Black scurf | Bintje | NA | Field | Lesions; discoloration and death of (unemerged) sprouts + severity of black scurf + number and wheight of tubers | Reduction of black scurf on progeny tubers | Reduction of mean number of progeny tubers; proportion of small (0·1–20·0 g) tubers; malformed and green‐coloured tubers | NA | Yes |
| Demirci et al. (2009) | African Journal of Biotechnology | 8(11) | Ten isolates of Verticillium biguttatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | R-99(AG 3) | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitro + in vivo | Percentage inhibition of radial growth; hyphal interactions; hyphae viability; germination of R. solani sclerotia; observation of stem canker | Reduction of growth; penetration of host cell walls;reduction of hyphae and sclerotia viabaility | Reduction of disease severity on potato sprouts | NA | Yes |
| Lahlali et Hijri (2010) | FEMS microbiology letters | 311(2); 152-159 | Alternaria longipes; Epicoccum nigrum; Phomopsis sp.; and Trichoderma atrovirid | NA | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | R14 | Potato | Black scurf | Riba | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Mycelial growth inhibition; Ability to produce volatile compounds; growth on antagonistic culture filtrates; stem lesions | T. atroviride and E. nigrum showed inhibition of mycelial growth of R. solani (+ correlated with culture filtrates) | T. atroviride and E. nigrum improved potato yield significantly and decreased the stem disease severity index of sensitive potato | NA | Yes |
| Canova et al. (2010) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 26(12); 2241-2247 | Paenibacillus sp. | IIRAC-30 | C15-lipopeptide | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitro | In vitro interactions | Mechanism used by Paenibacillus sp. IIRAC-30 to suppress R. solani was elucidated as lipopeptide production | NA | NA | Yes |
| Demirci et al. (2011) | Turkish Journal of Biology | 35(4); 457-462 | Forty-five fungal isolates obtained from sclerotia of Rhizoctonia solani on potato tubers | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani AG-3 | Isolate R-99 | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitro | Mode of inhibition; hyphal interaction | Acremonium sp.; Gliocladium viride; Paecilomyces marquandii; Paecilomyces sulphurellus; Penicillium camemberti; Penicillium expansum; Penicillium frequentans (ME-50); Penicillium nigricans; Penicillium olsonii; Penicillium phialosporum; Sporothrix sp. (MCY-4); Sporothrix schenckii; and Verticillium dahliae produced an inhibition zone in front of the R. solani colony | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aydin et al. (2011) | Anadolu | 21(2); 29-38 | Trichoderma asperellum TZ17; T. atroviride VG3; T. croceum BOZ26; T. gamsii VG47; T. hamatum ÖT16; T. harzianum LO52; T. inhamatum PT12; T. neokoningii A15; T. spirale KB13; T. strigosum LO43; T. tomentosum VG2; T. virens OT19; T. viride VG18; and G. roseum LO41 | NA | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | Greenhouse + in vitro | Viability and the formation of tuber-born sclerotia of Rhizoctonia solani | T. virens ÖT19; T. asperellum TZ17; T. viride VG18; T. strigosum LO43; T. gamsii VG47 and G. roseum LO41) good effect on plant | T. viride VG18; T. gamsii VG47; T. strigosum LO43; T. virens ÖT19; G. roseum LO41 and T. asperellum TZ17 proved to be the most effective antagonists in vitro | NA | Yes |
| Suwannarach et al. (2012) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 28(11); 3171-3177 | Muscodor cinnamomi | NA | Volatils from Muscodor cinnamomi | NA | NA | R. solani | AG-2 | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | Bird pepper; bush bean; garden pea and tomato | Dual culture volatile assay; damping-off symptoms | M. cinnamomi volatile compounds inhibited mycelial growth of pathogens | M. cinnamomi controlled damping-off symptoms after one month of planting | NA | Yes |
| Ikeda et al. (2012) | Biological Control | 60(3); 297-304 | Pythium oligandrum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | AG-3 | Potato | Black scurf | Irish Cobbler | NA | Field trial + in vitro | Disease rates of stolon; confocal laser scanning microscopic observations and interaction of P. oligandrum and R. solani | P. oligandrum hyphae colonized the sclerotia and established close contact by coiling around the R. solani hyphae present on the surface of seed tubers | P. oligandrum induced resistance against black scurf | NA | Yes |
| Donmez et al. (2015) | Acta Scientiarum Polonorum-Hortorum Cultus | 14(5); 29-40 | 73 bacteria isolated from rhizosphere of tea plants | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | Rs-pat; B-227 and B-1 | Potato and bean | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Bacterial inhibitory activity; lesions on roots and crown of potato plants | 15 bacteria strains (Bacillus subtilis (3); Bacillus cereus GC subgroup A (1); Bacillus cereus GC subgroup B (2); Citrobacter freundii (1); Enterobacter intermedius (1); Lysobacter enzymogenes (2); Pseudomonas putida biotype B (1); Acinetobacter calcoaceticus (1); Burkholderia pyrrocinia (2); Pantoea agglomerans GC subgroup C (1)) caused an inhibition zone | NA | NA | Yes |
| Saber et al. (2015) | Acta biologica hungarica | 66(4); 436-448 | B. subtilis | ATCC 11774 | Chitinase from B. subtilis | NA | NA | R. solani AG3 | NA | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | Greenhouse + in vitro | Degradation of cell wall; in vitro antagonism (+ chitinase); severity of lesions on plants | Presence of chitinase enzymes in the bacterial filtrate | In vitro inhibition + reduction of the disease incidence of stem canker and black scurf in greenhouse trials | NA | Yes |
| Khaldi et al. (2015) | J. Plant Pathol. Microbiol. | S; 3; 006 | Serratia marcescens | NA | Cell-free culture filtrates | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | Nicola | NA | In vitro + greenhouse trial | Effect on R. solani mycelial growth (bacteria + cell extract) | Antifungal properties of culture filtrate and bacteria | Reduction of disease severity under greenhouse conditions | NA | Yes |
| Yandigeri et al. (2015) | World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology | 31(8); 1217-1225 | Streptomyces vinaceusdrappus S5MW2 | S5MW2 | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | NAIMCC-F-01970 | Tomato | NA | NA | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Growth inhibition; chitinase production; plant growth promoting parameters; disease index of Rhizoctonia solani in tomato | In vitro antagonism and chitinase production | Disease reduction & growth promotion when bacteria was added with colloidal chitin | NA | Yes |
| Larkin (2016) | Crop protection | 90; 96-105 | Bacillus subtilis GB03; Burkholderia ambifaria type Wisconsin isolate J82; Trichoderma virens Gl-21; and Trichoderma harzianum strain T-22); | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | Field | Shoot emergence; incidence and severity of stem canker lesions; total and marketable weight | All treatments reduced the incidence and severity of stem canker | Soil microbial community characteristics were changed after biocontrol formulations | NA | Yes |
| Durak (2016) | AIP Conference Proceedings | Vol. 1726; No. 1; p. 020020 | 81 trichoderma isolates | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Antagonistic activity; plant height + wheight | Disease symptoms were reduced | NA | NA | Yes |
| Durak (2016) | AIP Conference Proceedings | Vol. 1726; No. 1; p. 020020 | Among which: T. harzianum; T. virens; T. asperellu and T. viride | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | NA | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Antagonistic activity; plant height + wheight | Disease symptoms were reduced | NA | NA | NA |
| Salamone et al. (2018) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 28(9); 895-900 | Clonostachys rosea | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | AG 3 | Potato | NA | NA | NA | In vitro + in vivo | Hyphal interactions and yield+ black scurf severity | Parasitic behaviour of the isolates | Significantly lower black scurf and higher yield after inoculation | NA | Yes |
| Larkin (2020) | Biological Agriculture & Horticulture | ; 1-11 | Hypovirulent R. solani | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | NA | NA | NA | Field | Crop growth; tuber yield; and disease development | Combinations including both a hypovirulent strain and GB03 seems to be most effective | NA | NA | Yes |
| Larkin (2020) | Biological Agriculture & Horticulture | ; 1-11 | Commercial B. subtilis | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | NA | NA | NA | Field | Crop growth; tuber yield; and disease development | Combinations including both a hypovirulent strain and GB03 seems to be most effective | NA | NA | Yes |
| Hussain et al. (2020) | Biocatalysis and Agricultural Biotechnology | 23; 101443 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | Culture filtrate | NA | NA | R. solani | NA | Potato | Black scurf | K. Bahar | NA | In vitro + in vivo + field | Percent growth inhibition; disease severity + incidence and yield | Inhibition of mycelium growth | Reduction in disease incidence under pot and field conditions | NA | Yes |
| Grosch et al. (2006) | Mycological Research | 110(12); 1464-1474 | T. viride | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani (RS 3; AG-3) | RS 3; AG-3 | Potato | Black scurf | Exquisa | NA | In vitro + in vivo + field | Viability of Rhizoctonia solani mycelium; germination of Rhizoctonia solani sclerotia; production of cell wall degrading enzymes; disease severity in pot experiments; yield and degree of tuber infestation in field trials | Reduction of the incidence of Rhizoctonia symptoms | NA | NA | Yes |
| Grosch et al. (2006) | Mycological Research | 110(12); 1464-1474 | T. reesei | NA | NA | NA | NA | R. solani (RS 3; AG-3) | RS 3; AG-3 | Potato | Black scurf | Exquisa | NA | In vitro + in vivo + field | Viability of Rhizoctonia solani mycelium; germination of Rhizoctonia solani sclerotia; production of cell wall degrading enzymes; disease severity in pot experiments; yield and degree of tuber infestation in field trials | Reduction of the incidence of Rhizoctonia symptoms | NA | NA | Yes |
| Baniasadipour and Bonjar (2014) | Journal of Biologica control | 28(4): 225-233 | Streptomycetes spp. B; F and S | Isolate B; F and S | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce rot | NA | NA | In vitro and green house test | In vitro inhibition assay; and disease suppression test of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum in vivo | Direct antagonistic effect of Streptomyces spp. B; F and S against Sclerotinia sclerotioru; and reduced disease severity in green house experiment | NA | NA | Yes |
| Abdullah et al. (2008) | Crop Protection | 27: 1354 - 1359 | Trichoderma harzianum | KucF010 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | White mold; sclerotinia wilt or stalk rot | NA | NA | In vitro and in vivo tests | Inhibition test on mycelia and sclerotia and in planta biocontrol assay | Inhibition of mycelia and sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum; and effective suppression of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum on infected plants | NA | NA | Yes |
| Abdullah et al. (2008) | Crop Protection | 27: 1354 - 1359 | NA | NA | NA | NA | T. harzianum (PlantShield HC) and Glicoladium virens (SoilGard) | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | White mold; sclerotinia wilt or stalk rot | NA | NA | In vitro and in vivo tests | Inhibition test on mycelia and sclerotia and in planta biocontrol assay | Inhibition of mycelia and sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum; and effective suppression of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum on infected plants | NA | NA | Yes |
| Abdullah et al. (2008) | Crop Protection | 27: 1354 - 1359 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | KucB001 and KucB002 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | White mold; sclerotinia wilt or stalk rot | NA | NA | In vitro and in vivo tests | Inhibition test on mycelia and sclerotia and in planta biocontrol assay | Inhibition of mycelia and sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum; and effective suppression of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum on infected plants | NA | NA | Yes |
| Fatouros et al. (2018) | Plant Pathology | 67: 418 - 425 | Paenibacillus alvei | K165 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce rot | Tom Thumb | NA | In vitro and field experiment | Biocontrol assay; and expression of pathogenesis-related (PR1); lipoxygenase (LOX) and ethylene response factor 1 (ERF1) genes | Suppression of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum by Paenibacillus alvei K165; and up-regulation of PR1; LOX and ERF1 | NA | NA | Yes |
| Shaw et al. (2016) | Molecular Plant Pathology | 17(9): 1425 - 1441 | Trichoderma hamatum GD12 | GD12 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Webb's Wonderful | NA | In vitro and in vivo | Transcriptional studies of Trichoderma hamatum GD12 in interaction with Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | Biocontrol potential of Trichoderma hamatum GD12 against Sclerotinia sclerotiorum involves the synthesis and secretion of antifungal compounds | NA | NA | Yes |
| Rabeendran et al. (2006) | Biological control | 39: 352 - 362 | T. hamatum (LU593; LU592; LU595 | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Field | % infection | 592: no effect; 595 good effect; 593: effect at late stage | NA | NA | Yes |
| Rabeendran et al. (2006) | Biological control | 39: 352 - 362 | T. rossicum LU596 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Effect at early stage of the infection | NA | NA | Yes |
| Rabeendran et al. (2006) | Biological control | 39: 352 - 362 | T. virens LU555; LU556 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | 555: godd effect in field; 556 no effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Rabeendran et al. (2006) | Biological control | 39: 352 - 362 | C. minitans LU112 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Good effect in field | NA | NA | Yes |
| Rabeendran et al. (2006) | Biological control | 39: 352 - 362 | Clonostachys rosea | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Effect at early stage of the infection | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitrampalam et al. (2010) | Biological control | 55(2010): 92-96 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans™ | Sclerotinia minor | NA | Lettuce | Letuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | Field | NA | Ok | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitprampalam et al. (2008) | Plant Disease | 92: 1625-1634 | C. minitans | NA | NA | NA | Contans | Sclerotinia minor and sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | Field experiment | Lettuce drop disease incidence | Reduction of the disease incidence in field as noted by the number of healthy heads | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitprampalam et al. (2008) | Plant Disease | 92: 1625-1634 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Plants shield | Sclerotinia minor and sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | NA | Lettuce drop disease incidence | Reduction of the disease incidence in field as noted by the number of healthy heads | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitprampalam et al. (2008) | Plant Disease | 92: 1625-1634 | B. Subtilis | NA | NA | NA | Companion (. Subtilis) | Sclerotinia minor and sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | NA | Lettuce drop disease incidence | Reduction of the disease incidence in field as noted by the number of healthy heads | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitprampalam et al. (2008) | Plant Disease | 92: 1625-1634 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | Supresevit (T. harzianum) | Sclerotinia minor and sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | NA | Lettuce drop disease incidence | Reduction of the disease incidence in field as noted by the number of healthy heads | NA | NA | Yes |
| Chitprampalam et al. (2008) | Plant Disease | 92: 1625-1634 | Gliocladium virens | NA | NA | NA | Soilgard | Sclerotinia minor and sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Winterhaven | Yes | NA | Lettuce drop disease incidence | Reduction of the disease incidence in field as noted by the number of healthy heads | NA | NA | Yes |
| Shaw et al. (2016) | Molecular plant pathology | 17(9); 1425-1441 | Trichoderma hamatum | GD12 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum (M448) | M448 | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Webb's Wonderful | NA | Growth chamber | Plant growth | The biocontrol agent promotes plant growth when it interacts antagonistically with Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | No direct study of plant protection in this study | NA | Yes |
| Chen et al. (2016) | Frontiers in microbiology | 7; 714 | Streptomyces exfoliatus FT05W | FT05W | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | (FW598) | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Capitata | NA | Growth chamber/field | In vitro and in vivo assay Protection assay | The biocontrol agents inhibited mycelial growth of the phytopathogen by more than 75% | In vivo S.cyaneus protected lettuce from drop by 100% | NA | Yes |
| Chen et al. (2016) | Frontiers in microbiology | 7; 714 | Streptomyces cyaneus | ZEA17I | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | (FW598) | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Capitata | NA | Growth chamber/field | In vitro and in vivo assay Protection assay | The biocontrol agents inhibited mycelial growth of the phytopathogen by more than 75% | In vivo S.cyaneus protected lettuce from drop by 100% | NA | Yes |
| Rodríguez et al. (2011) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 110(5); 1177-1186 | Clonostachys rosea | BAFC3874 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | BAFC225/BAFC2232 | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Greenhouse | In vitro assay Protection assay | Clonostachys rosea strain BAFC3874 was proved to be an effective antagonist against the aggressive soil‐borne pathogen S. sclerotiorum in greenhouse experiments | The inoculation of C. rosea 48h before the pathogen allowed for the establishment of the inhibitory effects over pathogen growth | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. hamatum | TMCS-3 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | Good effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. hamatum. | TMMS-21 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | Good effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. koningii | TKMS-7 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | Good effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. koningii. | TK | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. hamatum | TMMS-16 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. hamatum. | TMMS-19 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | Good effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Gliocladium sp. | GSS-10 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. hamanum | TRMS-32 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Gliocladium sp. | ; GSS-16 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Coniothyrium sp. | CMS-23 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. harzianum | TRMS- 15 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. harzianum | TRSS-9 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Trichoderma viride | TV | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | Good effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. aureoviride | TASS | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Trichoderma sp. | TCS- I | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Chaetomium sp. | CSS-5 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. harzianum | TRCS-5 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Aspergillus sp. | AMS-20 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | Fusarium sp. | FMS-26 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| Garcia-Garza et al. (1997) | Soil Biology and biochemistry | 29: 123-129 | T. harzianum | TRMS-13 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Ithaca | NA | Greenhouse | Infection of lettuce disk | No effect | NA | NA | No |
| McQuilken et al. (1997) | Biocontrol science and technology | 7: 23-36 | C. minitans | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Glasshouse and field | S. sclerotiorum viability | Ok | NA | NA | Yes |
| Adams and Fravel (1990) | Phytopathology | 80: 1120-1124 | Sporidesmium sclerotivorum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Field | Disease inceidence; S. minor survival in soil | Reduction of the incidence; especially at the highest concentration | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. asperellum | T2 | Filtrate from exudates (volatils or not) | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS10 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. hamatum | T3 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS11 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. harzianum | T6 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS12 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. asperellum | T12 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS13 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. harzianum | T14 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS14 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. hamatum | T14 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS15 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. hamatum | T19 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS16 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. asperellu | T20 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS17 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Aleandri et al. (2015) | Crop Protection | 67: 269-278 | T. virens | T21 | Filtrate from exudates | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | SS18 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Good growth reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Van beneden et al. (2010) | Soil Biology and Biochemistry | 42(8); 1268-1274 | NA | NA | Lignin | NA | NA | R. solani | S001-2 | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | Pot experiments | Sclerotial viability; soil microbial community structure; Ligninolytic enzyme activities | Soil-dependentreduction of sclerotial viability after lignin addition + increased mycoparasitism by Trichoderma | Changes in microbial community structure after lignin amendment | NA | Yes |
| Elias et al. (2016) | Summa Phytopathologica | 42(3); 216-221 | T. asperelloides | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor and S. sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Tainá | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Control S. minor and S. sclerotiorum in lettuce seedlings grown in Petri dishes and in pots | S. minor and S. sclerotiorum controled lettuce drop in vitro and in pot experiments (more effective against S. minor) | NA | NA | Yes |
| Elias et al. (2016) | Summa Phytopathologica | 42(3); 216-221 | T. asperellum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor and S. sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Tainá | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Control S. minor and S. sclerotiorum in lettuce seedlings grown in Petri dishes and in pots | S. minor and S. sclerotiorum controled lettuce drop in vitro and in pot experiments (more effective against S. minor) | NA | NA | Yes |
| Budge and whipps (1991) | Plant Pathology | 40(1); 59-66 | Trichoderma harzianum | HH3 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Celery and lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Glasshouses | Disease and marketable yield | C. minitans reduced the number of sclerotia recovered and spread to infect sclerotia in other plots | NA | NA | NA |
| Budge and whipps (1991) | Plant Pathology | 40(1); 59-66 | Trichoderma sp. | B1 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Celery and lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Glasshouses | Disease and marketable yield | C. minitans reduced the number of sclerotia recovered and spread to infect sclerotia in other plots | NA | NA | NA |
| Budge and whipps (1991) | Plant Pathology | 40(1); 59-66 | Coniothyrium minitans | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Celery and lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Glasshouses | Disease and marketable yield | C. minitans reduced the number of sclerotia recovered and spread to infect sclerotia in other plots | NA | NA | NA |
| Budge et al. (1995) | Biological control | 5(4); 513-522 | Coniothyrium minitans | IMI 134523 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Hudson | NA | Glasshouses | Sclerotia count; disease incidence | Reduced infection of Sclerotinia | NA | NA | Yes |
| Budge et al. (1995) | Biological control | 5(4); 513-522 | Gliocladium virens | G20 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Hudson | NA | Glasshouses | Sclerotia count; disease incidence | Reduced infection of Sclerotinia | NA | NA | Yes |
| Jones and Stewart (1997) | Proceedings of the New Zealand Plant Protection Conference | Vol. 50; pp. 154-158 | Trichoderma harzianum | C52 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Yateslake | NA | Glasshouses | Disease score | Disease reduction between 55 and 78% with T. harzianum | NA | NA | Yes |
| Jones and Stewart (1997) | Proceedings of the New Zealand Plant Protection Conference | Vol. 50; pp. 154-158 | Trcihoderma virens | TV1 | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Yateslake | NA | Glasshouses | Disease score | Disease reduction between 55 and 78% with T. harzianum | NA | NA | Yes |
| Budge and whipps (2001) | Phytopathology | 91(2); 221-227 | Coniothyrium minitans | IMI 134523 | NA | NA | NA | S. sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Hudson | NA | Greenhouse | Number of S. sclerotiorum infected plants; number of sclerotia present | Disease control in C. minitans with a single application of iprodione was equivalent to prophylactic sprays with iprodione every 2 weeks | NA | NA | Yes |
| Smith et al. (2013) | Journal of General Plant Pathology | 79(1); 74-85 | T. atroviride; T. koningiopsis; T. asperellum; T. spirale; T. harzianum; T. Brevicompactum and T. longibrachiatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | In vitro | Viability of Sclerotia and Sclerotia parasitism | Trichoderma asperellumTh034; T. atroviride Th002 and T. harzianum Th203 prevented germination of more than 70 % of sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum in bioassay test | NA | NA | Yes |
| Monteiro et al. (2013) | Journal of Agricultural Science | 5(4); 214 | B. subtiis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | NA | NA | NA | In vitro | Growth inhibition in vitro | Reduction | NA | NA | Yes |
| Monteiro et al. (2013) | Journal of Agricultural Science | 5(4); 214 | B. subtiis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia sclerotiorum | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Disease control | Healthier plants for only one cultivar on three | NA | NA | Yes |
| Pane et al. (2017) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 148(3); 687-697 | NA | NA | Solanum melongena L. Extracts | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor Jagger | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Penelope | NA | In vitro + pot experiment | Sclerotinia drop disease symptoms; fungal development | Fungal development was inhibited by the extracts; reduction of disease symptoms | NA | NA | Yes |
| Pane et al. (2017) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 148(3); 687-697 | NA | NA | S. aethiopicum L. extracts | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor Jagger | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | Penelope | NA | In vitro + pot experiment | Sclerotinia drop disease symptoms; fungal development | Fungal development was inhibited by the extracts; reduction of disease symptoms | NA | NA | Yes |
| Zaccardelli et al. (2020) | Agriculture | 10(2); 30 | Bacillus amyloliquesfaceiens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor and Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Rocket damping-off symptoms; mycelial growth | Mycelial growth reduction and biocontrol were observed | NA | NA | Yes |
| Zaccardelli et al. (2020) | Agriculture | 10(2); 30 | Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Sclerotinia minor and Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Lettuce | Lettuce drop | NA | NA | In vitro + greenhouse | Rocket damping-off symptoms; mycelial growth | Mycelial growth reduction and biocontrol were observed | NA | NA | Yes |
| Levy et al. (1988) | Plant Pathology | 37: 551-557 | Pseudomonas spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | ISR8036; ISR398 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Growth chamber /greenhouse | In vitro and in vivo activity test | Biofungicide | NA | Two leaf-stage | Yes |
| Levy et al. (1989) | Plant Pathology | 38: 564-570 | NA | NA | 1-hydroxyphenazine; chlororaphine | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | ISR8036; ISR398 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Protection assay | Biofungicide | NA | 10 days-old | Yes |
| Levy et al. (1992) | Plant Pathology | 41: 335-341 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | PMF2 | 2;4-diacetylploroglucinol | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | ST83A | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | In vitro | NA | Biofungicide | NA | NA | Yes |
| Flaishman et al. (1996) | Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions | 9: 642-645 | Pseudomonas putida | BK8661 | NA | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | NA | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Protection assay | Biofungicide | NA | 10 days-old | Yes |
| Alippi et al. (2000) | Journal of Plant Disease and Protection | 107: 155-169 | Bacillus subtilis; Bacillus cereus; Bacillus licheniformis; Bacillus pumilus; Brevibacillus laterospus; Paenibacillus polymyxa | NA | NA | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | NA | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Stage 15 (5 weeks-old) | Yes |
| Nolan and Cooke (2000) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 106: 203-207 | Drechslera teres | NA | NA | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | NA | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe antibiosis; antagonism; and induced or enhanced host resistance | NA | Growth stage 49 | Yes |
| Perello et al. (2001) | Phytoparasitica | 29: 341-351 | Stemphylium spp.; Epicoccum nigrum; Nigrospora sphaerica; Aspergillus niger; Fusarium moniliforme; Penicillium lilacinum; Chaetomium globosum; Cryptococcus sp.; Rhodotorula rubra | NA | NA | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | NA | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Stage 15 | Yes |
| Perello et al. (2002) | Journal of Phytopathology | 150: 232-243 | Paecilomyces lilacinus; Fusarium monoliform; Epicoccum nigrum; Bacillus spp.; Nigrospora sphaerica | NA | NA | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | NA | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Protection assay and in vitro antagonism | Biofungicide | NA | Five leaf-stage | Yes |
| Cordo et al. (2007) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 687-698 | Trichoderma spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | FALP00604 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Protection effect | Bioelicitor | NA | 10 days-old | Yes |
| Kildea et al. (2008) | Biological control | 47: 37-45 | Bacillus megaterium; Pseudomonas fluorescens | Bacillus megaterium: MKB135 | NA | Culture filtrate of Bacillus megaterium | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | THORN; BACK; ATHY | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Growth chamber | In vitro and in vivo activity test | Bioelicitor/biofungicide | NA | 21 days-old | Yes |
| Perello et al. (2009) | BioControl | 54: 113–122 | Trichoderma harzianum; Trichoderma koningii | Trichoderma harzianum: T1; T2; T3 and T5; Trichoderma koningii: T4 | NA | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | NA | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe biofungicide | NA | Growth stage 23; 58 | Partially |
| Shetty et al. (2009) | Journal of Experimental Botany | 60: 4287-4300 | NA | NA | Β-1;3-glucan | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | IPO323 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Effect on elicitation Protection effect | Bioelicitor | NA | Two leaf-stage | Yes |
| Maumene et al. (2015) | AFPP-Cinquième conférence internationale sur les méthodes alternatives de protection des plantes | NA | NA | NA | Chitosan | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | T01193 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse/ field | Effect on elicitation Protection effect in field | Bioelicitor and biofungicide effect | NA | Three-four leaf-stage | Yes |
| Stocco et al. (2016) | World J Microbiol Biotechnol | 1.3673611111111 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | FALP9J008; FALPLA008 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Antagonistic ability of Trichoderma against Z.tritici | Biofungicide | NA | Stage GS 1.1 (Zadoks et al.; 1974) | Partially |
| Lynch et al. (2016) | Journal of Applied Microbiology | 121: 485-494 | Lactobacillus brevis; Lactobacillus reuteri | Lactobacillus brevis: JJ2P; Lactobacillus reuteri: R2 | NA | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | 46.10; 552.11; 560.11; 563.11 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Antifungal bioassay | Biofungicide | NA | Two leaf-stage | Yes |
| Sahli et al. (2017) | Environmental Science and Pollution Research | 25: 29775-29783 | NA | NA | Effusol from Juncus maritimus | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | T01193/T02596 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | In vitro | In vitro antifungal bioassay | Biofungicide | NA | In vitro | Yes |
| Mejri et al. (2018) | Environmental Science and Pollution Research | 25: 29822-29833 | NA | NA | Lipopetides (mycosubtilin; surfactin; fengycin) from Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | T01193/T02596 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | In vitro antifungal assay | Bioelicitor and biofungicide | NA | Three leaf stage | Yes |
| Bocquet et al. (2018) | Industrial Crops and Products | 122: 290-297 | NA | NA | Co-humulone; Desmethylxanthohumol | Hop extracts and compounds | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | T02596 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | In vitro | In vitro antifungal bioassay | Biofungicide | NA | In vitro | Yes |
| Le Mire et al. (2018) | Agriculture | 8(1); 11 | NA | NA | Lipopetide (surfactin) from Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | T01187 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Effect on elicitation Protection effect | Bioelicitor | NA | Three leaf stage | Yes |
| Ors et al. (2019) | Phytopathology | 109:2033-2045 | NA | NA | A plant nutrient- and microbial (Trichoderma harzanium) protein-based extract | Foliar fertilizer based on manganese and sulfur enriched with an active complex | Nectar Céréales® | Zymoseptoria tritici | T01193 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Effect on elicitation Protection effect | Bioelicitor | NA | Three leaf stage | Yes |
| Mejri et al. (2019) | Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture | 99: 1780–1786 | NA | NA | Pyroglutamic acid; Salicylic acid-conjugated target derivatives | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | T02596 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Antigungal effect; effect on elicitation | Elicitor | NA | Three leaf stage | Yes |
| Le Mire et al. (2019) | Phytopathology | 109: 409-417 | NA | NA | Algal extracts (λ-carrageenan; Spirulina platensis); CpG-ODN; glycine betaine; and ergosterol | NA | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | T01187 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Effect on elicitation Protection effect | Bioelicitor | NA | Three leaf stage | Yes |
| Mejri et al. (2020) | Plant Disease | In press; doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-05-20-1106-RE | NA | NA | Saccharin | Artificial sweetener | NA | Zymoseptoria tritici | T02596 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Effect on elicitation and priming Protection effect | Bioelicitor | NA | Three leaf stage | Yes |
| Somai-Jemmali et al. (2020) | Journal of Applied Phycology | 32: 3387–3399 | NA | NA | Ascophyllum nodosum extract-based product | Ascophyllum nodosum extract; water-soluble nitrogen; free amino acids; vitamins; and coadjuvant) | Dalgin Active® | Zymoseptoria tritici | T01193 or St-08-46 | Wheat | Septoria tritici blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Effect on elicitation Protection effect | Bioelicitor | NA | Three leaf stage | Yes |
| Reignault et al. (2001) | New Phytologist | 149: 519-529 | NA | NA | Trehalose | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | MPEBgt1 | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Phytotrons | Effect on elicitation; Induction of resistance | Bioelicitor | NA | 2 weeks-old | Yes |
| Vechet et al. (2005) | Plant Soil Environ | 51: 469-475 | NA | NA | NA | Extracts of Curcuma longa; Zingiber officinale; Reynoutria sacchaliensis; Quercus robur | NA | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber/ small plots | Induction of resistance | Bioelicitor | NA | 20 days-old | Yes |
| Randoux et al. (2006) | Phytopahology | 96: 1278-1286 | NA | NA | NA | Ethanolic plant extract from leaves of Reynoutria sachalinensis | Milsana | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | MPEBgt1 | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Biofungicide effect; Effect on elicitation of defense response | Bioelicitor | NA | 10 days-old | Yes |
| Renard-Merlier et al. (2007) | Phytochemistry | 68: 1156-1164 | NA | NA | Iodus 40; salicylic acid; heptanoyl salicylic ; trehalose | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | MPEBgt1 | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Phytotrons | Biofungicide effect; Effect on elicitation of defense response | Bioelicitor | NA | 10 days-old | Partially |
| Serfling et al. (2007) | Phytopathology | 97: 523-531 | Piriformospora indica | NA | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | KF01 | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Bioelicitor/priming | NA | Stage 39 and 55 (BBCH scale) | Partially |
| Vechet et al. (2009) | Crop Protection | 28: 151-154 | NA | NA | Benzothiadiazole; salicylic acid; glycine betaine | Water extracts of Quercus robur; Reynoutria sachalinensis; Curcuma longa; Zingiber officinale | NA | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Induction of resistance; fungicidal activities | NA | (not mentioned) | Yes |
| Randoux et al. (2010) | Phytopathology | 100: 1352-1363 | NA | NA | Oligogalacturonides | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Effect on elicitation; Induction of resistance | Bioelicitor | NA | 10 days-old | Yes |
| Curtis et al. (2012) | Field Crops Research | 134: 36-46 | Rhodosporidium kratochvilovae; Cryptococcus laurentii; Aureobasidium pullulans | Rhodosporidium kratochvilovae: UM350; Cryptococcus laurentii: UM108; Aureobasidium pullulans: LS30 | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber/field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; maybe elicitation of biochemical defense responses | NA | 20 days-old (growth chamber); stage 39 (BBCH scale) (field) | Yes |
| Mustafa et al. (2013) | Communications in agricultural and applied biological sciences | 78: 467-478 | Rhizophagus irregularis; Glomus mosseae | Rhizophagus irregularis: DAOM197198; Glomus mosseae from MycAgro lab | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Room culture | Protection effect | Bioelicitor | NA | 6 weeks-old | Yes |
| Gao et al. (2015) | BioMed Research International | 2015: 462645 | Bacillus subtilis | E1R-J | NA | NA | NA | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Two leaf-stage | Yes |
| Mustafa et al. (2016) | Mycorrhiza | 26: 685-697 | Rhizophagus irregularis; Funneliformis mosseae; Glomus sp. | Rhizophagus irregularis: DAOM197198; Funneliformis mosseae: FR140 | NA | NA | Glomus sp.: Solrize® | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Protective efficiency | Bioelicitor | NA | 6 weeks-old | Yes |
| Cai et al. (2017) | Microbiological Research | 196: 89-94 | NA | CC09 | NA | Bioactive metabolites of Bacillus velenzis | NA | Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Powdery mildew | NA | NA | Field | Prevention efficacy (%) | Biofungicide | NA | Two leaf-stage | Yes |
| Kempf and Wolf (1989) | Phytopathology | 79: 990-994 | Erwinia herbicola | B247 | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia recondita f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Brown rust / Orange leaf rust | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Ability to suppress P. recondita | Biofungicide | NA | One leaf-stage | Yes |
| Flaishman et al. (1996) | Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions | 9: 642-645 | Pseudomonas putida | BK8661 | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia recondita f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Brown rust / Orange leaf rust | NA | NA | Humidity chambers | Protection assay | Biofungicide | NA | 10 days-old | Yes |
| Eldoksch et al. (2001) | Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences | 4: 550-553 | Trichoderma harzianum; Bacillus subtilis; Saccharomyces cerevisiae; | Bacillus subtilis: Rhizo-N | NA | Natural oil; peppermint oil; jojoba oil; eucalyptus oil and chenopodium oil | NA | Puccinia recondita f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Brown rust / Orange leaf rust | NA | NA | Moist chamber/field | Treatment effectiveness (%) | Biofungicide | NA | Booting stage | Yes |
| Sheroze et al. (2002) | Plant Pathology Journal | 1: 51-53 | Verticillium lecanii; Paecilomyces fumosoroseus; Beauveria bassiana; Cladosporium clodosporioides; Metarrhizium anisopliae | NA | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia recondita f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Brown rust / Orange leaf rust | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Coagulation and disintegration of cytoplasm of rust spores | NA | Before and after flag leaf stage | Yes |
| Dingle and McGee (2003) | Mycological Research | 107: 310-316 | Chaetomium spp.; Phoma spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia recondita f. sp. tritici | Pathotype 104-2;3;6 and 7 | Wheat | Brown rust / Orange leaf rust | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Antagonistic effect against P. recondita f. sp. tritici | Unknown; could be bioelicitors of defense response | NA | 3 weeks-old | Yes |
| Sheroze et al. (2003) | International Journal of Agricultural & Biology | 5: 83-85 | Verticillium lecanii; Paecilomyces fumosoroseus; Beauveria bassiana; Cladosporium clodosporioides; Metarrhizium anisopliae | NA | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia recondita f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Brown rust / Orange leaf rust | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Two leaf-stage | Yes |
| Li et al. (2013) | Crop Protection | 43: 201-206 | Bacillus subtilis | E1R-j | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia recondita f. sp. tritici | CYR32 | Wheat | Brown rust / Orange leaf rust | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Seven days-old | Yes |
| Zhan et al. (2014) | PLoS ONE | 9: e111484 | Cladosporium cladosporioides | CGMCC 7.175 | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia recondita f. sp. tritici | CYR32 | Wheat | Brown rust / Orange leaf rust | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Hyperparasitism | NA | 10 days-old | Yes |
| El-Sharkawy et al. (2015) | Plant Pathology Journal | 14: 182-188 | Trichoderma harzianum; Streptomyces viridosporus | NA | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia triticina | NA | Wheat | Brown rust / Orange leaf rust | NA | NA | Moist chamber/field | Incubation period; latent period; clorophyll content; leaf rust severity (%) | Unknown; could be biofungicide effect | NA | Seven days-old; 60 days-old | Yes |
| Pang et al. (2016) | BioControl | 61: 207-219 | Pseudomonas putida | JD204 | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Stripe rust / Yellow rust / Glume rust | NA | NA | Field | Control efficacy (%) | Unknown; could be both biofungicide effect and bioelicitor of resistance genes | NA | NA | Partially |
| Singh et al. (2016) | Indian Phytopath | 69: 357-362 | Pseudomonas fluorescens; Bacillus subtilis | Pseudomonas fluorescens: Pf3; Bacillus subtilis: Bs1 | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici | 38S102; 47S102; 70S69; 46S102; 46S119; 78S84 | Wheat | Stripe rust / Yellow rust / Glume rust | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; could be antibiosis | NA | 45-55 days-old | Yes |
| Reiss and Jorgensen (2017) | Crop Protection | 93: 1-8 | Bacillus subtilis | QST713 | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Stripe rust / Yellow rust / Glume rust | NA | NA | Field/Semi-field trial | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Stage 33 | Yes |
| Zheng et al. (2017) | Frontiers in Microbiology | 0.38263888888889 | Alternaria alternata | CPA001 | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici | CYR32 | Wheat | Stripe rust / Yellow rust / Glume rust | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Biocontrol effect | Hyperparasitism | NA | 10 days-old | Yes |
| Shabana et al. (2017) | Egyptian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences | 4: 67–73 | NA | NA | NA | Plant extracts: garlic; clove; garden quinine; pepper; anthi mandhaari; black cumin; wheat cedar and neem | NA | Puccinia triticina | NA | Wheat | Brown rust / Orange leaf rust | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Control efficacy (%) | Biofungicide | NA | Seven days-old | Yes |
| El-Sharkawi et al. (2018) | Physiological and molecular Plant Pathology | 103: 84-91 | Trichoderma harzianum; Trichoderma viride; Rhizophagus irregularis; Funneliformis mosseae; Rhizoglomus clarum; Gigaspora margarita; Gigaspora gigantea | Trichoderma harzianum: HL1; Trichoderma viride: HL5 | NA | NA | NA | Puccinia graminis f.sp. tritici | NA | Wheat | Black rust / Black stem rust / Stem rust of wheat | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | 60 days-old | Yes |
| Alippi et al. (2000) | Journal of Plant Disease and Protection | 107: 155-169 | Bacillus subtilis; Bacillus cereus; Bacillus licheniformis; Bacillus pumilus; Brevibacillus laterospus; Paenibacillus polymyxa | NA | NA | NA | NA | Cochliobolus sativus | NA | Wheat | Spot blotch / Root and foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Stage 15 (5 weeks-old) | Yes |
| Perello et al. (2001) | Phytoparasitica | 29: 341-351 | Stemphylium spp.; Epicoccum nigrum; Nigrospora sphaerica; Aspergillus niger; Fusarium moniliforme; Penicillium lilacinum; Chaetomium globosum; Cryptococcus sp.; Rhodotorula rubra | NA | NA | NA | NA | Cochliobolus sativus | NA | Wheat | Spot blotch / Root and foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe antagonism | NA | Stage 15 | Yes |
| Monaco et al. (2004) | World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology | 20: 285-290 | Trichoderma harzianum; Trichoderma koningii | NA | NA | NA | NA | Cochliobolus sativus | NA | Wheat | Spot blotch / Root and foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Antagonism effect | Antagonism | NA | Flowering stage | Partially |
| Salehpour et al. (2005) | Plant Pathology Journal | 4: 85-90 | Trichoderma viride; Trichoderma harzianum | Trichoderma viride: T122 and MO; Trichoderma harzianum: T194 and M | NA | NA | NA | Cochliobolus sativus | NA | Wheat | Spot blotch / Root and foot rot | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; maybe induction of resistance and antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Behdani et al. (2012) | International Journal of Agriculture and Crop Sciences | 4: 483-488 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | K16; K14; S5; G7 and P3 | NA | NA | NA | Cochliobolus spicifer | NA | Wheat | Foot rot / Leaf blight | NA | NA | Greenhoue/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis and antagonism | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Perello et al. (2013) | Journal of Plant Protection Research | 2.2111111111111 | NA | NA | NA | Garlic juice | NA | Cochliobolus sativus | NA | Wheat | Spot blotch / Root and foot rot | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Eken and Yuen (2014) | Romanian Agricultural Research | 31: 309-314 | Lysobacter enzymogenes; Rhizoctonia sp. | Lysobacter enzymogenes: C3; Rhizoctonia: BNR-8-2 | NA | NA | NA | Cochliobolus sativus | NA | Wheat | Spot blotch / Root and foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe antagonism and induction of systemic resistance | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Kang t al (2018) | Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions | 31: 623-632 | Bacillus velezensis | CC09 | NA | NA | NA | Cochliobolus sativus | NA | Wheat | Spot blotch / Root and foot rot | NA | NA | Light chamber | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | 2leaf-stage | Yes |
| Pfender (1988) | Phytopathology | 78: 1254-1258 | Limonomyces roseipellis; Trichoderma koningii | Limonomyces roseipellis: 3T163 and 6T207 | NA | NA | NA | Pyrenophora tritici-repentis | NA | Wheat | Tan spot / Yellow leaf blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Antagonism effect | Antagonism | NA | Flowering stage | Yes |
| Biles and Hill (1988) | Phytopathology | 78: 656-659 | Trichoderma harzianum | T95 and ATCC60850 | NA | NA | NA | Cochliobolus sativus | NA | Wheat | Spot blotch / Root and foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; could be antagonism; hyperparasitism; or antibiosis | NA | 4-6 leaf-stage | Yes |
| Pfender et al. (1993) | Phytopathology | 83: 371-375 | Limonomyces roseipellis; agonomycete; Laetisaria arvalis; Pithomyces chartarum | Limonomyces roseipellis: 3T163; agonomycete Sterile II | NA | NA | NA | Pyrenophora tritici-repentis | NA | Wheat | Tan spot / Yellow leaf blotch | NA | NA | Field | Antagonism effect | Hyperparasitism; maybe antibiosis and antagonism | NA | Wheat strow | Partially |
| Mandal et al. (1999) | Indian Phytopath | 52: 39-43 | Chaetomium globosum; Talaromyces flavus; Trichoderma hamatum; Trichoderma pseudokoningii; Trichoderma reesei; Trichothecium roseum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Cochliobolus sativus | NA | Wheat | Spot blotch / Root and foot rot | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Antagonism effect | Mycoparasitism; maybe antibiosis | NA | 3-4 leaf stage | Yes |
| Alippi et al. (2000) | Journal of Plant Disease and Protection | 107: 155-169 | Bacillus subtilis; Bacillus cereus; Bacillus licheniformis; Bacillus pumilus; Brevibacillus laterospus; Paenibacillus polymyxa | NA | NA | NA | NA | Pyrenophora tritici-repentis | NA | Wheat | Tan spot / Yellow leaf blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Stage 15 (5 weeks-old) | Yes |
| Perello et al. (2001) | Phytoparasitica | 29: 341-351 | Stemphylium spp.; Epicoccum nigrum; Nigrospora sphaerica; Aspergillus niger; Fusarium moniliforme; Penicillium lilacinum; Chaetomium globosum; Cryptococcus sp.; Rhodotorula rubra | NA | NA | NA | NA | Pyrenophora tritici-repentis | NA | Wheat | Tan spot / Yellow leaf blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe antagonism | NA | Stage 15 | Yes |
| Perello et al. (2003) | Crop Protection | 22: 1099-1106 | Trichoderma harzianum; Trichoderma aureoviride; Trichoderma koningii | NA | NA | NA | NA | Pyrenophora tritici-repentis | NA | Wheat | Tan spot / Yellow leaf blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; maybe antibiosis or mycoparasitism | NA | Stage 15 | Yes |
| Aggarwal et al. (2004) | Mycopathologia | 157: 369-377 | Chaetomium globosum | Cg-1; Cg-2; Cg-3; Cg-4; Cg-5 and Cg-6 | NA | NA | NA | Cochliobolus sativus | NA | Wheat | Spot blotch / Root and foot rot | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Biocontrol effect | Antifungal compounds | NA | 21 days-old | Yes |
| Perello et al. (2008) | BioControl | 53: 895-904 | Trichoderma spp. | T4; T5; T6; T7 and T8 | NA | NA | NA | Pyrenophora tritici-repentis | NA | Wheat | Tan spot / Yellow leaf blotch | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; maybe bioelicitor of sytemic resistance | NA | Stage 23; 58 | Yes |
| Perello and Dal Bello (2011) | Annals of Applied Biology | 158: 267-274 | Trichoderma harzianum | Th1 and Th2 | NA | NA | NA | Pyrenophora tritici-repentis | NA | Wheat | Tan spot / Yellow leaf blotch | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe bioelicitor of systemic resistance | NA | Stage 14 | Yes |
| Perello et al. (2013) | Journal of Plant Protection Research | 2.2111111111111 | NA | NA | NA | Garlic juice | NA | Pyrenophora tritici-repentis | NA | Wheat | Tan spot / Yellow leaf blotch | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Larran et al. (2016) | Biological Control | 92: 17–23 | Alternaria alternata; Bacillus sp.; Chaetomium globosum; Cladosporum herbarum; Epicoccum nigrum; Fusarium sp.; Penicillium sp.; Paecilomyces lilacinus; Rhodotorula rubra; Trichoderma hamatum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Pyrenophora tritici-repentis | NA | Wheat | Tan spot / Yellow leaf blotch | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; maybe biofungicide | NA | Stage 15 | Yes |
| Alippi et al. (2000) | Journal of Plant Disease and Protection | 107: 155-169 | Bacillus subtilis; Bacillus cereus; Bacillus licheniformis; Bacillus pumilus; Brevibacillus laterospus; Paenibacillus polymyxa | NA | NA | NA | NA | Alternaria triticimaculans | NA | Wheat | Leaf blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | Stage 15 (5 weeks-old) | Yes |
| Perello et al. (2001) | Phytoparasitica | 29: 341-351 | Stemphylium spp.; Epicoccum nigrum; Nigrospora sphaerica; Aspergillus niger; Fusarium moniliforme; Penicillium lilacinum; Chaetomium globosum; Cryptococcus sp.; Rhodotorula rubra | NA | NA | NA | NA | Alternaria triticimaculans | NA | Wheat | Leaf blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe antagonism | NA | Stage 15 | Yes |
| Monaco et al. (2004) | World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology | 20: 285-290 | Trichoderma harzianum; Trichoderma koningii | NA | NA | NA | NA | Alternaria alternata | NA | Wheat | Black point | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Antagonism effect | Antagonism | NA | Flowering stage | Partially |
| Johnsson et al. (1998) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 104: 701-711 | Pseudomonas chlororaphis | MA 342 | NA | NA | NA | Stagonospora nodorum | NA | Wheat | Glume blotch of wheat English Leaf and glume blotch / Node canker / Septoria leaf spot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe antibiosis and antagonism | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Nolan and Cooke (2000) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 106: 203-207 | Drechslera teres | NA | NA | NA | NA | Stagonospora nodorum | NA | Wheat | Glume blotch of wheat English Leaf and glume blotch / Node canker / Septoria leaf spot | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe antibiosis; antagonism; and induced or enhanced host resistance | NA | Growth stage 49 | Yes |
| Choi et al. (2009) | The Plant Pathology Journal | 25: 165-171 | Acremonium strictum | BCP | NA | NA | NA | Botrytis cinerea | NA | Wheat | Brownish-grey mildew / Grey mould | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Mycoparasitsm and antibiosis | NA | 1-4 weeks | No |
| McManus et al. (1993) | Plant Disease | 77: 1012-1015 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | 2-79 | NA | NA | NA | Tilletia laevis | NA | Wheat | Bunt / Smooth-spored bunt / Stinking smut of wheat | NA | NA | In vitro/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Hökeberg et al. (1997) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 103: 25-33 | Pseudomonas spp. | MA 342 | NA | NA | NA | Tilletia caries | NA | Wheat | Common bunt / Rough-spored bunt / Stinking smut | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Johnsson et al. (1998) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 104: 701-711 | Pseudomonas chlororaphis | MA 342 | NA | NA | NA | Tilletia caries; Tilletia contraversa | NA | Wheat | Common bunt / Rough-spored bunt / Stinking smut | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe antibiosis and antagonism | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Borgen (1998) | Fifth International Conference on Kyusei Nature Farming Bangkok Thailand | 201-206 | Effective microorganisms | EM1 | Acetic acid | Skimmed milk powder | NA | Tilletia caries | NA | Wheat | Common bunt / Rough-spored bunt / Stinking smut | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Maybe antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Borgen and Davanlou (2000) | Journal of Crop Production | 3: 157-171 | Streptomyces griseoviridis; Pseudomonas chlororaphis; Effective microorganisms; Trichoderma harzianum; Gliocladium roseum | Streptomyces griseoviridis: K61; Pseudomonas chlororaphis: MA 342; Gliocladium roseum: IK726 | Lactic acid bacteria (Lactobacillus acidophilus; Bifidobacterium bifidus; Streptococcus thermophillus) | Liquid manure; milk powder; compost; garden compost; thermo compost; rumen juice | NA | Tilletia caries | NA | Wheat | Common bunt / Rough-spored bunt / Stinking smut | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown | NA | Seeds trated | Yes |
| El-Naimi et al. (2000) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 106: 433-437 | NA | NA | NA | Skimmed milk; hucket (local skimmed milk); wheat flour | NA | Tilletia caries; Tilletia laevis | NA | Wheat | Common bunt | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Increase of antagonistic microorganisms; maybe antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Borgen (2004) | Seed Testing International | No.128 | NA | NA | NA | Juice of Canabis sativa; Eucalyptus globulus; Thuja sinensis; Datura stramonium; oil of Eucalyptus; Pinus; meal of Thuja sinensis; Picea glauca | NA | Tilletia caries | NA | Wheat | Common bunt / Rough-spored bunt / Stinking smut | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Yolageldi and Turhan (2005) | Phytoparasitica | 33: 327-333 | Cylindrocarpon olidum var. olidum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Tilletia laevis | NA | Wheat | Bunt / Smooth-spored bunt / Stinking smut of wheat | NA | NA | In vitro / field | Inhibition/Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe antagonism | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Sholberg et al. (2006) | Canadian Journal of Plant Science | 86: 839-843 | NA | NA | Acetic acid | NA | NA | Tilletia caries and Tilletia laevis | Tilletia tritici: T-1; T-6; T-13 and T-19; Tilletia laevis: L-7 and L16 | Wheat | Bunt | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Maybe biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Agarwal and Nagarajan (1992) | Journal of Biological Control | 6: 114-115 | Trichoderma viride; Trichoderma harzianum; Trichoderma koningii; Gliocladium virens; Gliocladium roseum; Gliocladium catenulatum; Gliocladium diliquescens; Gliocladium penicilloides; Bacillus subtilis | NA | NA | NA | NA | Ustilago segetum var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Loose smut | NA | NA | NA | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism | NA | Seed and soil treated | Partially |
| Singh et al. (2000) | Journal of Biological Control | 14: 35-38 | Trichoderma viride | NA | NA | NA | NA | Ustilago segetum var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Loose smut | NA | NA | NA | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism | NA | Seed and soil treated | Yes |
| Singh and Maheshwari (2001) | Indian Phytopathology | 54: 457-460 | Trichoderma viride; Trichoderma harzianum; Pseudomonas fluorescence; Gliocladium virens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Ustilago segetum var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Loose smut | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; maybe antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Kumar and Singh (2004) | Journal of Phytological Research | 17: 51-56 | Azotobacter chroococcum; Pseudomonas striata | NA | NA | NA | NA | Ustilago segetum var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Loose smut | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | - | NA | Seeds treated | No |
| Gupta and Maheswari (2007) | Seed Borne Diseases: Ecofriendly management | Pp. 163-170 | Trichoderma viride; Trichoderma harzianum; Pseudomonas fluorescence; Gliocladium virens | NA | NA | NA | NA | Ustilago segetum var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Loose smut | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; maybe antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Tao et al. (2014) | Biocontrol Science and Technology | 24: 901-924 | Endophytic wheat bacterial strains | 58-2-1 and 37-1 | NA | NA | NA | Urocystis tritici | NA | Wheat | Flag smut | NA | NA | Rainfed field | Biocontrol efficacy | Unknown; could be bioelicitors of defense response and antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Fernandez (1992) | Soil Biol Biochem | 24: 1031-1034 | Trichoderma harzianum | NA | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | NA | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; maybe antibiosis or competition | NA | Residues of wheat | Yes |
| Fulgueira et al. (1996) | Mycopathologia | 134: 137-142 | Streptomyces spp. | C/33-6 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium tricinctum; Fusarium graminearum | Fusarium tricinctum: NRRL 3299; Fusarium graminearum: CEREMIC 136/92 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | - | NA | Spikes treated | No |
| Khan et al. (2001) | Plant Disease | 85: 1253-1258 | Bacillus subtilis; Bacillus amyloliquefaciens; Cryptococcus spp.; Cryptococcus nodaensis; yeasts | NA | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | Z-3639 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe antagonism | NA | 8 weeks-old | Yes |
| Bujold and Paulitz (2001) | Plant Disease | 85: 977-984 | Microsphaeropsis sp. | P130A | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | DAOM 178148 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; maybe antibiosis or competition | NA | Anthesis (growth stage 45-Zadok's scale) | Partially |
| Dal Bello et al. (2002) | World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology | 18: 627–636 | Trichoderma spp.; Rhizosphere bacterial strains | NA | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | NA | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism and antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Schisler et al. (2002) | Plant Disease | 86: 1350-1356 | Bacillus subtilis; Cryptococcus sp.; Crypococcus nodaensis | Bacillus subtilis: AS 43.3 and AS 43.4; Cryptococcus sp.: OH 71.4 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | Z-3639 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Geenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe antagonism | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Takenaka et al. (2003) | Phytopathology | 93: 1228-1232 | NA | MMR2; 3; 7; 10; 14; 15; 19; 21; IFO32559 and OPU425 | NA | Cell wall proteins of Pythium oligandrum | NA | Fusarium graminearum | S1 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Elicitation of defense responses | NA | Anthesis | Yes |
| Johansson et al. (2003) | Plant Pathology | 52: 219-227 | Bacterial isolates | NA | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium culmorum | S141 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Glasshouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; could be antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Khan et al. (2004) | Biological Control | 29: 245-255 | Bacillus subtilis; Cryptococcus ssp.; Cryptococcus nodaensis; yeast | Bacillus subtilis: AS 43.3; AS 43.4 and OH 131.1; Cryptococcus ssp.: OH 71.4 and OH 181.1; yeast: OH 72.4; Cryptococcus nodaensis: OH 182.9 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | Z-3639 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism | NA | Soil treated | Yes |
| Nourozian et al. (2006) | Songklanakarin Journal of Science and Technology | 28: 29-38 | Bacillus subtilis; Pseudomonas fluorescens; Streptomyces sp. | Bacillus subtilis 71; Pseudomonas fluorescens biov1 strain 32; Streptomyces sp. strain 3 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | 79-3 and 165 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe induction of host resistance | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Palazzini et al. (2007) | Crop Protection | 26: 1702-1710 | Bacillus spp.; Paenibacillus spp.; Streptomyces spp.; Brevibacillus spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | RC276 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; antibiosis | NA | 12 weeks-old | Partially |
| Serfling et al. (2007) | Phytopathology | 97: 523-531 | Piriformospora indica | NA | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium culmorum | GU75 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Could be bioelicitor of defense responses | NA | Stage 39 and 55 (BBCH scale) | Partially |
| Roberti et al. (2008) | Plant Science | 175: 339-347 | Clonostachys rosea | 47 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium culmorum | 17 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Induction of defense responses | NA | 6 days-old | Yes |
| Palazzini et al. (2009) | Biological Control | 51: 370-376 | Bacillus subtilis; Brevibacillus sp. | Bacillus subtilis: RC 218; Brevibacillus sp.: RC 263 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | RC276 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; antibiosis | NA | Anthesis stage | Yes |
| Xue et al. (2009) | Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology | 31: 169-179 | Clonostachys rosea | ACM941 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | DAOM 178148; DAOM 212678 and DAOM 232369 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe antagonism | NA | Anthesis (greenhouse); 2-3 weeks before anthesis (field) | Yes |
| Khan and Doohan (2009) | Biological Control | 48: 42-47 | Pseudomonas fluorescens; Acinetobacter sp.; Pseudomonas frederiksbergensis; Chryseobacterium sp. | Pseudomonas fluorescens: MKB100; MKB158 and MKB249; Acinetobacter sp.: MKB121; Pseudomonas frederiksbergensis: MKB202; Chryseobacterium: MKB277 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium culmorum | FCF200 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe antagonism and induction resistance | NA | Growth stage 65 (mid-anthesis) | Yes |
| Schisler et al. (2011) | Plant Pathology Journal | 10: 128-137 | Cryptococcus aureus; Cryptococcus flavescens | Cryptococcus aureus: OH71.4 and OH181.1; Cryptococcus flavescens: OH182.9 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | Z-3639 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Could be biofungicide effect | NA | 7-8 weeks | Yes |
| Crane et al. (2012) | Phytopathology | 103: 146-155 | Bacillus amyloliquefaciens | TrigoCor | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | Gz014 NY98 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | 8weeks-old (greenhouse); anthesis stage (field) | Partially |
| Matarese et al. (2012) | Microbiology | 158: 98-106 | Trichoderma spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum; Fusarium culmorum | NA | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | In vitro assays | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; mycoparasitism; and may bioelicitor of defense responses | NA | 4 cm-long pieces | Partially |
| Palazzini et al. (2013) | Plant Pathology | 62: 859-866 | Clonostachys rosea | 016 and1457 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium avenaceum; Fusarium culmorum; Fusarium graminearum; Fusarium langsethiae; Fusarium poae; Fusarium sporotrichioides; Fusarium verticillioides | Fusarium avenaceum: IPO 29-3; T187; Fusarium culmorum: PD 90-283; Fusarium graminearum: 88/790 and KRC6; Fusarium langsethiae: PRI 07-01; Fusarium poae: 93-1780; Fusarium sporotrichioides: ITEM 3596; Fusarium verticillioides: RC2096 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism | NA | Stalk pieces 10-12 cm long containing crown and first node | Partially |
| Wachowska et al. (2013) | Biological Control and Technology | 23: 1110-1122 | Sphingomonas | S 11 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium culmorum | Fc 38 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Unknown | NA | End of flowering (BBCH 69) | No |
| Forrer et al. (2014) | Toxins | 6: 830-849 | NA | NA | Tannic acid | Botanical compounds: Rheum palmatum; Frangula alnus and Galla chinensis | NA | Fusarium spp. | Fusarium graminearum: 0407; 0410 and 9915; Fusarium crookwellense: 9703 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Climate chamber/field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect and may be bioelicitor of defense response | NA | GS 63-65 (mid-anthesis) in field experiments | Yes |
| Orzali et al. (2014) | Seed Science and Technology | 42: 132-149 | NA | NA | Chitosan | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | ER1481 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Effect on elicitation | Bioelicitor of defense response | NA | Seeds treated; first leaf-stage | Yes |
| Wachowska & Glowacka (2014) | BioControl | 59: 635-645 | Aureobasidium pullulans | Ap 1 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium culmorum | Fc 38 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Antagonistic effect against F. culmorum | Biofungicide effect | NA | BBCH 61/65 (beggining and full flowering stage) | Yes |
| Xue et al. (2014) | Biological Control | 73: 2-7 | Clanostachys rosea | CLO-1 (ACM941) | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | DAOM 178148; 212678 and 232369 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | ZGS 65 (anthesis stage) | Yes |
| Dunlap et al. (2015) | Plant Gene | 2: 1-9 | Bacillus subtilis; Cryptococcus flavescens | Bacillus subtilis: OH 131.1; Cryptococcus flavescens: OH 182.9 3C | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | Z-3639 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | 7-9 weeks-old (anthesis stage) | Yes |
| Pan et al. (2015) | Mycotoxin Research | 31: 137-143 | Endophytic bacterial strains | NA | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | FgC03.001; FgC03.002; FgC03.003; FgP03.001; FgP03.002; FgSJ03.001; FgSJ03.002; FgS03.001; FgS03.002; FgRN03.001 and FgRN03.006 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; antagonism; maybe induction of resistance | NA | ZGS 65 (anthesis stage) | Yes |
| Wang et al. (2015) | Microbiological Research | 177: 34-42 | Pseudomonas fluorescens; Pseudomonas aeruginosa; Pseudomonas azotoformans; Pseudomonas lemoignei; Pantoea sp.; Ochrobactrum sp.; Enterobacter sp.; Myroides sp.; Acinetobacter sp.; Bacillus cereus; Bacillus subtilis; Stenotrophomas maltophilia | NA | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | GF1117 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis and antagonism | NA | Second-leaf stage | Yes |
| Palazzini et al. (2016) | Biological Control | 94: 56-61 | Bacillus subtilis; Brevibacillus sp. | Bacillus subtilis: RC 218; Brevibacillus sp.: RC 263 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | RC276; KRC7 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Anthesis stage (50% of the heads at the flowring stage - Feekes stage 10.5.2-10.5.3) | Yes |
| Palazzini et al. (2016) | Microbiological Research | 192: 30-36 | Bacillus subtilis | RC 218 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | RC276; KRC8 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Anthesis stage (50% of the heads at the flowring stage - Feekes stage 10.5.2-10.5.3) | Yes |
| Zalila-Kolsi et al. (2016) | Microbiological Research | 192: 148-158 | Bacillus amyloliquefasciens; Bacillus subtilis; Paenibacillus polymyxa | Bacillus amyloliquefasciens: BLB369; Bacillus subtilis: BLB277; Paenibacillus polymyxa: BLB267 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | ISPAVE 271 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Lounaci et al. (2016) | Phytopathologia Mediterranea | 55: 355-365 | Paenibacillus polymyxa | SGK2 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum; Fusarium culmorum; Fusarium verticillioides | NA | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | NA | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism (competition for iron); formation of biofilms; maybe antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Palazzini et al. (2018) | Letters in Applied Microbiology | 66: 434-438 | Bacillus velezensis; Brevibacillus sp.; Streptomyces sp. | Bacillus velezensis: RC 218; Brevibacillus sp.: RC 263; Streptomyces sp.: RC 87B | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | NA | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | In vitro assays | Tolerance of the biocontrol agents to fungicides | - | NA | NA | Partially Tolerant; But Could Be Combined With Biocontrol Agents |
| Palazzini et al. (2018) | Toxins | 10: 88 | Bacillus velezensis; Streptomyces albidoflavus | Bacillus velezensis RC 218; Streptomyces albidoflavus RC 87B | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium graminearum | RC 276 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Anthesis stage (greenhouse and field) | Yes |
| Scherbakova et al. (2018) | Pathogens | 7: 61 | Fusarium sambucinum | FS-94 | NA | NA | NA | Fusarium culmorum; Fusarium avenaceum; Fusarium graminearum; Fusarium sporotrichioides; Fusarium oxysporum; Fusarium gibbosum | Fusarium culmorum: OR-02-37; Fusarium avenaceum: Br-04-60; Fusarium graminearum: FG-30; Fusarium sporotrichioides: KRT-12-1; Fusarium oxysporum: KF-1713-4; Fusarium gibbosum: KU-8-4 | Wheat | Fusarium head blight | NA | NA | In vitro assays/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; and maybe bioelicitor of defense responses | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Hökeberg et al. (1997) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 103: 25-33 | Pseudomonas spp. | MA 342; MA 250 | NA | NA | NA | Microdochium nivale | NA | Wheat | Foot rot / Head blight /Pink snow mould / Seedling blight / Snow blight / Snow mould | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Johnsson et al. (1998) | European Journal of Plant Pathology | 104: 701-711 | Pseudomonas chlororaphis | MA 342 | NA | NA | NA | Microdochium nivale | NA | Wheat | Foot rot / Head blight /Pink snow mould / Seedling blight / Snow blight / Snow mould | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe antibiosis and antagonism | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Diamond and Cooke (2003) | Crop Protection | 22: 99-107 | Microdochium nivale (Non-pathogenic) | NA | NA | NA | NA | Microdochium nivale | NA | Wheat | Foot rot / Head blight /Pink snow mould / Seedling blight / Snow blight / Snow mould | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Biocontrol effect | Unknown | NA | Early anthesis | Yes |
| Johansson and Gehardson (2003) | Plant Pathology | 52: 219-227 | Bacterial isolates | NA | NA | NA | NA | Microdochium nivale | S141 | Wheat | Foot rot / Head blight /Pink snow mould / Seedling blight / Snow blight / Snow mould | NA | NA | Glasshouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism; could be antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Palazzini et al. (2013) | Plant Pathology | 62: 859-866 | Clonostachys rosea | 016; 1457 | NA | NA | NA | Microdochium nivale | 766 | Wheat | Foot rot / Head blight /Pink snow mould / Seedling blight / Snow blight / Snow mould | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism | NA | Stalk pieces 10-12 cm long containing crown and first node | Yes |
| Lounaci et al. (2016) | Phytopathologia Mediterranea | 55: 355-365 | Paenibacillus polymyxa | SGK2 | NA | NA | NA | Microdochium nivale | NA | Wheat | Foot rot / Head blight /Pink snow mould / Seedling blight / Snow blight / Snow mould | NA | NA | NA | Biocontrol effect | Antagonism (competition for iron); formation of biofilms; maybe antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Islam et al. (2007) | African Crop Science Conference Proceedings | 8: 2079-2082 | Trichoderma harzianum | GT-1 | NA | NA | NA | Athelia rolfsii | NA | Wheat | Collar rot / Foot rot / Sclerotial blight / Seedling blight / Southern blight / southern stem rot | NA | NA | Field | Biocontrol effect | Unknown | NA | Soil treated | Yes |
| Serfling et al. (2007) | Phytopathology | 97: 523-531 | Piriformospora indica | NA | NA | NA | NA | Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides | Phh31/3 | Wheat | Eyespot | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Could be bioelicitor of defense responses | NA | Stage 39 and 55 (BBCH scale) | Partially |
| Kim et al. (1997) | Phytopathology | 87: 551-558 | Bacillus spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Pythium spp. | NA | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Growth chamber/field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Milus (1997) | Plant Disease | 81: 180-184 | Pseudomonas fluorescens; Bacillus sp.; Pseudomonas aureofaciens | Pseudomonas fluorescens: 2-79; Bacillus sp.: L324; Pseudomonas aureofaciens: Q29Z-80; Q2-87; Q65C-80; 30-84 and Ap-9 | NA | NA | NA | Pythium irregulare; Pythium torulosum strain; Pythium graminicola | Pythium irregulare: 127-2; Pythium torulosum: 109-2; Pythium graminicola: P-1 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Growth chamber/field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treatd | Yes |
| Abdelzaher (2004) | Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection | 37: 147-159 | Gliocladium roseum; Trichoderma harzianum | Gliocladium roseum MA110 strain E1-U108; Trichoderma harzianum MU510 strain E1-U615 | NA | NA | NA | Pythium diclinum | NA | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Growth illuminated chamber | Biocontrol effect | Mycoparasitism; maybe antibiosis | NA | Seedlings | Yes |
| Mazzola et al. (2007) | Phytopathology | 97: 1348-1355 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | SS101 and 10.24 (mutant) | NA | NA | NA | Pythium spp. | NA | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe bioelicitors of defense responses | NA | Seeds treated; 21 days-old seedling | Yes |
| Meyer et al. (2010) | Applied and Environmental Microbiology | 76: 6196-6204 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | CHA0 and KD | NA | NA | NA | Pythium ultimum | NA | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe biofungicide effect | NA | Seedlings | Yes |
| Mavrodi et al. (2012) | Biological Control | 62: 93-102 | Pseudomonas fluorescens; Pseudomonas chlororaphis; Pseudomonas vranovensis; Pseudomonas borealis; Pseudomonas syringae; Pseudomonas marginalis; Pseudomonas mandelii; Pseudomonas poae; Pseudomonas putida | NA | NA | NA | NA | Pythium ultimum; Pythium irregulare | Pythium ultimum: 0900119; Pythium irregulare: 0900101 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect (antibiosis) | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Worasatit et al. (1994) | Mycological Research | 98: 1357-1363 | Trichoderma koningii | 1.11; 1.16; 1.18; 1.20; 1.31 and 2.15 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | 409 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Stephens et al. (1993) | Soil Biology and Biochemistry | 25: 1477-1484 | Aporrectodea trapezoides | NA | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | 410 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Unknown; maybe by soil disturbance; antagonism;or predation | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Kim et al. (1997) | Phytopathology | 87: 551-558 | Bacillus spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | AG-8 C-1 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Growth chamber/field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Ryder et al. (1999) | Soil Biology and Biochemistry | 31: 19-29 | Bacillus cereus; Bacillus subtilis | Bacillus cereus: A47 and M22; Bacillus subtilis: B908 and B931 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | AG-8 21 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Duffy (2000) | Crop Protection | 19: 21-25 | Pseudomoanas fluorescens | 2-79R | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | C-1 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Huang et al. (2004) | FEMS Microbiology Ecology | 49: 243-251 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | Q8r1-96 (recombinant strain) | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | AG-8 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Coombs et al. (2004) | Biological Control | 29: 359–366 | Streptomyces spp.; Microbispora spp.; Nocardioides spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | In vitro assay; glasshouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | - | Yes |
| Barnett et al. (2006) | Australian Journal of Soil Research | 44: 331-342 | Pantoea agglomerans; Exiguobacterium acetylcum ; Microbacteria | Pantoea agglomerans: TCV14; Exiguobacterium acetylcum: CM18; Microbacteria: CM-6 and CM-7 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | AG-8 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Pots | Biocontrol effect | Suppression of root infecion by pathogen | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Fatima et al. (2009) | African Journal of Biotechnology | 8: 219-225 | Azotobacter; Azospirillum | Azotobacter: WPR-42 and WPR-51; Azospirillum: WM-3 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | NA | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect (antibiosis) | NA | 2 weeks-old | Yes |
| Mavrodi et al. (2012) | Biological Control | 62: 93-102 | Pseudomonas fluorescens; Pseudomonas chlororaphis; Pseudomonas vranovensis; Pseudomonas borealis; Pseudomonas syringae; Pseudomonas marginalis; Pseudomonas mandelii; Pseudomonas poae; Pseudomonas putida | NA | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani; Rhizoctonia oryzae | Rhizoctonia solani: AG-8 C1; Rhizoctonia oryzae: 0801387 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect (antibiosis) | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Yin et al. (2013) | Applied and Environmental Microbiology | 79: 7428-7438 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | AG-8 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Could be biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Eken and Yuen (2014) | Romanian Agricultural Research | 31: 309-314 | Lysobacter enzymogenes; Rhizoctonia sp. | Lysobacter enzymogenes: C3; Rhizoctonia: BNR-8-2 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | AG-4 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe antagonism and induction of systemic resistance | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Xu et al. (2014) | FEMS Microbiol Letter | 354: 142-152 | Bacillus cereus | 0-9 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia cerealis | HD-6 | Wheat | Sharp eye-spot | NA | NA | Incubation chamber | Biocontrol effect | Biofilm formation | NA | Seeds treatd | Yes |
| Yang et al. (2014) | Phytopathology | 104: 248-256 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | HC1-07 | NA | NA | NA | Rhizoctonia solani | AG-8 | Wheat | Root rot / Steam root / Damping-off | NA | NA | Incubation chamber/field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Thomashow and Weller (1988) | Journal of Bacteriology | 170: 3499-3508 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | 2-79 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | In vitro assay; growth chamber | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | 3-4 weeks-old | Yes |
| Simon (1989) | Soil Biology and Biochemistry | 21: 323-326 | Trichoderma koningii | IMI 308475 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Maybe antibiosis and antagonism | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Ryder and Rovira (1993) | Soil Biology and Biochemistry | 25: 311-320 | Pseudomonas fluorescens; Pseudomonas spp. | Pseudomonas fluorescens: 2-79 and Pf5 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | 8 | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Glasshouse/in vitro assay | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Pierson and Weller (1994) | Phytopathology | 84: 940-947 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | 2-79; Q2-87; Q1c-80; Q65c-80; Q8d-80; Q29z-80; Q72a-80; Q69c-80; Q88-87 and Q128-87 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | R3-111a-1 and SCS | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Growth chamber/greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Mazzola et al. (1995) | Applied and Environmental Microbiology | 61: 2554-2559 | Pseudomonas fluorescens; Pseudomonas chlororaphis | Pseudomonas fluorescens: 2-79 and Q2-87; Pseudomonas chlororaphis: 30-84 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Duffy et al. (1995) | Plant Disease | 79: 907-911 | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. graminis; Pseudomonas chlororaphis; Pseudomonas fluorescens; Pseudomonas putida; Pseudomonas fluorescens-putida | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. graminis: TX1; Pseudomonas chlororaphis: 30-84; Pseudomonas fluorescens: Q2-87; Q65c-80; Q1c-80; 2-79 and Q29z-80; Pseudomonas putida: Q8d-80; Pseudomonas fluorescens-putida: Q69c-80 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Growth chamber/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; maybe antagonism | NA | Seeds treated | Partially |
| Duffy et al. (1996) | Phytopathology | 86: 188-194 | Trichoderma koningii; Pseudomonas chlororaphis; Pseudomonas fluorescens; Pseudomonas putida ; Pseudomonas fluorescens-putida | Pseudomonas chlororaphis: 30-84; Pseudomonas fluorescens: Q2-87; Q1c-80; 2-79 and Q29z-80; Pseudomonas putida: Q8d-80; Pseudomonas fluorescens-putida: Q69c-80 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; antagonism; mycoparasitism | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Kim et al. (1997) | Phytopathology | 87: 551-558 | Bacillus spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Growth chamber/field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Ryder et al. (1999) | Soil Biology and Biochemistry | 31: 19-29 | Pseudomonas corrugata; Pseudomonas putida | Pseudomonas corrugata: 2140; Pseudomonas putida: 879 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | 8 | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Duffy (2000) | Crop Protection | 19: 21-25 | Pseudomoanas fluorescens | 2-79R | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | MV115 | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Coombs et al. (2004) | Biological Control | 29: 359–366 | Streptomyces spp.; Microbispora spp.; Nocardioides spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | B-100; C-3201; 8 and 17916 | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | In vitro assay; glasshouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Sari et al. (2007) | Journal of Phytopathology | 155: 720-727 | Bacillus pumilus | 7 km | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Glasshouse | Biocontrol effect | Bioelicitor of defense response and biofungicide effect | NA | 3-4 weeks-old | Yes |
| Nasraoui et al. (2007) | Tunisian Journal of Plant Protection | 2: 35-46 | Bacillus spp.; Burkholderia spp.; Pseudomonas spp.; Xanthomonas spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | Ggt r3-IIIa-1 | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Sari et al. (2008) | Plant Production Science | 11: 298-306 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | CHA0 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Bioelicitor of defense response | NA | 3-4 weeks-old | Yes |
| Liu et al. (2009) | Biological Control | 49: 277-285 | Bacillus subtilis | E1R-j | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | 9826 | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis; induction of defense responses | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Barret et al. (2009) | Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions | 22: 1611-1623 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | Pf29Arp | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | IV-26/00 | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Incubator | Biocontrol effect | Bioelicitor of defense response and biofungicide effect | NA | 7days-old | Partially |
| Liu et al. (2011) | Journal of Pest Science | 84: 257–264 | Endophytic bacterial strains | NA | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse/field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Shirzad et al. (2012) | Journal of Plant Pathology | 94: 621-628 | Tichoderma atroviride; Pseudomonas fluorescens | Tichoderma atroviride: P1; Pseudomonas fluorescens: Z7; B119; P4; P6 and P21 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Growth chamber | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Duran et al. (2014) | Biology and Fertility of Soils | 50: 983-990 | Acinetobacter spp.; Bacillus spp.; Klebsiella spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | In vitro assays | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | NA | Yes |
| Yang et al. (2014) | Phytopathology | 104: 248-256 | Pseudomonas fluorescens | HC1-07 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Incubation chamber/field | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Yang et al. (2015) | Biological Control | 85: 52-58 | Bacillus subtilis | YB-05 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | GGT-007 | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Zhang et al. (2017) | Letters in Applied Microbiology | 65: 512-519 | Bacillus spp. | NA | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide effect | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Yang et al. (2018) | Biological Control | 118: 1-9 | Bacillus subtilis | YB-57 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | GGT-007 | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Greenhouse | Biocontrol effect | Antibiosis (lipopeptides) | NA | Seeds treated | Yes |
| Kang et al. (2018) | Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions | 31: 623-632 | Bacillus velezensis | CC09 | NA | NA | NA | Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici | NA | Wheat | Take-all / Whiteheads / Foot rot | NA | NA | Light chamber | Biocontrol effect | Biofungicide | NA | 2 leaf-stage | Yes |
Are you sure?
Please confirm deletion. There is no undo!
